Tag Archives: should

SHOULD YOU INVEST IN BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

Should You Invest in Baseball Cards? The Pros and Cons to Consider

Baseball cards have been popular collectibles for over a century, dating back to the late 1800s. With the rise of the hobby in the 1980s and 1990s, millions of people started amassing collections of cards featuring their favorite players. While collecting cards can be a fun pursuit for any fan, many also wonder if baseball cards represent a viable long-term investment. Let’s explore some of the key factors to consider regarding the potential risks and rewards of investing in baseball cards.

Investing in high-value vintage cards

Some of the most sought-after baseball cards were produced in the early 20th century from the 1910s through the 1950s, prior to the widespread use of color printing. Rare T206 Honus Wagner cards from 1909 in near-mint condition have sold for over $3 million. But cards of that age are extremely scarce in high grades. Most other pre-war tobacco cards and early Topps issues can still fetch thousands or even hundreds of thousands for keys pieces in top condition with well-centered images and bright colors.

For investors willing to do extensive research, build relationships with experts, and wait patiently for the right vintage cards to surface on the market, there is legitimate long-term potential. Keep in mind that once a card is purchased, conservement and authentication measures are required to prove its integrity and provenance if reselling at a later date. Insurance is also advisable for truly high-end pieces. Overall condition is paramount, so intense scrutiny is needed to avoid overpaying for cards with flaws.

Locating and buying the right investment-caliber vintage cards requires considerable time, expertise, and financial resources. Many collectors will never find affordable opportunities to acquire the true blue-chip cards most likely to appreciate substantially. And even for expensive possessions like pristine ’52 Topps or ’33 Goudey cards, there are no guarantees – market demand can shift over generations.

Focusing on modern stars

A potentially more accessible approach is targeting modern rookie cards of superstar players still early in their careers. If the athlete goes on to have a Hall of Fame caliber career, first-year cards could gain tremendous value, especially for popular figures who help sustain fan interest for decades. But again, condition is critical.

Some examples that have grown steeply in value in recent years include baseball’s current generation of megastars like Mike Trout, Bryce Harper, Mookie Betts, Juan Soto, and Ronald Acuña Jr. Their base rookie cards from flagship Topps sets have increased five to ten times or more since issue. Numbered parallels and autographs have multiplied even further.

As with any investments in sports memorabilia, playing career longevity is not guaranteed. Injuries or sudden decline in production could undermine what was once seen as a surefire long-term stake. And short printing runs may not create the same multi-generational demand as the most prominent figures from baseball’s golden eras in the 1950s-1970s. Patience is still required to allow markets to fully recognize a player’s historical status.

Factors driving card values up and down

Several attributes influence value increases or decreases in baseball cards over time:

Player performance: Strong on-field production extends interest and demand for a player’s cards long after retirement. Injuries or early decline usually suppressed increases.

Career milestones: Achieving 3,000 hits, 500 home runs, election to the Hall of Fame are all catalysts for renewed collecting interest and price jumps.

Printing quantities: Lower print runs heighten scarcity and desirability. Common cards have less upside.

Condition: Even top rookie cards aren’t worth much in worn, creased, or damaged condition. Near-mint or better preserves value.

Grading: Third-party authentication from PSA or BGS adds to a card’s verifiability and establishes an agreed-upon quality standard followed in the marketplace.

Market saturation: When too many investors are chasing too few coveted vintage cards, overpricing can occur temporarily until equilibrium returns.

Counterfeiting: As values rise, so does incentive to produce fraudulent copies reducing authentic versions’ cachet and collectibility over the long haul.

For investment purposes, focusing on legitimately scarce, high-quality pieces from renowned players seems most likely to produce percentage price increases that exceed general inflation over decades although returns are not guaranteed. Diversification also reduces risk compared to wagering on a single athlete’s collectibles. Strong comprehension of market trends is paramount before committing large sums.

Costs to consider beyond the initial card prices

While an affordable vintagecard or future star’s rookie could be purchased, additional investment is required to properly realize returns:

Grading fees: Often several hundred dollars per card to receive third-party authenticity, even more for express handling. Re-holdering also costs money periodically to keep high grades.

Insurance: Valuable collectibles should be insured for damage, theft, or loss against natural/man-made disasters. Premiums add up annually.

Storage/security: Protecting cards requires a safe, preferably climate-controlled area limiting natural deterioration. Professional storage also charges monthly or annual fees.

Selling costs: Once cards are in your collection, expense is incurred selling through auction houses or consignment dealers taking commission cuts.

So factor in these auxiliary investment costs when initially projecting potential profits. Ballpark at least 15% to 25% more may need to be budgeted beyond acquisition to properly manage cards as assets over the long-term. Full analysis and expense planning is prudent.

The bottom line on investing in baseball cards

For passionate collectors looking to blend enjoyment with long-term store of value, selectively investing in the highest-caliber vintage and modern rookie cards of traditional star players can make sense. Returns aren’t guaranteed, but appreciation percentages have exceeded inflation for proven investments in authenticated pieces showcased through reputable third-parties like PSA/BGS over many decades.

Baseball cards require patience as an alternative investment class. Only serious researchers should consider using substantial funds. And full understanding of risks and regular costs is essential before pursuing appreciating card valuations as part of a diversified portfolio. For most, casual collecting of favorite players remains the primary motivation without dependable income expectation from cards. But for dedicated investors, solid rewards could be realized with due diligence applying discipline to choices and care of possessions.

