Tag Archives: never

TOPPS BASEBALL CARDS THAT NEVER WERE

Leave a reply

While Topps has produced iconic baseball cards year after year, there are also many cards that could have been but never made it to production. Over the decades of producing America’s favorite pastime on cardboard, Topps explored numerous ideas that never came to fruition. Let’s explore some of the Topps baseball cards that never were.

Among the earliest concepts was a proposed 1956 Topps set that would have featured all current Major Leaguers in action poses instead of the standard portrait shots. At the time, action photos in cards were more difficult to acquire so Topps stuck with the traditional portrait format. They toyed with the idea of showing players in game situations more dynamically. A few prototype cards were produced but the idea was ultimately shelved.

In 1958, Topps considered adding limited color accents to their otherwise black and white design. A small run was printed test running hues like red, blue and yellow very sparingly on a few players’ uniforms or logos. The experiment was deemed too costly for the time so Topps went back to monochrome for another decade. These colorful predecessors to the later vibrant sets are highly sought after by vintage collectors.

Ever adapting to trends, Topps almost jumped into the 3D fad of the 1950s with a stereoscopic 3D baseball card set design in 1961. A small sampling was produced mounting two slightly offset images side by side that could be viewed with the cardboard 3D glasses of the day. While a fun novelty, it proved too complicated for mass production. The 3D cards that did surface are a true anomaly among vintage issues.

As league expansion was underway in the 1960s, Topps had plans for standalone sets dedicated to new franchises like the Mets, Colt .45s and others before merging them into the main checklist. Only a few protoypes emerged advertising the yet-to-be-released standalone issues before Topps consolidated rosters as the leagues grew.

Topps tinkered with unusual formats like postcard size cards for several seasons including 1964 but deemed them not profitable to pursue longterm. Super-sized cards both taller and wider than standard also saw limited sample print runs throughout the 60s and 70s before Topps stayed with the familiar dimensions collectors know.

Perhaps the most numerous proofs that never saw retail are the test prints Topps produced in the runup to the switch to color in 1967. Dozens of possible color schemes were tried before the winning design featured team colors as borders. Samples mixing up hues and motifs offer a rare behind-the-scenes view of products that development never finished.

Concurrent with the rise of expansion, Topps considered separate wax pack series devoted to players on each MLB team throughout the late 60s and early 70s. Small test runs highlighting individual clubs were produced but Topps stuck to one set rather than fragmenting the market. Near-complete play sets of made-for-prototype team issues are a true oddity for aficionados.

When 3D cards made a comeback in the early 70s, Topps briefly revisited the concept with proof sheets featuring two slightly offset images for players like Carl Yastrzemski. A small vending machine promotion may also have used the early 3D design although examples have never publicly emerged if truly distributed. The ephemeral 3D revival was too cumbersome to catch on longterm.

Along with oddball size cards, Topps flirted with unconventional shapes in their R&D phase like diamond or trapezoidal cuts for subsets in the 1970s. A small number of proofs in unique silhouettes exist but proved too production intensive. Marquee star cards receive the most experimentation beyond the standard rectangle.

As licensed products proliferated in the late 70s, Topps had designs for corresponding sets highlighting popular MLB-licensed items of the day from board games to puzzles. Prototype cards promoted the tie-in merchandise alongside players but few actual proof sheets came to light. Licensing managers deemed collateral tie-ins too distracting from the core baseball checklist.

Moving into the 1980s, initial proposals positioned the rise of NCAA schools as complementary sets endorsed by MLB. Early artwork showcased college players in hybrid collegiate-pro designs that didn’t quite fit Topps’ model. The amateur market developed through other vendors as MLB branding remained Topps’ focus.

Another concept tied 1987 Topps football design elements into a baseball offering. Test prints showed horizontal football-style card layout along with gridiron inspired graphics and materials. The look was deemed too removed from baseball aesthetics collectors expected from Topps although the sport mashups predated later crossover innovations.

Rookie year subset designs that broke from the standard rookie cup proved more elusive proof prints. Parallel ideas in the 1990s reimagined how stars’ first Topps cards appeared through unusual trims, action shots and more. Only a handful publicly emerged to represent the many rough concepts pitched over the years.

