The 1991 Topps baseball card set is considered one of the classic and more desirable flagship issues produced by Topps over the decades. The design has a classic retro feel that harkens back to the early 1960s Topps issues. For collectors seeking high grade specimens of these iconic cards to build a long-term investment asset, PSA grading is generally the preferred holder. For various reasons collectors may opt to keep valuable 1991 Topps cards ungraded by PSA or any third party authentication company. Let’s take a deeper look at what makes 1991 Topps cards such a compelling vintage issue and considerations for keeping them raw versus getting them slabbed by PSA.
Released in 1991 at the height of the junk wax era, the base set contains 792 cards including traded set variations. Despite exploding production runs during this period, 1991 Topps cards feature classic posed action photography and vivid colors that give them real nostalgic appeal. The set is headlined by superstars like Barry Bonds, Mark McGwire, Nolan Ryan, Ken Griffey Jr. and Cal Ripken Jr. in the prime of their careers. Bonus inserts like Topps Finest Prospects additionally make the set very collector friendly. Perhaps most importantly, the 1991 season saw Griffey win the MVP and Ripken start his iconic consecutive games played streak, forever tying those achievements to the cards from this set.
While production numbers were enormous, the 1991 Topps design has proven to endure the test of time far better than many other late 80s/early 90s issues. This is partly why raw 1991 Topps cards command reasonably strong prices even today when compared to several preceding and subsequent series from the junk wax era. For example, a nice conditioned but weak centering Ken Griffey Jr. rookie in around Good-Very Good condition can still fetch $100-150. The cards also photographed and scanned well which is a big factor in their enduring popularity online. And names like Bonds, McGwire and Ripken from this set will ensure a steady market as they were absolutely huge players throughout the 90s & 00s.
For high-end specimens though, most serious collectors agree that PSA or BGS slabs provide the best way to fully encapsulate condition and history. This allows 1991 Topps cards to be considered blue chip long term collectibles. Cracking and submitting beloved vintage cards is a process that not all collectors are comfortable with for various reasons. First, it is a risk to the condition – cards can come back lower graded than expected or even damaged in the grading process. It also removes the ability to personally assess the raw card. Most importantly, if a card gets a poor grade, its resale ability takes a big hit. This matters more for rare and valuable key cards in the set.
Keeping beloved 1991 Topps cards raw has some advantages beyond avoiding grading risks. Collectors can personally examine every nook and cranny for flaws versus relying on a numeric grade. This intimacy with the actual piece of history is meaningful to many. The raw cards also maintain flexibility in the marketplace, as they can be crossed over to either the raw or slabbed collecting worlds. Vintage Topps issues like 1991 have proven remarkably stable investments even without slabs. So long as the condition is clearly above average, raw cards won’t necessarily suffer large long-term price drops relative to their slabbed counterparts. This allows collectors to bypass slabbing costs and wait for the right selling opportunity.
For the most important vintage cards in a 1991 Topps set like rare variations, short prints or especially the Griffey and Ripken rookie cards – slabbing does provide optimal long term protection. But there is certainly an argument to keep lesser key commons and short printed substitutes raw where grading risks may outweigh potential benefits to resale value down the road. It comes down to an individual collector’s priorities, risk tolerance and intended holding timeframe. Regardless of choice to slab or keep raw, the 1991 Topps design ensures these cards will remain a classic of the vintage era for decades to come.
While PSA encapsulation maximizes condition certainty and favors blue chip status long term – there are good reasons experienced collectors choose to appreciate and store their 1991 Topps baseball treasures raw as a personal collection. Both raw and slabbed examples from this truly iconic set deserve space in any vintage card portfolio.