The hobby remains popular thanks to the allure of its colorful cardboard history. By properly educating yourself on dynamics of this specialized marketplace, appreciating cards present viable prospects for long-term investors able to navigate fluctuations and commit for the long haul. Just be sure any financial plans conservatively factor all potential expenses and uncertainties to avoid excessive risk. With diligence, the playing field can be slowly angled in your favor.

SHOULD I INVEST IN BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

Thinking about investing in baseball cards but not sure if it’s a good idea? Baseball cards can be an intriguing investment option for those interested in the hobby and the potential for financial gain. It’s important to understand both the pros and cons of investing in cards before diving in. Let’s take a deeper look at whether investing in baseball cards could make sense for you.

To start, there are a few reasons why baseball cards have appeal as a potential investment. Perhaps the biggest factor is nostalgia – baseball has a long history in America and cards ignite fond memories for many people who collected them in their childhoods. This nostalgia drives ongoing interest and collector demand for vintage cards, especially for star players from the past. As long as baseball remains popular in the U.S., there will likely continue to be a market for collectibles related to the sport and its legends.

Another potential positive is scarcity. Baseball cards have been produced commercially since the late 1880s but the early decades saw more limited print runs compared to modern production. As cards from the sport’s earliest eras grow even rarer through loss and deterioration over decades and centuries, the surviving high-grade examples take on increasing value for collectors. Getting your hands on pristine vintage cards of iconic players from the early 20th century or before could result in significant appreciation over time if taken care of and preserved properly.

Cards for star rookie players can also offer good long-term investment potential. Interest is often highest right around the year a major new star emerges, making their rookie cards worth pursuing. Examples include cards for players like Mickey Mantle, Ken Griffey Jr., or Mike Trout. If the player lives up to expectations and has a Hall of Fame career, those early cards stand to increase substantially in value as the years pass. Timing the markets for stars just starting out takes some research and feel however.

On a similar note, limited print specialty sets tend to have collector demand that drives higher prices compared to regular issue cards. Examples include Topps Traded, Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects, and Topps Update Series cards which feature popular young prospects. Numbered parallel versions inserted randomly in packs at much lower quantities also hold investment potential if featuring big names pre-breakout.

Some other things that can boost long-term card values include special autographs, rare serial numbers, desirable card conditions grades of high “gem mint” status or above, and unique variations, parallels, or one-of-one printing plates.Cards meeting these type of scarce, condition sensitive criteria tend to attract serious collectors actively tracking specific sets and are more likely to appreciate steadily in a stable investment climate.

It’s also important to recognize that baseball cards carry significant risks as investments as well. Perhaps the biggest issue is liquidity – it can be difficult to quickly sell large collections or individual high-value cards, especially in downward markets. This poses problems if immediate cash is suddenly needed. You have to be comfortable holding cards as long-term investments that may not be easily turned back into cash on a whim.

Pricing transparency is another issue. While auction prices from companies like PWCC or Goldin help establish ranges, the secondary card market lacks Wall Street-style reporting. Values are ultimately what willing buyers agree to pay, and there are endless factors that drive demand up and down for any given card at a given moment in time. Sudden swings are common.

Another risk lies in the unpredictable nature of any given player’s career. Even the greatest talents sometimes fail to live up to expectations or encounter injuries that derail Hall of Fame trajectories. Cards invested in thinking a player is a “sure thing” can plummet in value rapidly with any change in fortunes on the field. Research, diversification across many players, and patience are required.

Perhaps most significantly, the baseball card market itself is inherently volatile and unpredictable. Periods of inflation, where investor mania and demand drives prices to unreasonable heights, will inevitably be followed by corrections as realities set in. The post-pandemic market is highly reminiscent of boom/bust cycles seen in the early 1990s Junk Wax Era and late 1980s. Without an intimate understanding of broader economic cycles, it’s easy to get caught investing at market peaks.

On a final negative note, transaction fees add up quickly in this hobby/industry. Between grading costs, seller commissions, shipping and other expenses, what may seem like profits on paper can be easily eaten away before an investor even nets any returns. Proper accounting of all associated costs is a must for calculating true profitability of long-term baseball card holdings.

So in summary – baseball cards can offer intriguing opportunities due to nostalgia, scarce supply of sought-after vintage specimens, and market inefficiencies related to new player rookie cards and limited issues. Liquidity issues, lack of pricing transparency, career risks, market volatility, and high transaction costs involved all contribute significant risks as well. For investing, patience, discipline, and comprehensive research skills are vital traits, as is an understanding of both baseball’s history and the broader economic cycles that impact speculative collectibles over decades.

Diversification across many eras, players, and card types/conditions can help mitigate some risks. But overall, baseball cards are best viewed as very speculative investments requiring a long-term buy-and-hold mindset through expected ups and downs. Only allocating a small part of a broader portfolio makes the most sense for those looking to add cards more for the enjoyment of the hobby rather than expectation of achieving fast or guaranteed profits. With the right approach, collecting and investing in baseball cards can provide decades of interest – but there are no sure things, so investing wisely requires managing risks appropriately.

While baseball cards hold some appeal as speculative long-term investments tied to the enduring popularity of America’s pastime, their many risks also mean they should realistically only be a small part of diversified collection for hobbyists – not viewed as a primary investment vehicle. Patience, research skills, and understanding broader economic factors are absolute musts for navigating the ups and downs of this inherently volatile market over the decades. As with any collectibles, only invest amounts one can genuinely afford to risk losing without creating unwanted financial issues further down the road. With proper perspective and prudent approach, cards can remain a source of interest and potential profits – but there are no guarantees, so managing risks intelligently is paramount.