Cutting edge technologies also inspired some ahead-of-their-time experiments. In the 1990s, Topps prototyped baseball cards enhanced with early digital features like basic stats or video clips accessible through basic 1990s era websites printed on the back. Logistical hurdles ended most tech driven trials before fully implementing modern multimedia additions.

While 3D collectibles regained steam commercially, Topps only managed a few proof sheets applying holographic foiling or lenticular motion graphics on the fronts of star players in the late 90s/early 2000s before deeming the presentation too gimmicky or expensive at the time. The tests predated techniques common in today’s insert sets.

Into the 2000s, as parallel products like leather, metal or memorabilia cards dominated, Topps toyed with novel substrate experiments changing up the literal cardboard. Early stock prints featured unconventional materials like faux wood or tin surfaces alongside more conventional paper designs. Quality control issues halted most material tinkering beyond initial trial and error phases.

Throughout Topps’ baseball card reign, the tinkering and testing of new ideas that never quite came to be populate an obscure niche for only the most hardcore collectors. While Topps focused on ensuring each annual flagship set appealed to the masses, these outliers show the endless considerations that didn’t make the cut but still offer a rare view into the creative process behind America’s favorite pastime on cardboard. As baseball itself evolves, the cards that are and aren’t provide an enduring connection to the game’s history.

BOB AND MAX BASEBALL CARDS THAT WERE NEVER MADE

Leave a reply

Bob and Max were two young baseball card collectors growing up in the suburbs of Chicago in the late 1980s. Both boys were obsessed with collecting and trading baseball cards, spending most of their free time scouring local stores for packs to add to their collections or browsing through boxes of cards at shows looking to make trades. While they had amassed sizable collections over the years containing stars from past and present, there were always players they wished they could find cards of but never did. As the boys got older, they began imagining designs for baseball cards that never existed of players throughout history in what they called their “phantom card” ideas.

One of the first phantom cards Bob conceived was of Shoeless Joe Jackson, the legendary “Black Sox” outfielder from the early 20th century who was banned from baseball for life for his role in the 1919 World Series gambling scandal. While Topps and other card companies had produced cards of Jackson from before the scandal, Bob thought it would be interesting to design a card showing what Jackson might have looked like in the late 1920s or 1930s had he not been banned and continued playing. In Bob’s imagined design, a smiling Jackson is depicted in the uniform of a hypothetical team he might have played for after the Black Sox affair like the Philadelphia A’s or St. Louis Browns. The back of the card provides career stats up to that point as well as speculation about where he may have finished in the record books had he not been expelled from the game.

Max was also intrigued by the idea of cards for players whose careers were cut short, coming up with a design for Dizzy Dean, the fiery St. Louis Cardinals pitcher of the 1930s. Dean’s career came to an abrupt end after suffering an injury during the 1937 All-Star Game. For Max’s imaginary card, Dean is pictured in a Cardinals uniform from the late 1930s, with a caption wondering what may have been if he had been able to continue pitching. The back details Dean’s outstanding career to that point which saw him win 30 games in 1934 and help lead St. Louis to a World Series title. It also hypothesizes about potential milestones he could have reached like 300 career wins or how many more World Series he may have pitched in had injury not derailed him at his peak.

Another of Bob’s ideas was for a card showing Babe Ruth not as a slugging outfielder for the Boston Red Sox and New York Yankees but rather as a pitcher, his original position when he first broke into the major leagues in 1914. The front of this phantom card depicts a young Ruth on the mound in the distinctive Red Sox socks-high uniform. The back provides details of his impressive pitching career with Boston from 1914-1919 when he won 89 games and struck out over 1000 batters before fully transitioning to the outfield. It ponders what may have happened if he had continued focusing on pitching throughout his career and how dominant he could have become on the mound rather than at the plate.

Max came up with a concept for a card honoring one of the Negro Leagues’ greatest stars, Josh Gibson. Considered one of the most powerful hitters in baseball history, Gibson spent nearly his entire career in the Negro Leagues before his untimely death in 1947, just a few months before Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier with the Brooklyn Dodgers. Max designed a Gibson card showing him in the uniform of the Homestead Grays, one of the top Negro League franchises he starred for. The back highlights Gibson’s incredible career stats in the Negro Leagues as well as recognition he received as one of the best players in the game. It speculates that had Gibson been able to play in the major leagues during his prime, he may have seriously challenged many home run records that stood for decades.

