Tag Archives: sell

WHERE TO SELL BASEBALL CARDS NJ

Leave a reply

One of the best places to sell baseball cards in NJ is at local card shops that specialize in trading cards. These shops are a great option because they have experience evaluating collections and will be able to give you a fair cash offer or take cards on consignment. Some of the largest and most reputable card shops in NJ that would be good options include Sports Card Express in Wall Township, Frank’s Cards and Collectibles in Chatham, and MVP Sports Cards in Rockaway.

These shops employ experts who closely follow the baseball card market and can accurately assess the value of individual cards as well as complete collections. They have the necessary equipment and supplies to safely package and store cards. As a buyer and seller of cards, the shop also has a large existing customer base that may be interested in purchasing the cards from the shop. You’ll want to take your cards in person to get evaluated, as shops are unlikely to offer pricing opinions over email or phone without seeing the physical cards.

Another viable option is to consign your cards with reputable auction houses such as Goldin Auctions or Robert Edwards Auctions, both based in New Jersey. These companies specialize in high-end trading card and memorabilia auctions. They will carefully catalog your cards, handle all aspects of the auction process, market the sale, and handle payments. The advantage is potential exposure to serious collectors worldwide who participate in the auctions. Consignment comes with auction fees that can amount to 20% or more of the final sale price.

You’ll also want to research past sale prices for comparable cards on the major online auction sites like eBay and PWCC Marketplace to help determine accurate value. Once you have estimates, you can decide to sell individual premium cards yourself online while taking other common cards to a local shop. For rarer, valuable cards, working with a respected auction house may make the most sense.

Selling at local card shows and conventions throughout NJ is another viable option. Major annual shows like the Collectors Universe Authenticated Sports Memorabilia & Card Show in Edison offer tables where you can display and directly interact with other collectors and dealers. You’ll need to research upcoming show schedules well in advance, and be prepared with supplies to safely showcase cards.

Regardless of where cards are sold, it’s important to only work with reputable, insured businesses and individuals. Take the time to research a company’s history, customer reviews, and any important licenses or accreditations before handing over valuable collections. Also, when possible, obtain estimated values for cards in writing to protect yourself in transactions. Taking clear photos of cards front and back and maintaining paperwork trails can help resolve any potential issues down the road. With diligence, any of these recommended options can help sellers find a fair price and good new homes for their New Jersey baseball card collections.

WHERE DO THEY SELL BASEBALL CARDS NEAR ME

Leave a reply

Local card shops and hobby stores are often the best places to buy baseball cards if you want to browse a wide selection in person. These shops will carry new packs, boxes and sets of cards as well as individual cards, autographs, memorabilia and vintage items. They offer the experience of digging through collections and making discoveries. Many card shops specialize specifically in baseball cards and will have knowledgeable staff that can help you find what you’re looking for or provide trading and grading services. They may also host card shows, tournaments and special events in their store.

To find local card shops in your area, you can do an online search for “baseball card shop near me” or check directories like the Baseball Card Shop Locator. Popular national chains like Local Card Shop, Heroes and Fantasma usually have multiple locations across regions so it’s worth checking if there’s one near you. Be sure to call ahead or check business websites and social media pages of independent shops for their current inventory levels and hours, as inventory and staffing issues due to the pandemic have affected some local businesses.

If you don’t have a local card shop conveniently located close by, big box hobby stores like Hobby Lobby and Michaels typically carry a decent selection of new baseball cards and supplies if they’re an option. Sports stores like Dick’s Sporting Goods and model stores may also have a card aisle worth browsing through for packs and supplies, though their selections won’t be as specialized as a dedicated card shop.

Major retail stores like Walmart and Target usually stock the most popular current baseball card sets, boxes and sports memorabilia in their trading card sections. You won’t have as much vintage and high-end selection compared to a card shop but their price and availability convenience makes them a decent place to find packs if you’re just looking to rip or collect the current year’s releases. Check with your local stores what days of the week they restock trading cards.