SHOULD YOU GET YOUR BASEBALL CARDS GRADED

Leave a reply

Getting your baseball cards professionally graded is a big decision that should not be taken lightly. There are advantages and disadvantages to consider, so it is important to understand the grading process and how it can impact the value and preservation of your collection.

One of the main reasons collectors consider grading is to verify the condition and authenticity of valuable cards. A professional grading company will examine the card under high-powered magnification and assign it a grade on the industry-standard 1-10 scale. This gives buyers confidence in exactly what kind of shape the card is in without having to inspect it themselves. Receiving a high grade from a reputable service like PSA or BGS can significantly boost a card’s worth, especially for rare and iconic cards that are in pristine condition.

The grading process itself comes at a cost. Major companies charge fees of $10-20 per card on average, with express or bulk order options that may lower that amount slightly. For a collector with dozens or hundreds of cards, those fees can add up quite quickly. There is also the risk that a card you believe is in mint condition could come back with a grade of 8 or lower. This means the card’s value may not increase as much as anticipated to justify the cost of submitting it.

Another factor to weigh is how a graded card’s value changes over time compared to raw, ungraded cards. High-end vintage cards have historically held their value well or increased if they receive top Gem Mint 10 grades from services like PSA. But for modern cards, there is no guarantee a PSA 10 will command a premium over a raw near-mint copy in 5-10 years as the bubble could burst on certain players or sets. The market is always shifting, so grading is not a sure-fire path to future profits.

Protecting the condition of valuable cards long-term is a key selling point for grading advocates. Snap-fits holders and stamped certification help deter tampering and authenticate the card years later. Raw cards are at much higher risk of damage from handling, moisture, heat exposure, and accidental alterations. But acrylic cases can also potentially damage cards over decades if they develop cracks or lose a perfect seal around the edges. Outer boxes, binders, and custom storage methods offer graded-level protection without grading fees.

For collectors grading only their true prize possessions, like rare vintage rookies, the cost is often worth the verification and preservation benefits. But for teams sets, modern parallels, and cards in average overall condition, raw storage in custom binders and fitting sleeves may suffice. As a general guideline, most experts say to only submit cards valued at $100 or more raw to grading unless authenticity or condition assurance is paramount. Below that, the fees are often not worthwhile for the average collector.

The exploding popularity of graded cards on the secondary market has also led to a new issue – the potential of “regraded” cards. Unscrupulous dealers may submit the same card to multiple grading services, hoping for a single high grade that can then be marketed as though it came directly from the grading company. Legitimate collectors often prefer cards that still have originalSubmission Authentication stickers intact to prevent regraded deception. Grading services are aware of the issue and implement anti-tamperingfeatures, but buyers still need to do diligence.

Card grading makes the most sense when the potential upgrade in value clearly outweighs fees for high-dollar cards, prized rookies, or collectibles being sold long-term. But for team sets, modern parallels, and average quality vintage, raw storage remains a prudent alternative. Collectors should carefully weigh the pros and cons based on their individual needs around condition verification, value increases, and preservation before deciding to submit prized pieces to the grading process. An educated approach is required to maximize returns in this evolving marketplace segment.

SHOULD I GET MY BASEBALL CARDS GRADED

Leave a reply

Deciding whether or not to get your baseball cards graded can be a difficult decision. On one hand, getting cards professionally graded could potentially increase their value, but the grading process also comes with costs that may not provide a good return on investment depending on the card. In this article, we will take an in-depth look at the pros and cons of baseball card grading to help you decide if it makes sense for your collection.

Why Get Cards Graded?

One of the main reasons people consider getting their cards graded is to potentially increase their value. Certified grading from reputable companies like PSA, Beckett, BGS or SGC adds an extra layer of legitimacy and assurance of condition that buyers are willing to pay more for. Establishing the official grade helps narrow down what condition the card is in for potential buyers and provides a sense of trust in the assessment. For rare and valuable vintage cards from the 50s-80s especially, a professional grade can justify paying a significant premium compared to raw, ungraded cards of the same condition.

Grading also properly encapsulates and seals the card in protective plastic, slowing down the aging process and preserving the condition long-term compared to loose cards in sleeves or binders. This is appealing for valuable investments that collectors want to keep untarnished for decades. The slab also makes cards easier to physically handle, store and display without risking scratching or other damage versus loose cards.

Getting a card graded boosts liquidity and provides access to a bigger pool of interested buyers on the popular major grading company auction sites like eBay. With tens of millions of collectors worldwide, having a card “slabbed” helps connect sellers to more bidders internationally. Buyers are generally more confident in the presented condition and authenticity versus raw cards of questionable history. Grading improves marketing appeal and helps fetch higher realized prices at auction in many cases.

Cons & Drawbacks to Consider

On the other hand, there are some notable cons and costs to weigh carefully before submitting cards for grading:

Cost – Professional grading is not cheap, ranging from $10-30 per basic modern card submission on average. Prices go up for express grading options. Bulk submissions discount the per card cost but still require a sizeable upfront investment that may not yield worthwhile returns for common cards.

No Guarantee of Grade – While reputable companies strive for consistency, grading is subjective and different evaluators may assess the same card differently on a given day. There’s no guaranteed outcome, so spending $10-30 to receive a lower grade than expected is a risk.