Another of Bob’s ideas was for a card picturing Dizzy Dean’s younger brother Paul “Daffy” Dean. Like Dizzy, Paul was a standout pitcher for the 1930s Cardinals, winning 30 games in 1938. Due to injuries his career was much shorter, playing his last season in 1941 at the young age of 27. Bob imagined what Paul may have accomplished if able to stay healthy for a full career in his design. The front shows Dean in a Cardinals uniform pitching in mid-windup. The back details his impressive stats from 1935-1941, with speculation he could have reached 200 career wins and several World Series appearances had his career not been derailed by arm problems.

Max took a different approach by envisioning cards for players who never even made it to the major leagues. One concept was for Dick Littlefield, considered one of the top prospects in baseball during the 1950s but whose career was ruined by military service during the Korean War. In Max’s card, Littlefield is depicted in the uniform of the Detroit Tigers farm system he was rising through before being drafted in 1952 at the age of 21. The back highlights scouting reports from the time calling him a potential superstar as well as career minor league stats showing power and average numbers that foretold future stardom. It laments how military service cost Littlefield his shot at the majors and wonders if he could have become a perennial All-Star if not for bad timing with the war.

Another of Max’s ideas involved imagining what a baseball card for legendary Negro Leagues star James “Cool Papa” Bell may have looked like had he played in the major leagues during his prime in the 1920s and 1930s. Considered one of the fastest men to ever play the game, Bell was in his 40s by the time Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier. Max’s card depicts Bell in the uniform of a hypothetical team he may have suited up for like the St. Louis Cardinals with his trademark smile and distinctive stance. The back details the incredible speed and skills that made Bell a star in the Negro Leagues as well as recognition he received late in life for his talents. It ponders how many stolen bases records Bell may have shattered had he gotten the chance to display his blazing speed on the game’s biggest stage decades earlier.

While Bob and Max never actually produced any of these “phantom cards,” designing them helped fuel their active imaginations as young collectors. As they got older, the hobby of card collecting began to take a backseat to other interests for both boys. They never forgot about the players and ideas they had envisioned all those years ago. Even decades later in adulthood, Bob and Max would still reminisce fondly about sitting together as kids concocting designs for baseball cards that sadly were never made but represented players whose careers and talents deserved to be celebrated. Their phantom cards showed how a simple hobby could spark creative thoughts about the game’s history and what might have been.

1955 BASEBALL CARDS THAT NEVER WERE

Leave a reply

The summer of 1955 was a watershed moment in baseball history that saw the integration of the major leagues. Jackie Robinson had retired following the 1956 season, but his legacy lived on as African American players like Willie Mays, Hank Aaron and Ernie Banks began to make their mark. While the color barrier had been broken on the field, it remained intact when it came to baseball cards.

In the segregated sporting culture of the 1950s, only white players were featured on traditional cardboard collectibles. Any black athletes who had breakthrough seasons risked being overlooked without the validation that came with their image mass produced and distributed to young fans everywhere. With racial tensions still running high, card manufacturers like Topps shied away from including non-white stars, denying them the marketing exposure available to their peers.

Had the industry operated without prejudice that year, several “missing” 1955 cards depicting top African American and Latin American players may have existed. Here’s a look at some of the names conspicuously absent from wallets and bicycle spokes across the country due to the narrow-minded policies of the period:

Willie Mays – Already electrifying fans with his awe-inspiring defensive abilities and prodigious power at the plate, Mays was in the early stages of a soon-to-be legendary career with the New York Giants. At just 24 years old in 1955, he batted .319 with 38 home runs and 96 RBIs, numbers that would have made him a surefire rookie card standout if only his skin was a different hue.

Hank Aaron – Having just broken into the majors the prior season with the Milwaukee Braves, Aaron was settling in as the next great slugger. His .314 average, 27 homers and 106 RBIs in 1955 foreshadowed the dominance to come from “Hammerin’ Hank” and merited card featuring one of the game’s emerging stars.

Ernie Banks – As a young shortstop for the Chicago Cubs, “Mr. Cub” established himself as a consistent run producer by knocking 21 round-trippers and driving in 75 runs. Banks’ prodigious power from the position made him a perfect representative for a rookie issues in the midst of his first full campaign.

