Card Shack – Located at 5101 Summer Ave, Memphis, TN 38122, Card Shack is one of the largest and most well-established card shops in the city. They buy, sell, and trade all sports cards, including baseball cards. Some key things to know about selling at Card Shack:
They pay cash on the spot for individual cards or full collections depending on condition and demand. Pricing is based on recent eBay sold listings and industry guide prices like Beckett.
They are only interested in higher end, rare vintage rookie cards from the 1950s-1980s or modern parallels, autographed cards, and high grade rookie cards. Common cards from the 1990s onwards have little value.
Bring in your cards organized and in protective sleeves or toploaders so they can review quickly. They may make offers on full collections versus individual cards.
card is very busy, especially on weekends, so come during off-peak hours mid-week for the best experience.
Ask for Bryan, he has over 30 years of experience and is the best buyer at assessing collection value.
If they don’t make a fair offer, they will be upfront about it and you are welcome to shop cards around elsewhere.
Consider trading some cards towards store credit to purchase other items if cash offer is lower than hoped.
Gameday Sports Cards – Located at 4510 Summer Ave, Memphis, TN 38122, Gameday is another local favorite for sports card collectors. A few notes about selling to Gameday:
Similar to Card Shack in terms of buying singles, collections, or trading. Cash offers depend on condition and demand.
Very knowledgeable staff that can provide fair market value estimates before you sell.
Gameday will also post your cards for sale on their website and social media at no extra cost if they don’t buy outright. This gets cards in front of more potential buyers.
Consider consignment if they don’t buy outright rather than taking a low cash offer. Cards are only sold when a fair price is met.
Store credit is another option if they feel cards will sell better long term in their shop versus a cash offer.
Gameday hosts regular sport card shows/events where your cards may find new homes over time through their network.
Again, mid-week is best to avoid weekend crowds and get staff’s full attention to assess collection.
The recordEXchange – Located just across from Graceland at 3727 Elvis Presley Blvd, recordEXchange is known Memphis-wide for its huge selection of used records, movies, games, toys, and other pop culture collectibles. While smaller than Gameday/Card Shack for cards, some good reasons to check here are:
The owners Luke and Jason are avid baseball fans and collectors themselves dating back decades.
They have connections to serious collectors nationwide that may want higher end vintage and they can try to broker a deal.
Consider consignment here if your collection contains gems they think would appeal to their special buyer network over time.
Short of trades or consignment deals, they will make fair cash offers on the spot for commons needing a new home.
Great middle option between a large card shop and pawn/buy-sell shops with more personalized attention.
Beyond those three options, some other places that may purchase individual baseball cards or very small collections include Memphis Coins & Collectibles, Game X Change (multiple locations), Cash America Pawn, and various buy-sell-trade shops in the area. These often pay very little and are really meant for offloading common duplicates or unwanted cards quickly for a few dollars rather than assessing true collection value.
In summary, Card Shack, Gameday Sports Cards, and recordEXchange are the top recommendations for properly selling baseball cards in Memphis. Going mid-week, having cards organized, and asking questions will help maximize the return. Trading or consignment are also good alternatives to consider beyond straight cash sales. With some patience and networking, serious collectors in Memphis can find baseball cards a good new home.