Poorly Centered or Damaged Cards Won’t Benefit – Grading only adds value to centered, high quality examples. Heavily off-center cards or those with creases, stains or other flaws may receive a grade that doesn’t increase their price compared to just being raw.

Slab Cracking Over Time – The hard plastic slabs can develop stress cracks after years of handling/display that compromise the grade while cards are stuck inside until replaced at further cost by the grading company.

Storage & Display Hindrances – Many collectors prefer displaying raw cards in personal binders versus shelving slab boxes. Slabs also take up more space long-term versus raw cards in boxes.

Risk of Fraud – A very small percentage of unscrupulously graded cards slip through that were altered, trimmed or don’t match the stated grade. Buyer beware is important when purchasing solely based on grades.

Who Should Consider Grading?

In most cases, it’s only truly worthwhile to grade high-end vintage rookies, stars and extremely rare cards with a proven track record of higher prices in graded form. For such cards, the benefits outweigh the costs long-term as a sound investment. Some additional guidelines:

Rookie cards of hockey stars from the 50s-70s have shown large appreciation in top PSA/BGS grades

Extensively research a particular player/card first to analyze past graded auction performance

Stick to true “keys” rather than player collections, parallels, inserts likely not to increase in price

Consult population reports to gauge future grade rarity/demand before submitting a card

Consider bulk/package submission discounts for teams sets, but don’t overestimate returns

Consult with coin/card shops about local consignment grading for a small commission fee

The vast majority of modern cards, inserts, parallels and such will never return the grading cost. For these, preserving raw condition in one-touch magnetic holders or penny sleeves suffices. Only committed long-term investors positioning themselves to wait decades for graded cards to appreciate meaningfully should consider grading average material without a proven track record. Otherwise, the costs outweigh potential benefits.

Whether grading is prudent for your cards depends on doing research into demand and returns for similar graded properties historically. Only high-end, condition-sensitive vintage keys are typically a sure bet to consistently realize higher prices following professional authentication and encapsulation long-term. Most material is better preserved raw to pass down generations still enjoying the cards rather than paying nonrefundable fees on a gamble. With care and diligence, both raw collectors and those pursuing grades can build wonderful collections.

SHOULD I SELL MY BASEBALL CARDS NOW

Leave a reply

Thinking about selling your baseball card collection? With the collectibles market experiencing shifts due to economic conditions and generational interests changing, now may seem like either the perfect or worst time to sell your cards. There are many factors to consider when making this decision.

The Values of Baseball Cards Fluctuate

Like any collectible, the values of baseball cards rise and fall depending on supply and demand in the marketplace. The late 1980s and early 1990s saw immense growth in values, fueled partly by the entry of a new generation of young collectors. A boom inevitably leads to a bust, and the baseball card market crashed in the mid-1990s due to overproduction. It took nearly 20 years for values to recover to pre-crash levels.

More recently, the 2010s saw another boom in the collectibles space, powered by factors like growth in online selling platforms, new enthusiast demographics, and nostalgia driven by the childhood collections of Millennials. Iconic rookie cards like a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle or a 2009 Topps Update Mike Trout rookie fetched record prices at auction.

The long-term impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic and 40-year-high inflation are causing economic turmoil, while a renewed focus on non-physical experiences among younger consumers could reduce future demand for sporting memorabilia. Cards from the late 1980s and 1990s boom may be especially vulnerable if a new downturn occurs. Their values are not supported by on-field performance decades later.

On the other hand, if inflation persists for years, tangible assets like baseball cards could maintain value better than cash. Rookies of current stars may hold value since the players’ primes are still ahead. But as with any commodity, there are no guarantees – only educated guesses – about future prices.

Analyze the Composition and Condition of Your Collection

Not all baseball cards are equal in terms of value. Rookie cards, autographed memorabilia cards, serially numbered parallels, and cards featuring all-time great players in high grades are where the big money resides. Bulky collections consisting mainly of commons from the junk wax era (late 1980s-early 1990s) will not realize peak values.

Condition is also critical. Even a valuable card loses most of its potential profit if damaged, worn or off-center. Have your high-end cards professionally graded to verify their condition-census ranking before a sale. Low-grade versions of stars’ rookie cards may still sell, but won’t capture maximum prices. Take the time to properly assess what you have.

Determine Your Motivation and Optimal Sales Strategy

Are you selling for necessity due to financial hardship, or merely cashing in a potentially rising asset? Is your primary goal to maximize profits, or quickly downsize a collection? These priorities shape the optimal sales plan.

For maximum value, consign top cards to season veteran auction houses like PWCC or Goldin Auctions. Accept that the process may take months to achieve the highest bids. Selling individually also allows you to set reserves to avoid unwanted lowball offers.

If time is a factor, listing valuable groups on eBay through an established dealer can yield acceptable overall returns within a couple weeks, for a 12-15% commission. Moving bulk lots of commons through a site like COMC can also net fair proceeds with minimal work.

A local card shop may buy everything together via a cash deal. While convenient, this strategy often means settling for 50-70 cents on the dollar compared to patient individual sales. Factors like the shop’s current demand influence their best offer too.

Don’t Neglect Other Costs

When calculating profit from sales, factor in expenses like grading fees (up to $50 per card), commissions to sellers like eBay (10%) or auction houses (12-15%), and shipping charges. Online selling portals impose other nominal fees as well. Card shows with table fees for sellers are also an option in some areas.