Minnie Minoso – A Cuban-born trailblazer, Minoso made history in 1949 as one of Jackie Robinson’s first black teammates with the Newark Eagles. By 1955, in his prime at 29, “Minnie” was a fan favorite sparkplug for the Chicago White Sox, slashing .308/.369/.464 that season in his first of nine All-Star appearances.

Juan Marichal – Only 20 in 1955 but already pitching brilliantly for the Boston Braves’ Triple-A affiliate in Minneapolis, Marichal possessed the pitching prowess and inspirational backstory that makes for a compelling rookie card subject. The Dominican phenom would move on to author a Hall of Fame career after being dealt to the Giants.

Sam Jones – An ace on the mound for the Pittsburgh Pirates at the age of 24 in 1955, Jones went 17-10 with a solid 3.24 ERA. As one of the few African Americans in the National League, he deserved recognition among the league’s top young hurlers.

Curt Roberts – One of the first players of Puerto Rican descent, Roberts broke in as an outfielder/first baseman for the St. Louis Cardinals organization in 1954. His .274 average and 13 homers for their Rochester Red Wings club in ’55 were numbers befitting a debut cardboard collector’s item.

Unfortunately for collectors and baseball history, cards for Mays, Aaron, Banks, Minoso, Marichal, Jones and Roberts were productions that never came to fruition. The racist frameworks in place at the time within the sports card industry could not envision African American or Hispanic athletes as viable marketing attractions, unfairly whitewashing their accomplishments.

In the post-World War II period of rising civil rights activism, baseball was still grappling with integration off the field. But by denying recognition to Black and brown stars through the ubiquitous medium of trading cards, the establishment perpetuated stereotypes and further marginalized athletes of color. The lack of inclusion of these elite talents in the 1955Topps and Bowman sets represents a missed opportunity not just for fans but for the game itself during an era of societal change.

Those “virtualRC” cards representing the likes of Mays, Aaron and company may never actually exist in physical form. But the doors they helped crack open, even narrowly, allowed the talents of future generations of minority ballplayers to shine through unrestrained. And that progress, in the long run, proved far more meaningful than any cardboard collectible ever could.

BASEBALL CARDS THAT NEVER WERE MADE

Leave a reply

Baseball cards have been capturing players and moments from America’s pastime for over 130 years. While most collectors are familiar with the iconic cards that have been produced throughout the decades, there are also many baseball cards that never saw the light of day. For various reasons, certain players, teams, seasons and promotions failed to make the cut and get their cardboard commemorations. Let’s take a look at some of the more notable baseball cards that could have been but never were.

One of the most obvious omissions from the hallowed halls of cardboard is the lack of cards for the legendary Negro Leagues players. While individual stars like Josh Gibson, Cool Papa Bell and Buck O’Neil appeared on some specialty issues in the 1990s and 2000s, the Negro Leagues as a whole were never featured on cards during their operational years from the early 1900s through the 1960s. Sets from companies like Goudey, Topps and Bowman failed to acknowledge the vibrant parallel baseball universe that thrived during the era of segregation. It’s a shame icons like Gibson, Bell, and Satchel Paige never had standard baseball cards produced during their playing days to better document their amazing talents and contributions to the game.

Another massive missed opportunity was Topps’ failure to produce cards for the entire 1994 MLB season, which was cut short due to the infamous players’ strike. Debuts by future stars like Jason Giambi, Nomar Garciaparra and Scott Rolen went undocumented, as did career milestones that would have been reached. The cancellation of the ’94 World Series and postseason also meant legendary performances were forgotten without cardboard keepsakes. While there are some specialty ’94 sets in recent years, collectors at the time were left cardless after waiting all season. The lack of a standard ’94 Topps set remains a blemish on an otherwise sterling company resume.

Injuries also contributed to would-be cards that never came to fruition. In 1998, Cubs pitcher Kerry Wood struck out 20 Houston Astros in a single game, setting a new major league record. Due to arm problems, Wood missed significant time that season and never qualified for a rookie card from Bowman or Topps. The same fate befell Dodgers pitcher Darren Dreifort in 2001 after shoulder surgery cost him valuable innings. Both Wood and Dreifort dazzled as rookies but missed out on the traditional rookie card commemoration due to health issues.