Online retailers have become a major force in the baseball card market in recent years, given their scale and selection. Websites like eBay, Amazon, Steel City Collectibles and daCardWorld allow you to browse an immense variety of individual vintage and modern cards, autographed memorabilia, unopened wax packs and boxes from sellers around the world. The variety is unparalleled but do your research on sellers as there are risks of deception, so stick with highly rated stores if possible. Delivery times will vary versus instant gratification of an in-store purchase.

Card shows are another fun way to search for cards without needing to rely on local shops, and the variety of vendors gathered under one roof often results in great deals. Sports card and memorabilia shows travel around the country on a rotating schedule, usually hosted on weekends at convention centers, hotel ballrooms or fairgrounds. Entrance fees are usually nominal, and browsing tables of vendors yields opportunities to find older singles, full sets and complete collections at reasonable prices compared to eBay. Show schedules are published online in advance.

In addition to those venues focused primarily on selling baseball cards, keep an eye out for opportunities where cards might turn up unexpectedly – places like flea markets, antique malls, coin and collectibles shops where some vendors may have scattered individual baseball cards or lots mixed in. Estate and garage sales can also occasionally yield dusty forgotten shoeboxes of treasures if you search patiently. Neighborhood Facebook buy/sell groups are another source for local listings. You never know where persistence might uncover a rare find!

With so many options from local shops to national retailers both online and in-person, with a bit of searching anyone can enjoy acquiring baseball cards whether pursuing a lifelong hobby or just looking to add to a burgeoning collection. Happy hunting as you support both local small businesses and grow your own baseball card collection! Let me know if you need any other recommendations.

DOES GOODWILL SELL BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

While individual Goodwill stores may vary in their inventory and selection, in general Goodwill does not focus on selling baseball cards as a major part of their business model and retail experience. Goodwill is a nonprofit organization that operates over 3,300 stores across the United States and 11 other countries. Their main goal is job training and placement services rather than being a dedicated collectibles retailer.

That being said, baseball cards can and do occasionally end up in Goodwill stores through donations and make their way onto the sales floor. Since Goodwill relies entirely on donated items to stock their stores, what inventory they receive can vary greatly depending on what the local community is donating. Sometimes people clean out their attics, basements, or storage units and donate old sports card collections without really knowing their value. Other times collectors may donate duplicate cards they no longer want.

So while Goodwill isn’t seeking out baseball card donations specifically or setting aside display space specifically for cards, individual store managers have discretion over what donated items to accept and put out for sale. It’s certainly possible that on any given day a Goodwill store could have a box of old baseball cards mixed in with other used books, movies, toys and clothing. Finding sports cards is usually more hit-or-miss compared to stopping at a dedicated card shop.

Some tips for anyone wanting to check their local Goodwill for potential baseball card finds include visiting frequently, at least once a week, to increase chances of seeing any donated cards before they sell. It also helps to get to know managers and volunteers who process donations – they may alert you if they know a large sports card collection just came in. Weekday mornings tend to be best, before donations get picked over. Explore all areas of the store too, not just specific trading card display racks, as loose packs or boxes of cards can end up mixed in with other donated items.

The flip side is that since Goodwill doesn’t specially target card collectors, their sorting and pricing procedures may not always give maximum value to what is donated. Cards could end up in the general kids’ toy section priced very low, not realizing their true worth. And if Goodwill volunteers aren’t card experts themselves, it’s possible valuable singles or sets could be overlooked amongst less valuable common cards. Proper sorting, grading and price guides simply aren’t Goodwill’s emphasis the way they are at specialized collectible shops.

Still, with some hunting and luck, Goodwill shopping provides a budget-friendly way for casual collectors to potentially find interesting vintage cards or starters for beginner sets – and help support Goodwill’s mission in the process. While it’s risky to count on steady or large card supplies, pop-culture treasures do surface in Goodwill’s ever-changing used goods selection now and then. So taking a look through your local store every so often is worth sports fans’ while, you never know what surprise finds might be nestled amongst the thrift store racks.