Be aware of potential tax consequences. The IRS views collecting appreciations as an investment subject to capital gains taxes. Profits over $40,000 in a single year from “occasional” sales may face a 15% federal tax. Consider consulting a accountant if realizing substantial earnings. Careful record-keeping of purchase prices is also important come tax time.

Patience is Often Rewarded in this Hobby

While an urge to cash in lingering cards exists, those who can wait are frequently rewarded. Many iconic stars are still in their primes, ensuring continued demand. Patience has benefits – such as avoiding potential down cycles by holding valuables long-term. Sitting cards until after retirement of attached players also maximizes nostalgia and interest levels.

The baseball card market endures due partly to its multi-generational appeal. But short-term economic and collecting trends can influence prices too. By comprehensively auditing a collection, understanding the various sales options, factoring taxes and expenses, and considering goals and timelines, collectors can make an optimal decision about whether now is the shrewdest time to convert cards back into cash. An individual assessment is needed based on each person’s unique situation and goals. With careful planning, both profit and enjoyment can be realized from any baseball card collection.

SHOULD I GET MY VINTAGE BASEBALL CARDS GRADED

Leave a reply

Getting vintage baseball cards professionally graded is a big decision that requires careful consideration. On one hand, grading can significantly increase the value of high quality vintage cards by providing a verified assessment of condition. The grading process itself poses risks like damage and costs money in fees. Let’s take a deeper look at the pros and cons of grading to help you determine if it makes sense for your collection.

One major benefit of having cards professionally graded is that it establishes an impartial validation of the card’s condition. Grading services like PSA, BGS, SGC analyze cards under stringent guidelines and assign them numeric condition grades on a consistent scale from 1 to 10. This provides transparency that wasn’t previously possible with raw cards. Buyers look to the grade as an objective measure of quality, so cards that grade highly are proportionally more valuable in the marketplace.

For the most desirable vintage cards in pristine condition, grading can yield huge returns. A Mickey Mantle rookie that grades a PSA 10 could sell for hundreds of thousands compared to just a few thousand for the same card raw. Even common cards can see significant boosts, like a 1960 Topps Roberto Clemente that might sell for $50 ungraded fetching $200+ in PSA 8-9 condition. The grading essentially acts as third party insurance that the card is exactly as presented without surprises, giving buyers confidence to pay top dollar.

Not only does a high grade increase demand, but it also attracts more serious collectors and dealers. Cards that crack the elite PSA 10 or BGS Black Label category enter a completely different stratosphere, transacting only between the deepest of hobby pockets. For a true condition sensitive vintage gem in your collection, the exponential value increase from a perfect grade could far outweigh the costs of submitting.

Another major plus is that by encapsulating cards in tamper-proof plastic holders, third party grading provides protection that raw cards lack. Card savers and one-touches leave cards susceptible to damage from fingerprints, accidental creases or waves from being shuffled in boxes. Once certified, graded cards are safely sealed and the case itself acts as a permanent record of the card’s original condition. This preservation of condition is important not just for value, but for collectors who want lifelong enjoyment from their vintage cards.

There are also real potential downsides to consider before submitting cards for grading. First and foremost is the risk that the grading service damages or loses the card in the authentication process. Mistakes do happen, like minor edge nicks or creases inadvertently added during the handling required for close examination. Some unlucky collectors have even had cards completely destroyed by grading mishaps. While reputable services have insurance policies, no amount of compensation makes up for losing an irreplaceable piece of history.

Another cost is simply the fees charged, which have risen substantially in recent years due to increased demand. Getting a single card graded by PSA, BGS or SGC usually starts around $20-30 per card for regular tier service, and climbs from there depending on how fast you want the turnaround. Add in the shipping costs both ways and it’s not unusual for the authentication of one card to cost $50 or more before even considering any potential value increase. For larger bulk submissions, the total bill can easily run into the hundreds or thousands of dollars – a major investment simply to validate condition.

The lengthy waiting periods involved to have cards graded also detract for many collectors. Standard service levels routinely take 3-6 months or longer these days due to crushing backlogs industry-wide. Some feel the long delays diminish the joy of collecting in the short-term. And there is always a risk that economic or hobby conditions could change unfavorably by the time cards are eventually returned, decreasing their worth.

Not every card necessarily demands grading approval to retain or maximize value. Common issues of iconic stars like Mickey Mantle or Babe Ruth may remain profitable raw pieces even with minor flaws, as nostalgia trumps surface imperfections for many collectors and fans. And esoteric vintage cards with dubious origins could actually receive lower “authenticity” grades that diminish resale demand compared to being left raw and untouched. In these cases, the grading costs may outweigh any incremental sale price increase from a numerical condition assessment.

Before submitting your cards for authentication there are several key factors to weigh carefully: the specific cards involved, their projected grade, current market conditions, and your own personal collection and investment goals. Take time to do thorough research on comps of similar graded cards to realistically forecast potential returns. It’s generally accepted that only the highest quality gems benefit most from professional validation, while lesser condition or more common cards are best left raw. With care and selectivity, third party grading has the power to significantly appreciate your prized pieces of baseball history. But it’s not right for each and every card – so choose submissions wisely after fully understanding the pros and cons.

