Tag Archives: goodwill


Goodwill does generally accept donations of baseball cards, but there are some important factors to consider before donating your collection. As a nonprofit organization, Goodwill relies heavily on donations to fund its mission of providing job training and career services. Baseball cards can be a valuable donation for Goodwill since there is nostalgia and collector interest in vintage cards. Like any donation, Goodwill must consider how easily the items can be sorted, priced, and sold in their retail stores to generate funding.

With baseball cards, there are a few key things to keep in mind when donating to Goodwill:

Condition of cards: Goodwill prefers cards to be in at least fair/playable condition with no excessive bending, creases, or other defects that would prevent them being displayed and sold. Heavily worn cards may not be acceptable. Organizing cards by condition/quality helps Goodwill most.

Volume: Goodwill stores have limited space to display items, so large collections of thousands of cards may be difficult to process and store all at once. It’s best to donate baseball cards in batches of a few hundred at a time to avoid overloading their receiving areas.

Sorting/Organization: Taking the time to sort cards by year, team, player can help Goodwill maximize the value when pricing and shelving items. Putting all cards loosely in a box makes them much harder to organize on the sales floor. Consider storing cards in plastic sheets, pages, or binders if possible.

Rarity/Value: While Goodwill aims to sell everything they receive, they may not have the expertise to properly assess extremely rare/valuable cards worth hundreds or thousands individually. In such cases, it’s best to set aside truly high-end vintage gems for auction or a specialty sport card store instead.

Format: Goodwill prefers traditional cardboard stock cards versus other unconventional formats like gold/foil wrappers that are harder to display. Stick to standard sized cards.

Rotating donations: Consider donating your baseball card collection in phases over time rather than all at once. This helps avoid oversupply and allows Goodwill to fully process batches before new inventory arrives.

If following these guidelines, Goodwill is generally happy to accept baseball cards as donations that can be easily sorted and sold. Each local Goodwill store may have their own individual policies too, so it’s always best to call your specific location’s donation entrance in advance to check acceptance guidelines before dropping off a large collection. Some stores may occasionally pause accepting cards if their backstock gets too high too. Communication is key.

Once cards are donated to Goodwill, they go through a sorting/pricing process by employees and volunteers. The goal is to get the cards neatly organized by year/team/player on shelves within a few weeks for customers to browse. Pricing aims to be fair and competitive with local card shops. Proceeds from all Goodwill sales directly support job training programs in the community.

As long as cards are in reasonable condition, organized to some degree, and donated in manageable batches, most Goodwill locations will happily accept baseball card donations to generate funding for their charitable mission. Rarer, pricier cards may do better finding new homes at specialty hobby dealers instead though. Communication with your local Goodwill on guidelines is also recommended before gift of larger collections. With some planning, donating baseball cards can be a win-win for collectors and the nonprofit.


The answer is that sometimes Goodwill stores will have baseball cards, but it varies significantly by location and what type of donations each individual store receives. Goodwill is a nonprofit organization that operates over 3,000 stores nationwide, so the inventory in each store will be different based on what community members donate. There are a few factors that determine the likelihood of any given Goodwill having baseball cards for sale:

Goodwill accepts donations of used and unwanted household items from community members. This includes clothing, books, electronics, sporting goods, toys, and more. When people clean out their attics, basements, or move homes, they will often donate entire boxes or collections of baseball cards that have been accumulated over many years but are no longer wanted. Baseball card collecting was hugely popular from the 1950s through the 1990s, so there are countless boxes of cards floating around in used goods that end up at Goodwill.

The likelihood of finding baseball cards at Goodwill depends on the demographics and interests of the local community. Stores located in areas that have historically had large populations of baseball fans from that eras are more apt to receive box loads of donated cards. For example, a Goodwill store near a neighborhood known for its Little League baseball programs from the 1970s would stand a better chance than a store in an area without such recreational sports history. Regional differences also play a role, as certain areas of the country engage with baseball as a pastime more so than others.

Store size is another factor – larger Goodwill locations with more retail space available will be more likely to unpack and sort through boxes of donations looking for valuable items to put out for sale. Smaller stores may just quickly process donations and not discover an intact baseball card collection. The timing of donations also matters – a store that just received a big donation of unsorted memorabilia right before a shopper’s visit has better odds of finding cards than one that hasn’t had such a donation in months.