While Goodwill isn’t primarily focused on baseball card sales, their reuse and recycling business model means related donations dosometimes end up on shelves – offering bargain hunters and collectors occasional chances to see what undiscovered treasures pop up. Consistent browsing increases odds of success for anyone hoping to build collections or find interesting vintage items on a budget through their local Goodwill store.

HOW TO SELL BASEBALL CARDS FOR TOP DOLLAR

Leave a reply

The baseball card market can be very lucrative if you know how to properly sell your cards. There are many collectors and dealers looking to buy cards for less than their true value. To get top dollar for your baseball card collection, it’s important to do your research, prepare your cards well, and leverage the best selling platforms and strategies.

Start by taking inventory of your entire baseball card collection. Carefully sort cards by player, year, brand (Topps, Bowman, etc.), and condition. Take clear, high-quality photos of each rare and valuable card. Do research on recent eBay and auction house sales to get a sense of fair estimated values for each card based on its attributes. Note any identifying markings, flaws or issues that could impact value.

Once you understand what you have, it’s time to shore up the physical condition and appeal of the cards. Any worn, dirty or damaged cards may need to be cleaned. For valuable vintage cards, use a soft-bristled brush and distilled water only – no chemicals. Plastic sleeves and toploaders can protect the surfaces. Consider sending elite vintage cards to a professional grading service like PSA or BGS. Graded cards in high grades often fetch 5-10x+ prices compared to raw counterparts.

Now you’re ready to showcase your collection. Listing individual cards on eBay is a direct way to access the biggest pool of buyers. Taking beautiful photos against a neutral backdrop and describing every detail is crucial. As with any online sale, pack and ship cards securely and promptly. Graded cards can also be consigned to major auction houses like HeritageAuctions.com. Their advertising and collector databases provide maximum exposure.

For collection-level sales, local card shops and shows offer direct access to avid collectors. Their buyer pools tend to be smaller. A new alternative is online collection marketplaces like BaseballCardExchange.com or PWCCMarketplace.com – they allow you to list your entire holdings with a single inventory upload and provide escrow payment protection.

To maximize prices, time your sale strategically. Major sports card conventions like the National and large vintage/modern card shows often see the most competition between eager buyers. Selling right after a highly publicized sport milestone like a record-breaking performance can also increase interest. Consider breaking your collection into themed lots focused on a player, team, set, or era to improve salability.

Once cards are listed, engage actively with potential buyers. Answer questions promptly and provide extra photos upon request. Negotiate deals patiently while holding out for your price targets. Remember – the true gem cards are scarce and demand often outstrips supply for collection-worthy pieces of baseball history. With care, research, and proper exposure of what you have to offer, you’ll be well positioned to find the right buyers willing to pay top dollar for your baseball card collection. Executing this comprehensive strategy will help you avoid leaving any money on the table as you transition your assets to their next appreciative homes.

HOW TO ORGANIZE AND SELL BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

The first step in organizing and selling your baseball card collection is to take inventory of what cards you have. Go through your entire collection and make a list of every player and year of each card. This can be done on a spreadsheet on your computer. The spreadsheet should include the player’s name, year, team, and condition of the card. Properly taking inventory will ensure you know exactly what you have to sell.

Once your inventory is complete, it’s time to start organizing. The best way is by year, then by team within each year. Put all cards from 1952 together, all from 1953 together, and so on. Within each year, group cards by team alphabetically. For example, all 1952 Brooklyn Dodgers cards together, then 1952 Chicago Cubs cards, and so on. Store the organized cards in baseball card pages, sleeves, or boxes. Organizing them in this manner makes it easy to find specific cards when someone asks about a player.

The next step is grading the condition of each card. Use a standard 1-10 grading scale where 1 is poor condition and 10 is mint. Inspect each card closely under good lighting and consider factors like centering, corners, edges and surface to determine the grade. Write the grade on the inventory sheet next to each card listing. Accurately grading condition is crucial for determining value.

Once organized and graded, it’s time to research values. The best way is to search recently sold listings on eBay for comparable graded cards from the same year, team and player. Note the prices those similar cards sold for to get a sense of estimated value. You can also check price guides from companies like Beckett, but eBay “sold” prices will give you the most accurate recent market values.