SHOULD YOU GET BASEBALL CARDS GRADED

Leave a reply

Should You Get Baseball Cards Graded? The Case For and Against Grading Your Cards

For decades, baseball card collectors have debated the pros and cons of getting their prized cards professionally graded. On one hand, grading provides authentication and encapsulation to preserve condition while higher grades can significantly boost a card’s value. The grading process also presents costs and risks that must be weighed against potential benefits. This article will examine both sides of the grading debate so you can decide if submitting your cards is the right choice for your collection.

The Case For Grading Cards

Perhaps the biggest potential advantage of grading is establishing a card’s authenticity and condition grade, two critical factors that determine value. While most collectors can generally assess condition, professional grading removes ambiguity and dispute over a card’s exact grade. The encapsulation provided by top slabbing companies like PSA, BGS, and SGC also protects cards from further handling wear that could reduce grades and value over time.

Receiving an official high grade, especially a pristine mint 9 or flawless mint 10, takes a common card and transforms it into a true gem that commands a sizable premium. The wider the gap between raw and graded value, the more financial sense grading makes since submission fees are recoupable. Iconic vintage rookies and rare modern parallels routinely fetch thousands or even tens of thousands more with strong grades versus raw.

Grading is essential for high-end cards destined for long-term holding or eventual resale where maximizing gains is the goal. Certified cards occupy the top rungs of the hobby in terms of desirability and prices realized at auction. They are considered the gold standard for registry sets as well as prestigious collection goals like obtaining every graded rookie card of a marquee player.

Grading also provides peace of mind. Encapsulation gives collectors confidence cards will stay as fresh as the day they were slabbed, future-proofing long-term preservation and display. Authentication reassures buyers the graded card they just bought sight-unseen is exactly as described. This increases demand and helps maintain resale values over the decades. Some collectors simply enjoy proudly showing off shiny, certified cardboard bearing prestigious company logos and promise of quality control.

The Case Against Grading Cards

On the other hand, grading is not perfect or risk-free. Some potential cons to consider include costs, submission risks, and reduced liquidity versus raw cards.

Submitting cards involves fees paid to the grading company as well as shipping expenses. Budget $10-30+ per card depending on service selected which eats into profits on all but the rarest cards expected to grade highly. Multiple cards must be precisely packaged and carefully sent off too, adding complexity over simply buying and selling raw.

Once in a grading company’s hands, there is always a small but inherent risk of damage, loss, or an unexpected conservative grade that limits financial upside compared to staying raw. Reconsideration requests against perceived grading inaccuracies generally do not correct initial grades either. These outcomes mean submitters sometimes fail to recoup costs or even lose money on cards they thought sure-fire candidates.

The graded market is generally less liquid than raw due to fewer potential buyers/sellers. Most collectors are not targeting slabbed mid-range cards but instead seek raw copies for personal collections at lower price points. Slabbed cards also remove opportunity for condition/authenticity upgrades found in raw cards also, limiting appeal to ambitious upgraders.

Lastly, some collectors simply dislike the notion of permanently encasing treasured pieces of cardboard. They prefer displaying raw cards as a purist appreciation of the printed paper medium itself. While slabbing protects long-term, it eliminates flexibility of periodically appreciating condition details with naked eyes. This intangible sentimental attachment to raw cards as designed artwork is worth considering too for certain collectors.

Making The Right Choice

Ultimately, whether grading is worthwhile depends on an individual card, collection goals, and risk tolerance. Sensible submission guidelines include:

Iconic vintage stars and key modern parallels likely to grade high and boost value significantly.

Cards intended for long-term investment holding where authenticity and preservation matter most.

Cards headed to auction markets where certified cards typically outperform.

Pieces bound for registry sets where graded status is standard or preferred.

For most modern base cards in average condition, grading often does not pencil out financially and removes liquidity. Similarly, sentimental favorites best stay raw. Test the market first by checking recent eBay sales data on similar certified vs raw copies to gauge potential upside and chances of hitting a home run grade. Carefully weigh costs versus outcomes to make informed decisions benefiting your collection long-term. Done right, grading maximizes certain cards’ full potential – but it’s not right for every collector or situation either.

The decision whether to grade ultimately involves balancing authentication, preservation, and financial factors against costs, risks, preferences around viewing raw cards, and liquidity needs. Coming down on one side or the other depends on each collector’s particular situation and goals for their unique baseball card collection. With an understanding of the full picture, you can make the choice best serving your interests long into the future.

SHOULD I SELL MY BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

Deciding whether to sell your baseball card collection is a big decision with many factors to consider. On one hand, selling your cards could generate some cash, but on the other hand you may end up parting with collectibles that could appreciate in value or have sentimental meaning. Let’s take an in-depth look at some important things to weigh regarding this choice.

The value of your collection:
How much your baseball card collection is actually worth will play a major role in determining if you should sell. Getting your cards professionally appraised is a good first step to establish a realistic baseline value. Consider factors like the condition and print runs of the cards, how many high value rookie cards or autographs you have, if you have full or nearly full sets, etc. Generally speaking, the more valuable and in demand the cards are, the stronger case there is for selling now versus holding onto them.

Potential for future appreciation:
While past performance is no guarantee of future results, some baseball cards have proven to be solid long term investments that appreciate well above inflation. Rookie cards of all-time great players especially tend to hold or increase in value as the player’s legend grows after retirement. You need to weigh if you think your cards have strong potential to be worth noticeably more say 10-20 years from now versus today. Newer cards carry more uncertainty than established veterans in this regard.