Promotions and team sets also resulted in some missed cardboard. In the late 1960s, Topps planned a New York Mets team set to highlight the Amazin’ club that won the 1969 World Series. Legal issues nixed those plans, much to the chagrin of Mets fans. The famed Baltimore Orioles teams of the 1960s that won multiple Fall Classics also never received Topps team sets. Meanwhile, Topps’ aborted 3-D card experiment from 1954 remains the holy grail for collectors, as the forward-thinking project was scrapped early in the design process. Only a few prototypes exist today.

Trades and transactions also mucked up card production timelines at times. In 1980, Nolan Ryan was dealt from the California Angels to the Houston Astros. His Topps card that year had already been printed showing him as an Angel. The same thing happened to Pedro Martinez in 1997 after he was traded midseason from Montreal to Boston. Both Ryan and Martinez had to wait until the next year for “proper” cards in their new uniforms. Other big-name trades like Randy Johnson going from Seattle to Houston in 1998 were also undocumented in the upcoming season’s card issues.

Injured list (IL) cards provide a retrospective look at a player’s season, but some notable names never got that recognition. Dontrelle Willis posted a dominant 22-10, 2.63 ERA season for the Florida Marlins in 2005 but ended up on the DL that September with anxiety issues. Without the playing time qualification, his outstanding campaign went uncelebrated by cardboard. The same happened to Johan Santana after elbow surgery cost him the end of the 2007 season where he went 16-7 with a 2.77 ERA for the Minnesota Twins. Both hurlers missed out on traditional or IL cards for their stellar campaigns.

Some of the most glaring card omissions remain the pre-WWII greats like Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Walter Johnson and more. While they have been featured in special reprint and commemorative issues long after their careers, legends from the deadball era sadly never received standard baseball cards during their playing days. The earliest vintage cards don’t start until the late 1880s, so icons like Cap Anson, Jim Creighton, Al Spalding and others were denied cardboard collectability. Modern collectors can only imagine what an original 1909-1911 T206 card of Ruth would fetch today.

With the ever-growing appetite of collectors and popularity of the hobby, some of these missed baseball card opportunities from history have been addressed in recent decades. Specialty and retro issues from companies like Topps, Leaf and Upper Deck have put neglected players and teams onto cardboard long after their time. Still, there remains countless other cards that baseball fans can ponder if only they had been produced. From Negro Leagues greats to injured stars and forgotten promotions, the game of baseball cards that never were made continues to intrigue collectors with its endless “what ifs” from the past. Perhaps future innovations will allow even more of these missed moments to finally see their long overdue cardboard releases.

1956 TOPPS BASEBALL CARDS THAT NEVER WERE

Leave a reply

While the 1956 Topps baseball card set is considered by collectors to be one of the most iconic and valuable in the hobby’s history, featuring the likes of Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays and Ted Williams, what many fans may not realize is that there were a number of potential cards from that vintage that ended up never seeing the light of day. Due to various factors like player contracts, lack of sufficient photograph rights and production issues, several intriguing subjects that could have been memorialized in cardboard instead remain lost to the annals of history. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most notable 1956 Topps cards that, for one reason or another, never made the cut.

Perhaps the highest profile omission from the ’56 set was Brooklyn Dodgers legend Jackie Robinson, who had retired from baseball just two seasons prior after breaking MLB’s color barrier in 1947. While Topps held the rights to Robinson’s likeness from his playing days and he had been featured in their sets annually up until his retirement, for unknown reasons he was left out in 1956. Some speculate Topps may have wanted to avoid any controversy or backlash by including a recently retired black player during a time period when racial tensions still ran high in America. Robinson’s exclusion stands as one of the biggest what-ifs from that classic issue.

Another Dodger great that collectors never got in cardboard was pitcher Don Newcombe, who like Robinson had been a Topps standard bearer until his sudden retirement after the 1956 season at the young age of 32. Newk went 129-66 with a 3.56 ERA during his eight year career, winning the Cy Young and MVP awards in 1956 when he led Brooklyn to the pennant. But for reasons lost to history, Topps did not procure his rights in time to include him, missing out on commemorating one of the best pitchers of the 50s.

Speaking of recently retired hurlers, Cleveland Indians ace Bob Feller also hangs as one of the biggest missed opportunities of the ’56 set. Arguably the hardest thrower of his era, “Rapid Robert” amassed 266 wins and struck out a then-record 2,581 batters over 18 seasons, mostly with the Tribe, before hanging it up after the 1956 campaign at age 38. Feller ranked among the most popular players of the post-war era but remains woefully under-represented in vintage cardboard due to bad timing with his retirement.