Now that your cards are organized, graded and valued, it’s time to decide how you want to sell them. Your best options are individually on eBay, via a local card shop consignment, or through an online group/forum marketplace. Selling individually on eBay gives you the highest potential profit but requires more work listing each item. Consignment through a local shop is easier but they will take a sizeable cut (usually 35-50%.) Online forums like Collectors Universe Marketplace allow batch selling to other serious collectors.

If selling individually, take quality photos of each card, clearly show the front and back and grade. Write detailed listing descriptions mentioning the player, year, team, set, grade and recently sold comparables. List similar to other recently sold items to attract buyers. For consignment, work with your local shop on sorting cards by predicted sale price to maximize your percentage earned. Bundle common/lower value cards to move them.

Proper organizing, grading, researching values and selective listing/selling tactics are key to maximizing profits from your baseball card collection. With some work upfront you can sell cards strategically for the best pricing and realize the most value possible compared to just selling the full collection in bulk. Taking the time to do it right will lead to higher overall returns in the long run.

In the end, organizing and selling baseball cards takes effort but can be very rewarding. Not only can you earn money from cards sitting in boxes, you may uncover valuable gems that could fund new hobbies or investments. More importantly, the process allows you to relive memories from your collection while also introducing a new generation of fans to the players and teams of yesterday. With the proper approach, card collecting can be both a nostalgic experience and a worthwhile side business.

DOES WALMART NEIGHBORHOOD MARKET SELL BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

While the main supercenter-style Walmart stores often have a larger selection and devote more shelf space to trading cards like baseball cards, many Walmart Neighborhood Market locations do offer a smaller assortment of sports and non-sports trading cards for customers. The availability and selection can vary significantly between individual stores.

Walmart Neighborhood Market is Walmart’s line of smaller format stores that are designed to fit into urban and suburban areas where there may not be space for a larger supercenter. They aim to provide consumers with an expanded grocery selection along with some general merchandise products in a more compact store size compared to a supercenter. Since space is more limited, they cannot carry the same massive and diverse product assortments as full-size Walmarts.

When it comes to trading cards, Neighborhood Market stores typically have a much smaller dedicated section for cards than what you would find in the main Walmart stores. They usually only have space to stock a basic selection of recently released sports trading card products rather than maintaining an expansive back catalog of older series and sets. The amount of space given to cards can be as small as just one or two short shelves or peg board strips near the front of the store.

The baseball card selection at Walmart Neighborhood Markets tends to focus primarily on the latest and most popular sets from manufacturers like Topps, Upper Deck, Panini, and Donruss that were released within the past 6-12 months. Examples of sets they may carry include the current year’s versions of Topps Series 1, Topps Series 2, Topps Chrome, Topps Update, Stadium Club, and Allen & Ginter. Some stores may also have a small assortment of value packs and discounted repack boxes from the recent years.

It’s less common for Neighborhood Market locations to stock older baseball card releases unless they are incredibly sought after sets. You’re not likely to find back inventory dating back multiple years. Their allotted space is really geared towards customers being able to readily find the most up-to-date cards on the market at any given time rather than browsing a deep catalog.

In addition to baseball cards, some stores may carry a limited selection of the most recent NFL, NBA, soccer, wrestling, and non-sports trading card products as well. Again selections here are much more condensed compared to a large Walmart. The supply also depends on the time of year – during the peak seasons for each sport is when that sport’s cards are most likely to be in stock.

Another thing to note is that not every single Walmart Neighborhood Market will necessarily carry trading cards. The individual store managers have some discretion over precisely what general merchandise categories they choose to allocate shelf space to based on customer demand patterns in their local area. So cards may not be present at smaller or lower volume locations where selling space is absolutely maximized for groceries.

There is no centralized online tool for checking trading card inventory at Walmart Neighborhood Markets like there is on Walmart.com for regular supercenters. Customers would need to call individual stores ahead of time or visit in person to confirm what, if any, trading card products are currently being carried. Product selection and availability also does fluctuate frequently as new shipments are received and older items sell out.