It also depends on if the Goodwill has employees or volunteers who are personally interested in baseball cards and know what to look for. Someone familiar with vintage cards may better recognize the potential value in sorting through a disorganized box of old cardboard and plastic versus just assuming it’s meaningless junk. Not all Goodwills can rely on staff with specialist knowledge areas.

Some Goodwill locations have realized baseball cards can be aconsistently good seller and make more of an effort to actively seek them out. An individual store’s business model and profit priorities also factor in – a for-profit Goodwill style store may give cards more priority than a nonprofit focused on job training services. Stores located in areas with many retro toy and memorabilia resellers know cards can attract commercial buyers as well as fans.

Once found, how cards are priced also varies. Pricing inaccurately too high could mean they languish, but too low risks leaving money on the table. The ideal scenario is partnering with a local collector volunteered to help value selections. In the absence of expertise, selling by the pound is common but less profitable. Factors like year, player, and condition are ignored.

While individual donations are unpredictable, Goodwill remains a very worthwhile place for baseball card collectors and investors to regularly check. With a little luck, patience, and the right local circumstances, it’s certainly possible to find forgotten stashes of vintage cardboard treasures or feed new collections at bargain prices. The secondary market has only increased demand and made cards more valuable in recent years. With so much variance between locations, treasure hunters just need to discover which of their local Goodwills provide the most fun and profitable hunting grounds.


It depends on the individual Goodwill location, but in many cases Goodwill will accept donations of old baseball cards. Goodwill is a nonprofit organization that operates over 3,300 stores across the United States and Canada. Their goal is to provide job training and employment services while also raising funds through the sale of donated goods. With regards to baseball cards specifically, here are some more details on Goodwill’s policies:

While Goodwill will generally accept most types of donations as long as they are in reasonably good condition, individual stores have discretion over what items they will accept based on their ability to sell the items. Old baseball cards fall into a gray area because while they may hold nostalgic value for some, they can be difficult to sell and do not necessarily appeal to Goodwill’s broad customer base. That said, if the cards are organized and in protective sleeves or books, they have a better chance of being accepted. Loose unsorted bulk cards may be turned away.

It’s always best to call the local Goodwill store location in advance to ask about their policy on baseball card donations before making the trip. Staff can give you an assessment of their ability to handle and merchandise cards based on current space, supplier demand, and past sales history. Goodwill also prefers donations be dropped off during store hours as opposed to leaving boxes outside when the store is closed. This allows an associate to inspect the cards and ensure they meet donation guidelines.

Some Goodwill locations may only accept baseball card donations from recognized dealers and resellers who supply on a bigger scale. Individual casual collectors are less likely to have large enough quantities of pre-sorted cards to interest these stores. Other Goodwill locations are open to smaller donations from community members. Again, the policy varies by individual thrift store.

If accepted, the baseball cards would be processed, priced, and sold just like any other donated collectible item. Some Goodwill stores have a dedicated “collectibles” section, while others may mix higher value donations like cards in with general merchandise. Most cards would be priced individually but bulk lots may be sold at a flat rate per box or binder as well. Proceeds from card and other collectible sales help fund Goodwill’s charitable mission.

Other donation tips that can help increase the chances of Goodwill accepting old baseball cards include: keeping cards in protective plastic sleeves or pages rather than loose; sorting by player, year, team or other categories; and focusing donations on more valuable vintage years versus large quantities of common modern cards. Also, donating cards to Goodwill during peak leisure season like summer when more shoppers browse the thrift stores can boost sales potential.

While policies vary by individual location, many Goodwill stores are open to receiving baseball card collections as donations depending on factors like quantity, condition, organization level and the local store’s ability to sell. Calling ahead is advised to check the specific guidelines, but for organized vintage card donations, Goodwill may provide an appreciated second life helping their job training programs. With over 16,000 retail stores across both countries, Goodwill offers a widespread donation network to responsibly recycle old collections back into the marketplace.


While individual Goodwill stores may vary in their inventory and selection, in general Goodwill does not focus on selling baseball cards as a major part of their business model and retail experience. Goodwill is a nonprofit organization that operates over 3,300 stores across the United States and 11 other countries. Their main goal is job training and placement services rather than being a dedicated collectibles retailer.