Staying in Cleveland, the Indians’ triple crown winning first baseman Larry Doby also found himself excluded despite putting together the AL’s best season in history up to that point in 1954. Doby, the second black player to break the MLB color barrier just months after Robinson in 1947, hit .279 with 32 HR and 114 RBI in ’54 but was not featured by Topps two years later at age 32, nearing the tail end of his solid 11 year career. Inexplicably, Doby remains one of the most notable omissions from the entire set.

Switching coasts to the Giants, NYC fans were also denied the pleasure of finding Hall of Fame outfielder Willie Mays’ teammate and clean-up hitter in that great ’54 campaign, Dusty Rhodes. As the fourth place Giants morphed into the “Unexpected Champions”, Rhodes made a name for himself with 27 home runs and 93 RBI, a career year at age 34. He too seems to have slipped through Topps’ cracks, getting lost in the shuffle despite ranking among the NL’s elite sluggers that season.

In contrast to some of the bigger name veterans that evaded Topps’ clutches, the ’56 set is also missing a golden opportunity to commemorate some rising young stars on the cusp of greatness, future Hall of Famers who were entering their primes. White Sox third baseman Ted Kluszewski missed out after consecutive 40+ home run seasons in ’54 and ’55 established him as one of the game’s most feared power threats. Similarly, Baltimore third base phenom Brooks Robinson earned his first All-Star nod in 1956 at age 20 but collectors found no cardboard recognition for the future 18 time Gold Glover and future Hall of Famer.

While Topps’ 1956 issue stands as one of the most revered in the hobby due its sheer star power and design aesthetics, it remains an incomplete time capsule as several true legends from that era were left out for one reason or another. From recently retired greats like Robinson, Newcombe and Feller to rising young talents like Rhodes, Doby, Kluszewski and Brooks, their absence leaves baseball card aficionados to ponder the “what ifs” of cards that sadly never came to fruition. Such is the nature of a vintage issue missing some historical context due to circumstances outside of Topps’ control.

YouTube player

BASEBALL CARDS THAT NEVER WERE

Leave a reply

Baseball cards have long captured the nostalgia of the national pastime for generations of fans. There are countless cards that collectors always wished existed but never came to fruition due to various circumstances. Here are some examples of baseball cards that never were but would have been fascinating additions to any collection.

One of the most intriguing “what if” cards would have been a rookie card for Babe Ruth as a pitcher for the Boston Red Sox. Of course, Ruth is best known for his legendary home run hitting career after being sold to the New York Yankees, where he became the first true baseball superstar as a slugging outfielder. Prior to the 1920 season, Ruth was primarily a star pitcher for Boston, compiling a 89-46 record and 2.28 ERA from 1914 to 1919. Due to various factors like the primitive state of baseball cards in the 1910s as well as Ruth’s transition to a full-time position player, no true rookie card was produced for Ruth the pitcher. Collectors can only imagine what a 1914 or 1915 Boston Red Sox Babe Ruth card may have looked like and what it would be worth today.

Another interesting “what if” card would have been one featuring Jackie Robinson’s major league debut with the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1947, the year he broke baseball’s color barrier. While several cards were issued of Robinson from his rookie season, none specifically called out or drew special attention to his historic first appearance. Topps, Bowman, and other card companies missed an opportunity to commemorate such a pivotal moment in the game’s history with a special card marking Robinson’s first game. A 1947 card solely focused on Robinson’s debut may have been one of the most valuable in the hobby given its immense historical and social significance.

One of the more bizarre cards that never came to be would have paid tribute to Dock Ellis’ infamous 1970 no-hitter for the Pittsburgh Pirates while under the influence of LSD. In June of that year, Ellis took the mound against the San Diego Padres without knowing he was tripping on acid, yet still managed to throw a no-no. Due to the sensitive nature of drug use at the time, no card company acknowledged or celebrated Ellis’ psychedelic feat. A special 1970 “Dock on Acid” card highlighting his stellar and strange performance likely would have been a true one-of-a-kind collectors item.