Your personal financial situation:
Do you have pressing bills to pay, large purchases coming up, or other reasons you need cash now? Or are you in solid financial shape where you don’t necessarily need to monetize your collection right away? Selling makes more sense if the money will be put to good immediate use, whereas holding makes more if your situation allows patience. Consider how sale proceeds could be better utilized versus keeping the cards.

Sentimental attachment:
Some collections are kept more for nostalgia, memories of collecting with family/friends, or just sheer love of the players/teams represented than monetary value alone. Selling sentimental pieces may leave you feeling like you lost a connection to your past. Weigh if you’re mostly attached to individual cards or the overall collection as a whole. Selling select duplicates could still free up funds while keeping your favorites.

Transaction costs:
If your collection is valuable enough, you may find brokerages or auction houses willing to facilitate a sale for a commission. But for smaller lots, such costs may eat significantly into proceeds. Consider researching the options to maximize net dollars from a sale. Selling individually on eBay may net more after fees than one bulk sale. Grading high value cards first could also boost prices greatly.

Ease of liquidating:
Unless you have true gem mint graded cards from iconic rookies, actually selling cards one by one takes a lot of active effort. You need to take photos, write listings, field inquiries, package and ship individually. For larger volumes, this could become a part time job in itself. Consider if you are willing/able to invest that kind of time to slowly unload over months versus getting everything sold quickly with less individual dollars.

Taxes:
Be sure to check capital gains tax rates for baseball card sales in your location. In the U.S., any profits above a certain amount in a single year could face taxes. Keeping thorough records of purchase prices, individual sale proceeds and dates is crucial for maximizing your post-tax profit from a sale. Consulting a tax advisor may give you tips to structure a sale to minimize obligations.

Overall market conditions:
Like any collectible category, baseball card prices rise and fall depending on overall investor demand and money available in the marketplace. Selling during a peak period when many collectors/investors have discretionary funds to spend could maximize value. Similarly being patient and waiting out any short term dips has its advantages. Monitor broader trends for timing insights.

There is no universally right answer when it comes to selling your baseball card collection, it ultimately depends on weighing these varied factors towards your unique situation and objectives. The keys are properly valuing what you have, being honest about attachments, considering future appreciation potential realistically, and timing a sale intelligently if chosen. With thorough research and analysis, you can feel confident about maximizing the returns or sentimental value of your cards whichever path you take.

SHOULD I OPEN OLD PACKS OF BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

Should I Open Old Packs of Baseball Cards? The Pros and Cons to Consider

Many collectors have old packs of baseball cards sitting in their collections that they’ve held onto for decades. At some point, the question arises – should I open these packs? Opening older packs of cards from the 1950s, 60s, 70s, and 80s can seem very tempting. But there are several factors to weigh before ripping into those wrappers. In this article, we’ll explore some of the pros and cons of opening vintage baseball card packs to help you decide what is the best course of action.

Pro: Discovering Hidden Gems

One of the biggest appeals of opening old packs is the chance of finding a valuable card hidden inside. Cards from the vast majority of vintage packs are not worth much at all today. There is always the slim possibility of unearthing a true “gem” – like a rookie card of a Hall of Famer, rare error card, or short printed parallel. These types of hits could be worth thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars depending on the player and condition. The excitement and rush of potentially striking gold is a huge motivator for many collectors to open their vintage packs.

Con: Loss of Collectible Pack Value

If the packs are truly vintage and still sealed in their original packaging, their collectible value as unopened items often far exceeds the combined worth of the few random cards inside. Sealed 1950s and 1960s packs in particular can be extremely valuable to sealed pack collectors, sometimes selling for hundreds or even thousands of dollars depending on the brand, set, and level of packaging preservation. Once a pack is opened, its appeal as a sealed collectible is forever lost, even if the cards inside ended up being particularly valuable themselves. So there is inherent risk in sacrificing a pack’s sealed value for the gamble of its contents.

Pro: Satisfaction of Reveling History

For collectors who love the history and nostalgia of the hobby, opening old packs can provide a deeply fulfilling experience. Getting to admire vintage cardboard designs, advertisements, and production techniques only enhanced by decades of aging can make one feel more connected to how the original purchasers may have experienced the packs. Being able to view the cards in the order they were originally packaged also satisfies a desire to mimic the surprise and anticipation fans in earlier eras felt when ripping packs off the rack. This can make the risk of diminished monetary value worth it for the historical experience alone.

Con: Condition and Playability Factors

Cards from 50+ year old packs are highly unlikely to grade well no matter the centering or edges due to the inevitable aging effects of time like creasing, staining, fading, and so on. Even light play from their original owners could diminish a rare card’s value today. At the same time, 1958 Hank Aaron rookies almost certainly wouldn’t pass the condition standards to be considered “game-used” either. So opening packs severely limits preserving collector value based on condition grades or potential authenticated provenance that sealed packs maintain. This can offset any monetary benefit from discovering a key rookie within.

Pro: Personal Satisfaction and Enjoyment

At the end of the day, a collectible is meant to be enjoyed, not merely preserved as an investment. Opening vintage packs one has held for decades as a personal collection milestone could bring great enjoyment and satisfaction that offset any lessened dollar value proposition. Getting to directly handle cards that are significant pieces of history while sharing the experience with loved ones of the hobby can create special memories worth more than any single card’s price if individually slabbed and sold. Not every collectible decision needs to have a profit-driven motivation behind it for it to still feel worthwhile.