That being said, baseball cards can and do occasionally end up in Goodwill stores through donations and make their way onto the sales floor. Since Goodwill relies entirely on donated items to stock their stores, what inventory they receive can vary greatly depending on what the local community is donating. Sometimes people clean out their attics, basements, or storage units and donate old sports card collections without really knowing their value. Other times collectors may donate duplicate cards they no longer want.

So while Goodwill isn’t seeking out baseball card donations specifically or setting aside display space specifically for cards, individual store managers have discretion over what donated items to accept and put out for sale. It’s certainly possible that on any given day a Goodwill store could have a box of old baseball cards mixed in with other used books, movies, toys and clothing. Finding sports cards is usually more hit-or-miss compared to stopping at a dedicated card shop.

Some tips for anyone wanting to check their local Goodwill for potential baseball card finds include visiting frequently, at least once a week, to increase chances of seeing any donated cards before they sell. It also helps to get to know managers and volunteers who process donations – they may alert you if they know a large sports card collection just came in. Weekday mornings tend to be best, before donations get picked over. Explore all areas of the store too, not just specific trading card display racks, as loose packs or boxes of cards can end up mixed in with other donated items.

The flip side is that since Goodwill doesn’t specially target card collectors, their sorting and pricing procedures may not always give maximum value to what is donated. Cards could end up in the general kids’ toy section priced very low, not realizing their true worth. And if Goodwill volunteers aren’t card experts themselves, it’s possible valuable singles or sets could be overlooked amongst less valuable common cards. Proper sorting, grading and price guides simply aren’t Goodwill’s emphasis the way they are at specialized collectible shops.

Still, with some hunting and luck, Goodwill shopping provides a budget-friendly way for casual collectors to potentially find interesting vintage cards or starters for beginner sets – and help support Goodwill’s mission in the process. While it’s risky to count on steady or large card supplies, pop-culture treasures do surface in Goodwill’s ever-changing used goods selection now and then. So taking a look through your local store every so often is worth sports fans’ while, you never know what surprise finds might be nestled amongst the thrift store racks.

While Goodwill isn’t primarily focused on baseball card sales, their reuse and recycling business model means related donations dosometimes end up on shelves – offering bargain hunters and collectors occasional chances to see what undiscovered treasures pop up. Consistent browsing increases odds of success for anyone hoping to build collections or find interesting vintage items on a budget through their local Goodwill store.


Baseball cards are a collectible item that many enjoy seeking out and building complete sets of. With the rise of online auction sites and card shops, it can sometimes feel difficult to find affordable cards. Thrift stores like Goodwill can offer a treasure trove of baseball card finds if you know where to look. Here are some tips for having success locating cards at Goodwill.

Start by regularly checking the toy, game, and book sections of Goodwill stores. Many people donate old collections of cards that get sorted into these areas. Look through bins and on shelves for loose packs of cards or full albums filled with players from various eras. Goodwill prices cards very reasonably, often a few dollars or less for large collections. Be sure to thoroughly look through anything you find, as valuable rookie cards or error cards could be hiding within.

Beyond the designated sections, also scan other areas like clothing and household goods. People sometimes donate boxes of childhood belongings containing cards. Folders or envelopes tucked inside boxes or bundled with papers/photos are easy to miss but can hold gems. Thoroughly inspecting donations gives you the best chance of discovering hidden card caches.

Timing your Goodwill visits for when new donations come out can up your odds. Ask employees when they receive the largest volume of donations each week. Those early days after an influx offer the freshest pickings before other shoppers scoop things up. Morning and midday weekday visits tend to have fewer shoppers competing for finds.

Consider expanding your search radius to multiple Goodwill locations. Larger metro areas may have several stores worth checking regularly. Suburban and rural Goodwills sometimes get more unique donations not picked through as quickly. Make a morning of hitting multiple stores in one outing.

Beyond just cards, keep an eye out for related collectibles like books, magazines, equipment, and unopened packs/boxes too. People sometimes donate full collections with cards still sealed in their original packaging. These can contain valuable pre-production samples or oddball promotional items.

Bring a phone or tablet along to quickly research anything interesting you come across. Sites like eBay let you check recent sold prices to gauge potential value. This helps determine if something is worth purchasing or leaving for another collector. Only buy condition-appropriate cards worth a few times what Goodwill is asking to ensure profit potential.

