Sportscards Direct – This is one of the largest retailers that buys and sells sports cards both online and in physical stores. They have locations across the United States and Canada. On their website, they have a page dedicated to selling cards to them. You can get a free instant online card price guide just by uploading photos of your cards. They will make you an offer eligible for store credit that you can use towards future purchases. They are interested in buying collections of cards but also single rare and valuable cards as well. Some of the factors that affect the price they will offer include the condition or state of preservation of the card, the player, the year it was printed, and of course rarity. Damaged or worn cards will receive much lower offers than near mint conditioned cards.
Cardboard Connection – This company has been a leading hobby shop for sports cards, memorabilia and related collectibles since 1997. They have 4 shops in Ohio and Michigan. In addition to selling cards, they have a standing offer to purchase card collections from customers. Similar to Sportscards Direct, they provide an online card price guide to help you get a ballpark value of your collection. You can then send pictures of the cards you want to sell so one of their buyers can provide you with a customized offer. They pay competitively for rarer, higher value cards in good condition from the top players. The rate they offer is usually around 60-70% of what they would subsequently list the cards at in their online store.
Steiner Sports Memorabilia – This major sports collectibles company focuses more on equipment, autographs and signed memorabilia but they do purchase baseball card collections as well. You need to contact one of their specialized baseball/cards buyers who can look up latest values, condition grade your cards and provide you with a total dollar amount offer for the entire lot. They tend to pay higher offers than typical hobby shops, upwards of 75%+ of estimated market value for extensive collections containing key vintage/rookie cards. Shipping and insurance is covered by them as well.
Baseball Card Exchange – Operating since 1992, this store and website is dedicated just to baseball cards. They have locations in 5 states and will consider buying both individual rare cards as well as large collections. Their staff includes experienced graders who will not only provide a dollar amount offer but also issue a comprehensive condition report for your records. In addition to cash payment, they may offer store credit or trade-in value that can be applied to future card/equipment/memorabilia purchases from their inventory. Condition, brand, year and player statistics heavily impact the price they are willing to pay.
Dave and Adam’s Card World – With retail shops found throughout the Midwest and online presence, Dave and Adam’s is a top destination for sports cards for both buyers and sellers. Their website features a handy collection calculator tool where you enter the description of cards and get an estimated worth. This provides a starting point for discussing price if you want to liquidate your collection to them. They emphasize speedy payment (within 2-3 business days) and higher offers for more valuable components of your lot containing popular stars from the sport’s seminal eras in the 1970s-1990s.
BuyMYWTC – This website is solely dedicated to buying baseball card collections online. Their staff of experts will inspect photos of your cards, check prices/values against the major industry pricing guides and make you an offer within 24 hours. Payment is typically via check or PayPal upon receipt of the cards. BuyMYWTC prides itself on fast responses, competitive prices (up to 80% of estimated values) and hassle-free transactions. The minimum lot size they will consider is a 60-page box filled with cards. Larger, more valuable collections with premier stars typically fetch the best sale prices.
Those represent some of the largest and most trusted companies that actively seek to purchase baseball card collections from individual consumers and collectors. Weighing factors like payment speed, price offered, store credit options, insurance coverage and size/value requirements can help you decide where to liquidate your cards for the best overall experience and return on your investment in the hobby. Having condition reports and organized singles will give buyers confidence and result in higher bids for your collectible baseball cards.