While baseball cards and other trading cards can be found at some Walmart Neighborhood Markets, the selection offered is usually much more limited compared to larger Walmart stores due to space constraints. Patrons seeking a wide variety of older cards released over multiple years from baseball to other sports and hobbies may be better served visiting a supercenter location instead if possible. But Neighborhood Markets can provide a convenient option for locally browsing and purchasing the latest newly-issued card series and products in a smaller format store.

WHERE TO SELL BASEBALL CARDS NEAR HOUSTON TX

Leave a reply

Sportscards Plus – This is perhaps the largest and most well-known sports card and memorabilia shop in the Houston area. They have multiple locations including ones in Katy, Spring, Humble, and Pearland. Sportscards Plus offers cash or store credit for your baseball cards, depending on their condition and value. They have a team of experts who can properly assess the worth of even the most vintage and rare cards. They maintain an extensive online and in-store inventory so you can easily see what cards are in high demand and what they may be willing to pay.

Play It Again Sports – With locations all throughout Greater Houston, Play It Again Sports is ideal for someone looking to sell baseball cards without having to travel too far. While they aren’t primarily a sports card shop, they do purchase individual cards or entire collections. They provide fair cash offers and can help you unload cards quickly if needed. Just be aware their payment amounts may not be as high as specialized card shops since reselling vintage sports items is just part of their larger business model.

Houston Card and Comic Show – This is a weekly collector’s event held every Sunday from 9 AM to 3 PM at the Safari Texas Ranch event venue located northwest of Houston in Richmond. Dozens of vendors rent tables to buy, sell, and trade sports cards and other collectibles. It’s a great place to get a sense of current market prices for your cards by browsing multiple dealers’ inventories side by side. You can either set up your own table to directly sell cards or bring your collection with you and get on-the-spot offers from vendors. Admission is free.

Classified Ads – You can post classified listings to sell your baseball cards on popular sites like Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, OfferUp, Letgo, and eBay. Taking this route means you avoid any retailer commissions but will have more work finding individual buyers, handling payments, and shipping cards safely if selling from a distance. Photos and detailed descriptions are key to generating interest. Rarity guides can help you price cards appropriately to sell quickly. Meet local buyers in a public place for safety.

Sports Memorabilia Conventions – Twice a year during the winter and summer months, large memorabilia and card shows are held in the Houston area that are worth visiting to find serious card collectors and dealers. Events like the Houston Sports Collectibles Convention in March and the Houston Sports Collectible, Memorabilia & Card Show in August regularly attract hundreds of exhibitors and thousands of attendees. With so much foot traffic, these shows practically guarantee you can sell nearly any baseball cards if priced competitively.

Baseball Card Shows – Smaller, baseball-focused conventions occur periodically in Houston as well. Check sites like HoustonCardshows.com, beckett.com or bravesjournal.com for upcoming dates and locations. Depending on the size and time of year, attendance can range from a couple dozen to a few hundred collectors at these specialty events. Some sellers prefer the more focused audiences at baseball-themed shows over the diversity of larger memorabilia conventions.

Online Auctions – A timely option is to sell baseball cards through online auction sites such as eBay, Heritage Auctions, or Lelands. You set minimum bids and auction timeframes or sell cards individually at fixed buy-it-now prices. Bidder interest may depend heavily on how cards are photographed and advertised. Selling online expands your potential customer base but has costs like insertion and final value fees that cut into profits compared to local in-person sales. For extremely rare finds, auction houses provide structured marketplaces to maximize prices.

Some final tips – No matter which path you choose, make sure to thoroughly research recent fair market values for your cards using industry sources like Beckett, Ebay “sold” listings, and130Point.com. Presentation is important – have cards in sleeves or toploaders, organized properly. And when meeting strangers, take standard precautions like arranging transactions during daytime hours and in well-populated areas. Following these best practices will help you get top dollar and safely sell off your baseball card collection near Houston.