Get to know the Goodwill employees. Mention your interest in cards and that you’re a regular shopper. They may hold items aside or give you a heads up about large donations coming in. Employees often have insight into what areas tend to yield the best finds for different collectors. Developing relationships helps optimize your Goodwill card hunting adventures.

Consider donating your own duplicates and bulk commons to Goodwill too. This pays it forward while also advertising your collecting interests. Other local collectors will discover your donations and may reach out to trade. You never know what other treasures you could acquire through kind gestures within the thrifting community.

With some strategy and regular visits, Goodwill can become a reliable source of affordable baseball cards. Just be sure to thoroughly search in unexpected areas, time your trips smartly, and get to know the staff. With some luck and perseverance, you’re bound to uncover gems that add to your collection for a steal. So get out there and happy thrifting – you never know what baseball history could be waiting on the Goodwill shelves.


Goodwill has become an unlikely source for sports card collectors searching for forgotten treasures inexpensively. While thrift stores are not traditionally known as hot spots for finding valuable memorabilia, the mix of randomness and affordability has drawn many enthusiasts to scour racks and shelves at their local Goodwill locations. The thrill of the hunt and potential payoff keeps collectors stopping by on a regular basis, hoping this visit will be the one where they uncover a forgotten gem in mint condition priced just a few dollars.

Some key factors have contributed to Goodwill emerging as a destination for bargain baseball card hunters. As the sports card boom of the late 80s and 90s faded, many collections were broken up and cards ended up donated along with other clutter as families cleaned out homes of deceased relatives or downsized their possessions. Rather than properly assess the value of specific rare cards, most donations were just seen as taking up space. The low prices Goodwill assigns all media keep values realistic for shoppers but don’t necessarily reflect what a key vintage rookie or star player card in pristine shape could fetch on eBay.

For collectors on a budget or just starting out, places like Goodwill offer the chance to build a collection affordably through serendipitous finds versus spending hundreds on a single chase card online. The unknown nature of what could be sitting in a unsorted long box also provides an element of surprise and potential for striking gold. While value cards show up infrequently, patrons spend only a few dollars versus gambling on boxes or packs of new cards where rates of return are slim. Low overheads allow Goodwill to price competitively, passing savings directly to customers versus collectibles dealers aiming to turn profits.

Vintage cards from the 1950s and 60s eras are particularly coveted discoveries considering how the combination of age and mass production runs have made many early issues quite scarce in high grades today. Iconic rookie cards of players like Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron and Sandy Koufax change hands for thousands in pristine condition. Even commons and star lesser known players from this golden age of the game hold value due to collecting interest and nostalgia. Condition is king so finding examples in seemingly “pack fresh” state straight from donation boxes creates huge excitement.

1970s issues are also prized by collectors seeking stars of that era before inflation took hold of card values. Players like Reggie Jackson, Nolan Ryan and George Brett all debuted and had successful careers anchoring many a collection. 1981 Topps Traded football cards containing Lawrence Taylor’s rookie also gained fame ending up in unlikely locations.The early 90s BOOM period saw unprecedented production which practically gave away prized rookie cards of future Hall of Famers like Ken Griffey Jr, Chipper Jones and Jim Thome by the pack. Finding these “affordable” and quite valuable today adds great nostalgia and investment potential for collectors.

While ungraded low-end cards make up the bulk of thrift store donations, highlights show up enough to keep dedicated collectors regularly stopping by Goodwill. One such hunter struck gold finding a 1909-11 T206 White Border Nap Lajoie valued near $15,000 in excellent condition priced just $2.99. In another story, an 1887-1890 Old Judge tobacco card of Cap Anson graded PSA 3.5 sold for over $25,000 having been purchased for $5 at a Salvation Army. Such stories ignite the hopes of anyone sifting through common boxes or racks you never know what may be sitting in plain sight.

Grading cards adds considerable value so even well-worn examples can get new life after professional assessment. Services like PSA and BGS aim to provide consistency and remove questions over condition/centering contributing to higher prices commanded in the marketplace. Slabbed vintage commons can sell for ten times over face value ungraded. New technology like Coin/Card grading machines may allow places like Goodwill to better assess value without taking up experts time vs just applying standard prices. This could allow true treasures proper exposure versus sitting unseen in the $1 bins.

