Sports Collectibles: Located in the heart of downtown Toronto at 189 Yonge Street, Sports Collectibles is considered one of the premier sports card and memorabilia shops in the city. With over 15,000 square feet of retail space spread over two floors, this massive store has an incredible selection of new and vintage baseball cards to choose from. They have individual packs, boxes and cases of all the latest MLB releases from the major card companies. Sports Collectibles also has a vast supply of older wax packs, boxes, sets and singles dating back to the early 20th century. Whether you’re looking for current stars or historic greats, you’re sure to find it here. The friendly and knowledgeable staff can also help locate specific cards you may be searching for.
Pastime Cards: Nestled in the East End of Toronto along Woodbine Avenue is Pastime Cards, a popular local shop for all things baseball cards and collectibles. While smaller than Sports Collectibles, Pastime still offers a superb selection of new release cards as prospective buyers can find unopened boxes and cases from Topps, Panini, Leaf and more on the shelves. They also have an organized area dedicated to vintage cardboard where customers can flip through thousands of individual pre-1980s singles sorted by team and year. Pastime Cards is a great spot for collectors looking to build sets from past eras as well as find older valuable rookie cards. Customer service is excellent and staff are always happy to discuss the hobby, latest trends or provide recommendations.
TNT Cards & Collectibles: Tucked away in a nondescript plaza in Scarborough near Markham Road and Eglinton Avenue East lies TNT Cards, a low key local treasure trove for sports card aficionados. While the shop may not have the glitz of some of the bigger collectors hotspots in the city, TNT makes up for it with consistently reasonable prices and a carefully curated assortment of new and used items. Recent MLB issues from Panini, Topps and more are stocked alongside unopened vintage wax packs and a wide selection of affordable used singles dating back decades. TNT is the perfect spot for collectors on a budget hunting for specific needs or browsing for diamond in the rough vintage cards. Friendly staff are always around to offer guidance or appraisals as well.
Toonie For Two: Located right in the heart of the bustling Kensington Market neighborhood, Toonie For Two distinguishes itself as one of Toronto’s most unique collectibles stores. Alongside its expansive stock of comics, toys, movies and other pop culture treasures lurks a impressive baseball card selection. While the focus is more on vintage cardboard from the 1970s and earlier, discerning collectors can still find excellent conditioned complete sets, individual stars, oddball issues and even unopened boxes of penny and nickel packs from yesteryear. Prices tend to be extremely reasonable and negotiated which adds to the charm of the shopping experience. Toonie For Two is definitley worth a visit for anyone in search of affordable vintage baseball nostalgia.
616 Card Shop: Operating out of a small but perfectly formed booth at the popular TCX Collectibles Market, 616 Card Shop is a mainstay for regular attendees and demonstrates that big things can come in small packages. Owner Akim has a exceptional eye for sourcing affordable inventory from across North America often featuring complete team and star player sets, binder collections lots and large boxes of vintage wax packs, factory sets and oddballs. He’s constantly unearthing buried treasure to showcase and prices everything extremely reasonably. 616 also actively buys, sells and appraises collections large and small if you’re ever looking to turn cards into cash or fill gaps in your want lists. It’s an ideal stop for anyone shopping the busy Sunday market.
The GTA has an excellent selection of brick and mortar shops catering to all levels of baseball card collectors. From massive outlets with every imaginable new release to niche vintage specialist holes in the wall, Toronto area buyers are truly spoiled for choice. Those seeking the finest new and used cardboard can certainly find almost anything they need without ever having to go online. Competitive prices, knowledgeable staff and a vibrant community atmosphere make searching for cards in this city a thoroughly enjoyable experience.