WHERE’S THE BEST PLACE TO SELL OLD BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

Online Marketplaces – Some of the most popular and reliable sites for selling cards online include eBay, SportscardsDirect, COMC (Collectiblesonlinemarketplace.com), and Blowout Cards. eBay is the largest auction site and will provide the best chance of finding interested buyers but you’ll pay fees of around 13% of the final sale price. Sites like SportscardsDirect and COMC are dedicated specifically to cards and have buying/consignment programs that can simplify the process but may not always get top dollar. With any online option, it’s important to photograph cards well, describe conditions accurately, ship promptly, and communicate professionally with buyers.

Local Card Shops – Calling up any local collectible shops is a good option, especially for larger collections or valuable singles. Shops can appraise collections and may buy entire lots rather than just individual cards. They need to make a profit so you likely won’t get top dollar. Some will also take cards on consignment if you want a chance at a higher sale price. Dropping by in person to establish a relationship could also lead to referrals of interested customers.

Card Shows – Regionally throughout the year there are various collector card shows, conventions and expos where hundreds of vendors set up tables. These are great opportunities to meet buyers face-to-face, get on-the-spot appraisals from experienced dealers, and potentially sell cards quickly in bulk rather than piecing out online. Entrance fees are usually nominal and you can rent a table to display items for sale if desired. Shows draw serious collectors who may pay top dollar for valuable cards. Transporting large collections can be cumbersome and you’re competing against many other sellers.

Facebook Groups – Many local and topic-specific collectibles Facebook groups exist solely for buying and selling items. Make a post with photos of your cards, their conditions and prices. Interacting on the site helps establish you as a trustworthy seller. Deals are made in the comments. This personalized approach allows for haggling on price and building rapport with interested buyers. Risks include shipping to strangers and no platform protections like eBay. Stick to highly populated, well-moderated groups.

Consignment Shops – For very large or valuable collections, another option is consignment shops that specifically handle sports memorabilia and card liquidation. They’ll assess your entire collection (which can take days or weeks), divide into lots, handle pricing, display at their storefront, and manage all sales and shipping. While this hands-off approach minimizes your time investment, consignment shops generally take the largest commission percentage, around 30-50% of final sales. But it ensures top dollar prices are achieved through their experts and established clientele.

The best approach depends on factors like size of collection, urgency to sell, and desired profits. Combining multiple online and in-person selling venues often nets the highest returns. With some research to find reputable buyers and platforms, and clearly presenting your items for sale, you can confidently move your old baseball cards into the hands of appreciative collectors. Just be sure to sell authentic cards and represent their actual conditions honestly to maintain a positive reputation.

HOW TO SELL UNGRADED BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

When it comes to selling ungraded baseball cards, there are several factors to consider in order to get the best possible price and find buyers. Ungraded cards can still hold significant value, but sellers need to properly showcase the condition and history of each card.

The first step is to carefully examine each individual card. Take the time to inspect the front and back for any flaws, bends, stains or other issues that could impact the grading if it were to be professionally assessed. Make note of any flaws and be fully transparent in your listing descriptions. Potential buyers will appreciate the honesty and it will set proper expectations.

To showcase the condition, clear photos from multiple angles under good lighting are essential. Snap at least 4 high-resolution pictures of each card – a straight-on front photo, a straight-on back photo, and two angled photos of each side. Proper lighting will help show off surfaces and edges for flaws. Use a neutral background so the card itself stands out.

In the listing description, write detailed notes on the overall condition using industry standard terms. Note the centering, corners, edges and surfaces and rate on a 1-10 scale if possible. Mention any creases, stains, whitening on edges or other flaws in great detail. An accurate condition report gives buyers confidence and stops disputes.

Research recently sold prices of similar ungraded cards on platforms like eBay to determine a fair asking price range. Factor in the specific player, year, set and noted condition issues when comparing. Generally, price on the lower end of similar solds to allow for bidding wars and negotiate up. Overpricing will result in no sales.

When photographing the card, include a handwritten note with your username, the date and the item number/code. This proves authenticity and protects against stolen photos being used fraudulently elsewhere online. Only ship in a hard plastic toploader and sleeve for protection.