Con: Potential Damage from Improper Opening

There is real risk of damaging key cards irreparably if packs are not opened with extreme care and proper techniques. Adhesives can deteriorate and become extremely brittle, causing cards to crack or flake during removal if too much force is used. Aromatic solvents used back in the day like benzene make materials extra prone to disintegration as well. Without proper archival tools and cautious technique, a valuable mint rookie could be torn trying to remove it from the tightly adhered backing, forever compromising its condition and significantly decreasing its collector value. The stress of opening isn’t worth the gamble for some.

So in summary – while opening vintage packs can provide excitement, nostalgia and personal satisfaction, there are legitimate collectors’ arguments both for and against the practice. Ultimately the choice comes down to weighing preservation of pack and card condition/history against the thrill of discovery. Sealed items are safest investments long term, but opening allows unique experiences collecting can’t replace. Consult preservation experts if you decide to open, and consider both options equally valid depending on your personal priorities as a vintage baseball card collector. With care and moderation, both sealed and opened vintage items have their important place in the hobby.

In the end, there’s no universally right answer – it depends on one’s individual goals and risks they find acceptable within their own collection. with care and moderation, both sealed and opened packs have their place among collectors. The choice ultimately comes down to what provides the most enjoyment and satisfaction given each collector’s unique circumstances.

SHOULD I OPEN MY UNOPENED BASEBALL CARDS

Leave a reply

Deciding whether to open unopened baseball cards is a dilemma many collectors face. On one hand, opening the packs provides the excitement of seeing what cards you pulled, but it also reduces the mint condition and monetary value of the cards. There are pros and cons to both opening and leaving cards sealed that collectors need to carefully weigh. Let’s take a deeper look at the factors involved in making this decision.

Perhaps the biggest consideration is how opening cards impacts their monetary value. Sealed packs and boxes appreciate in value over time as they become harder to find in pristine condition. Leaving items in their original wrap protects them from any chance of damage or wear that opened items face. This perfect factory state commands top dollar from serious collectors. For example, unopened 1980s and 1990s packs that originally sold for $1-3 can now sell for $50-100 or more depending on the brand, set, and player inclusion odds. Highly sought after unopened cases of cards from the junk wax era have been known to sell for thousands.

Naturally, any card pulled from a freshly cracked pack will not carry the same premium as one still sealed in the wrapper. It loses the cachet of being in a mint sealed state. Opened cards can still gain value depending on certain factors. Authentic vintage cards of legendary players in near-mint to mint condition frequently command hundreds or even thousands due to their historical significance and the player featured. Rarest parallel or autograph cards can likewise earn substantial sums. Meanwhile, common base cards from opened packs may have negligible value outside of use for playing/collecting purposes. The odds of pulling a massive hit are also quite low in most cases.

But opening packs is not done purely as an investment – it provides the excitement and rush of the chase that draws many enthusiasts to the hobby. Cracking that fresh wax and viewing the shiny cardboard within stimulates the brain’s reward system in a way that simply buying or trading for singles cannot match. The surprise and anticipation of not knowing what will be revealed keeps the experience engaging. Some collectors prefer to experience this thrill repeatedly with multiple box and pack breaks over time rather than leaving everything sealed long-term.

Opening packs allows collectors the flexibility to build sets or trade duplicates more easily. A complete set holds appeal to many who enjoy the satisfaction of filling the final slot. And being able trade or sell extra cards pulled can help recoup some costs rather than having packs that just gain value slowly if left unopened long-term. This supports continued enjoyment and engagement with the hobby. Whereas sealed boxes tie up capital that could potentially be used to acquire more singles, complete different sets, or invest in other areas.

When weighing these variables for a personal collection, it is wise to consider one’s own goals. If the primary focus is long-term appreciation and resale value, sealed boxes have a clear advantage over opened cards in that regard. If enjoyment of the card opening and collecting processes is most important, cracking packs provides memorable experiences that increase personal enjoyment and connection to the cards despite any minimal loss of future fiscal worth compared to leaving everything untouched. A balanced approach of opening some and keeping others sealed allows aspects of both speculation and enjoyment to be incorporated based on one’s individual circumstances and preferences.

Communication and documentation also become more vital for opened cards to establish provenance if large sums are ever involved down the line. Things like recording pack/box contents, purchase location/date, and storage details over time build a clear chain of ownership that serious collectors will demand – especially for vintage rarities. This type of paper trail does not exist for many circulated cards from the past without such evidence preserved. Leaving high-end items sealed simplifies future transactions by speaking for themselves in mint condition.

Ultimately, each collector must thoughtfully weigh factors like intended holding period, financial goals, level of enjoyment obtained from the hunting aspect versus displaying mint classics, and any sentimental attachment when electively cracking wax versus preserving it pristine. Consulting industry experts, researching past case studies, and learning from others’ experiences can also shed light when grappling with this choice. With careful consideration of pros, cons, and personal priorities, an informed decision that aligns with one’s unique preferences can be made. But there are logical stances to be made on both opening and leaving baseball cards sealed in their factory-fresh state long-term.

Whether to open unopened baseball cards comes down to balancing investment potential against the thrills of the chase based on each collector’s individual goals and circumstances. Communicating provenance remains key if large sums are ever involved with opened items. Both approaches can have merits depending on how collected items are intended to be enjoyed versus appreciated monetarily over the long haul. An informed choice that synthesizes knowledge of these multifaceted factors will result in an outcome satisfying each collector’s unique motivations.