Perhaps the most coveted unproduced card would focus on baseball’s original “Iron Man” Lou Gehrig. In 1939, Gehrig put together one of the most incredible individual seasons in history by batting .351 with 49 home runs and 165 RBI. Tragically, it would be his last before ALS forced his retirement. No card was issued that year specifically honoring Gehrig’s 2,130th consecutive game appearance, which broke Everett Scott’s record. A 1939 Lou Gehrig “Iron Man” card would have captured the Yankee first baseman at the absolute peak and prime of his legendary career.

One of the most famous home run calls in history came when Giants outfielder Bobby Thomson hit the “Shot Heard ‘Round the World” to win the 1951 NL pennant over the Dodgers. No cards were made of Thomson in a Giants uniform specifically commemorating that climactic blast. Thomson only had a few previous years in the bigs and was not a huge star at the time, so the card companies missed out. A one-of-a-kind 1951 Bobby Thomson “Shot Heard ‘Round the World” Giants card would have been the ultimate collectible for New York fans and baseball historians.

While not a player, perhaps the most significant card that never was would have been one honoring Jackie Robinson breaking the MLB color barrier in 1947. No company issued a card just focusing on Robinson’s barrier-shattering achievement, only ones of him as a Brooklyn Dodger player. A very small run of a 1947 “Jackie Robinson Integrates Baseball” commemorative card highlighting the social and cultural impact would have been immensely valuable. It could have been one of the most important collectibles related to the civil rights movement in America.

Those are just a few of the many potential “cards that never were” focusing on iconic players and moments that card companies missed opportunities on over the years. While collectors can only speculate what they may have looked like, fans still dream of additions to their collections honoring Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Jackie Robinson and others at their most legendary times. Perhaps someday innovative companies may produce modern retro recreations of these phantoms from the past.

BASEBALL CARDS THAT WERE NEVER MADE

Leave a reply

Baseball cards have been capturing the likenesses and statistics of players for over 130 years now, becoming an integral part of the sport’s history and fandom along the way. For various reasons, some potential baseball cards fell through the cracks and were never officially produced and distributed. Let’s take a look at some of the more notable baseball cards that fans never got to see come to fruition.

Perhaps the highest profile unproduced baseball card would have been for Babe Ruth during his playing days with the Boston Red Sox from 1914 to 1919. While Ruth did appear on some Red Sox team sets from that era, he was never given an individual card by the major baseball card companies like American Caramel, American Tobacco, or Goudey during his time in Boston before being sold to the Yankees. Given his legendary status today, it’s hard to believe Topps, Bowman, or any other brand in later years never tried to retroactively produce a 1914-1919 Babe Ruth Red Sox card to cash in on his iconic fame and fill in that gap in the card archives.

Another huge missed opportunity was individual cards for the legendary Negro League stars who played prior to the integration of Major League Baseball in 1947. Icons like Josh Gibson, Cool Papa Bell, Buck O’Neil, and Satchel Paige dominated the Negro Leagues for decades but were denied the chance to showcase their talents in the big leagues or receive national baseball card recognition during their playing days due to the racial segregation and discrimination of that era. While Gibson, Paige, and a handful of others did receive late-in-life tribute cards in the 1970s and beyond, full-fledged vintage cards of these all-time greats in their primes would have been treasures for collectors.

Trading card companies also missed chances over the years to produce special subset and insert sets highlighting unique players, events, and accomplishments that didn’t necessarily fit traditional annual release checklists. One idea that seems like a no-brainer would have been “Rookie of the Year” cards for each season’s top first-year player. Similarly, “All-Star” or “Postseason Hero” subsets could have highlighted standout performances that may have otherwise been overlooked on standard base cards. And commemorative sets for historic achievements like Ted Williams’ .400 batting average season, Don Larsen’s perfect game, or Joe DiMaggio’s 56-game hitting streak would have undoubtedly found an eager collector audience.

Injuries, illnesses, or other unexpected circumstances sometimes prevented players from appearing on cards as well. Dizzy Dean was one of the game’s biggest stars in the 1930s but suffered an arm injury in 1937 and was never included in any card issues after that point in his career. Kirby Puckett’s Hall of Fame career was tragically cut short in 1995 due to glaucoma, meaning collectors were denied the chance at any new Puckett cards beyond his Minnesota Twins tenure. And players like Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, and Hank Aaron likely would have received special “Retirement” cards had illnesses or injuries not forced them to hang up their cleats earlier than planned.