List individual high value cards separately rather than in lots whenever possible. Sellers have more control over pricing and buyers can choose specific needs. But very low value cards can still make sense in discounted lots. Only accept payment through secure platforms like PayPal Goods & Services for buyer and seller protection on transactions.

Promote listings across multiple sports card marketplace sites and groups including eBay, Facebook, Twitter, Reddit forums and specialty platforms like COMC. Reach a wide potential buyers pool. Be transparent in all communication and ship timely once paid to build trust. Respond quickly to any questions from interested parties.

Following these tips will help sellers of ungraded baseball cards maximize chances of sales and prices by properly showcasing condition details upfront. With patience and honest collaboration with buyers, ungraded vintage and modern cardboard still holds value when transacted carefully person to person outside of professional grading.

WHERE CAN I SELL MY BASEBALL CARDS IN MEMPHIS

Leave a reply

Card Shack – Located at 5101 Summer Ave, Memphis, TN 38122, Card Shack is one of the largest and most well-established card shops in the city. They buy, sell, and trade all sports cards, including baseball cards. Some key things to know about selling at Card Shack:

They pay cash on the spot for individual cards or full collections depending on condition and demand. Pricing is based on recent eBay sold listings and industry guide prices like Beckett.

They are only interested in higher end, rare vintage rookie cards from the 1950s-1980s or modern parallels, autographed cards, and high grade rookie cards. Common cards from the 1990s onwards have little value.

Bring in your cards organized and in protective sleeves or toploaders so they can review quickly. They may make offers on full collections versus individual cards.

card is very busy, especially on weekends, so come during off-peak hours mid-week for the best experience.

Ask for Bryan, he has over 30 years of experience and is the best buyer at assessing collection value.

If they don’t make a fair offer, they will be upfront about it and you are welcome to shop cards around elsewhere.

Consider trading some cards towards store credit to purchase other items if cash offer is lower than hoped.

Gameday Sports Cards – Located at 4510 Summer Ave, Memphis, TN 38122, Gameday is another local favorite for sports card collectors. A few notes about selling to Gameday:

Similar to Card Shack in terms of buying singles, collections, or trading. Cash offers depend on condition and demand.

Very knowledgeable staff that can provide fair market value estimates before you sell.

Gameday will also post your cards for sale on their website and social media at no extra cost if they don’t buy outright. This gets cards in front of more potential buyers.

Consider consignment if they don’t buy outright rather than taking a low cash offer. Cards are only sold when a fair price is met.

Store credit is another option if they feel cards will sell better long term in their shop versus a cash offer.

Gameday hosts regular sport card shows/events where your cards may find new homes over time through their network.

Again, mid-week is best to avoid weekend crowds and get staff’s full attention to assess collection.

The recordEXchange – Located just across from Graceland at 3727 Elvis Presley Blvd, recordEXchange is known Memphis-wide for its huge selection of used records, movies, games, toys, and other pop culture collectibles. While smaller than Gameday/Card Shack for cards, some good reasons to check here are:

The owners Luke and Jason are avid baseball fans and collectors themselves dating back decades.

They have connections to serious collectors nationwide that may want higher end vintage and they can try to broker a deal.

Consider consignment here if your collection contains gems they think would appeal to their special buyer network over time.

Short of trades or consignment deals, they will make fair cash offers on the spot for commons needing a new home.

Great middle option between a large card shop and pawn/buy-sell shops with more personalized attention.

Beyond those three options, some other places that may purchase individual baseball cards or very small collections include Memphis Coins & Collectibles, Game X Change (multiple locations), Cash America Pawn, and various buy-sell-trade shops in the area. These often pay very little and are really meant for offloading common duplicates or unwanted cards quickly for a few dollars rather than assessing true collection value.

In summary, Card Shack, Gameday Sports Cards, and recordEXchange are the top recommendations for properly selling baseball cards in Memphis. Going mid-week, having cards organized, and asking questions will help maximize the return. Trading or consignment are also good alternatives to consider beyond straight cash sales. With some patience and networking, serious collectors in Memphis can find baseball cards a good new home.