The element of surprise combined with affordability help explain the popularity of Goodwill hunting for sports card collectors. While big hits only surface on rare occasions volumes looked through mean dedicated patrons will stumble on usable common cards expanding sets or premiums like oddball issues and parallels impossible to predict appearing. With millions of cards donated annually, this secondary market looks set to remain an endless source of rediscovered gems for open-minded collectors. Whether seeking affordable classics or improbableSCOREs Goodwill’s low-risk, high-reward formula brings many back hoping their persistence may finally pay off.


Donating Baseball Cards to Goodwill: An Overview

Many baseball card collectors accumulate boxes upon boxes of cards over the years, whether through opening packs as kids, buying collections, or trading online. At a certain point, space becomes an issue and collectors may feel they have more cards than they actually need. This is where donating cards to Goodwill can be a great option.

Goodwill is a nonprofit organization that operates thrift stores across the United States and Canada. Their mission is to provide job training, employment placement services, and other community-based programs for people who have barriers preventing them from otherwise obtaining a job. Anything donated to Goodwill is either sold in their retail stores to fund these programs or recycled/disposed of properly if it can’t be sold.

Baseball cards are one of the top donated items Goodwill receives. While they may not have the same value to you as a collector, there is still demand from other collectors and kids looking to start a collection. Here’s a breakdown of the process for donating your baseball cards to Goodwill:

Sorting and Organizing
The key is to properly sort and organize your cards before donating. Goodwill prefers cards to either be in sleeves/toploaders already or at minimum sorted by sport, year, team, etc. This makes it much easier for them to display and sell the cards in their stores. Take the time to go through your collection and pull out any valuable/high-end cards you may still want to sell or trade separately. The rest can then be donated.

Packaging for Transport
Once sorted, you’ll want to package the cards securely for transport. Many collectors use boxes specifically designed for holding cards, but even just using a sturdy cardboard box and packing the cards tightly with bubble wrap or newspaper works well too. The goal is to avoid any bending or damage to the cards in transit. Proper packaging shows Goodwill you took care in the donation process.

Dropping Off Your Donation
Most Goodwill locations accept walk-in donations during their business hours. It’s best to call your local store ahead of time to confirm they accept baseball cards and ensure they have space. Most stores have designated drop-off areas. Simply inform the staff you are donating cards and they’ll direct you where to leave the packaged boxes. You’ll receive a receipt for tax purposes.

Pricing and Display in Stores
How Goodwill prices donated cards varies by location, but in general here is the process: Less common/bulk cards may be priced individually at $0.25-1 each or in discounted lots. Rarer/higher valued singles could be priced looking at eBay sold listings. Complete sets are usually priced as a single item. Cards are then displayed together either in card boxes, binders/books or on rack cards based on the store. This allows other collectors easy browsing.

Potential Tax Benefits
By requesting a receipt for your baseball card donation from Goodwill, you are eligible to claim the non-cash contribution on your taxes. The value of the donation is based on fair market value. While you won’t get the full original purchase price back, it can provide a tax break. Be sure to keep your Goodwill receipt with your tax documents. Consult a tax professional for specifics on how much you can claim.

Knowledgeable Goodwill Pricing
While Goodwill employees aren’t card experts, many locations do employ individuals familiar enough with the hobby to properly assess donations. Prices are usually fair compared to similar donated items. Of course, there’s no guarantee every single card will sell, but Goodwill aims to price cards at levels collectors are still willing to pay. Any unsold cards may be put into discounted bundles over time too.

Recycling Unsellable Cards
Not every card in a donation will necessarily be in good enough condition to sell, no matter the effort of sorting. Very worn, damaged or common cards may only have recycle value at that point. Goodwill ensures anything that won’t sell is properly recycled instead of ending up in a landfill. So feel good knowing even cards without resale value still help support their mission through the recycling revenue.

Potential for Future Collecting
While the primary goal is supporting Goodwill’s mission, donating your cards also provides the opportunity for others to discover the hobby. A young kid browsing may find an affordable lot that sparks a new collecting passion. You never know, the cards you donate could end up in the hands of the next generation of baseball fans. There’s a good chance some of the cards may even make their way back to you one day too through the secondary market.

Donating your excess or no-longer-wanted baseball cards to Goodwill is an easy way to declutter your collection while supporting a great cause. With some organization beforehand, your cards have the best shot at finding a new home and potentially helping grow the hobby. So consider Goodwill as the ideal option the next time you need to thin out that card box pile taking up space. Both collectors and Goodwill can benefit from card donations.