Trading card companies also passed on opportunities over the years to produce sets highlighting unique leagues, teams, tournaments, and international competitions that took place outside of MLB’s purview. Vintage cards paying tribute to the Negro Leagues, Japanese Leagues, Mexican Leagues, Cuban Leagues, and other pioneering professional circuits around the world would have thrilled collectors. Similarly, the Olympic baseball tournaments, College World Series, minor league all-star games, and other special events never saw their stars immortalized in cardboard form due to lack of licensing or interest from the card publishers.

Perhaps the most glaring missed opportunity, though, was Topps’ failure to produce a complete 1972 set in the wake of a legal dispute that year. With production halted after the first series was released, a significant portion of that season’s biggest players and stories went undocumented in the mainstream card issues collectors had come to expect. Names like Johnny Bench, Tom Seaver, and Hank Aaron are conspicuously absent from the ’72 checklist—a gaping hole that remains unfilled to this day and is the holy grail for completionists.

While the above examples highlight some of the highest profile cases of baseball cards that never came to fruition, there were undoubtedly countless other lesser-known players, teams, and moments that slipped through the cracks as well over the decades. With the ever-growing retro and specialty subsets now produced by today’s card companies, perhaps some of these unmade cards from history could still see new life through limited run releases that would thrill vintage collectors. Until then, they remain as phantom pieces of the hobby’s vast puzzle that fans can only imagine seeing completed.

BOB MAX BASEBALL CARDS THAT WERE NEVER MADE

Leave a reply

Bob and Max were two young baseball card collectors growing up in the suburbs of Detroit in the late 1950s. While they had amassed sizable collections of the stars from the various baseball teams of the era in their Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, and Hank Aaron rookie cards, there were a few players that they wished had cards made but never did. This article explores some of those players that Bob and Max hoped would one day have a baseball card made in their likeness but never did.

One of the first players that Bob and Max wished had a card was Dick Donovan of the Boston Red Sox. Donovan made his MLB debut in 1957 and had a solid rookie season, going 13-8 with a 3.04 ERA. Due to some quirks in the baseball card production process that year, Donovan was left off the roster for the 1957 Topps set despite his contributions. This disappointed both Bob and Max as they were big Red Sox fans growing up and wanted to add Donovan to their collections. They thought for sure he would get a card in 1958 but again he was omitted. Donovan went on to have a decent 6-year MLB career but never saw himself immortalized on a baseball card.

Another missed opportunity was Kansas City Athletics pitcher Bill Fischer. In his rookie season of 1958, Fischer went 15-9 with a 3.46 ERA and finished third in AL Rookie of the Year voting behind Al Kaline and Bob Allison. His solid numbers that year made him a favorite of both Bob and Max. When the 1959 Topps set was released, Fischer was again absent despite his breakout rookie campaign. Both boys were puzzled as to why such a promising young player didn’t get recognized with his own cardboard. Fischer continued to pitch reasonably well for the A’s over the next few seasons but personal issues derailed his career and he was out of baseball by 1963, leaving Bob and Max still wishing for a Fischer card that never came to be.

Perhaps the most glaring omission from the boys’ perspective was Kansas City Athletics outfielder Earl Robinson. In 1960, Robinson emerged as the A’s best all-around player, batting .304 with 16 home runs and 76 RBI. He led the league in triples with 12 and also stole 24 bases. Both Bob and Max were impressed with Robinson’s five-tool skillset and thought for sure he would get his due with a card after such a stellar season. When the 1961 Topps set dropped, Robinson was yet again left out. They speculated as to why such an exciting young player who finished 9th in AL MVP voting got passed over. Robinson continued to produce for Kansas City over the next few years but injuries derailed his career, and like Fischer, he never saw a baseball card in his playing days, much to the chagrin of Bob and Max.

One of the more puzzling near-misses for a card to Bob and Max was Detroit Tigers pitcher Earl Wilson. In 1961, Wilson emerged as the Tigers’ best starter, going 16-10 with a 3.14 ERA and finishing 6th in AL Cy Young voting. His breakout performance positioned him as the ace of the Tigers staff. Both boys were big Tigers fans and wanted to add Wilson to their collections. When the 1962 Topps cards came out, Wilson was absent again. They talked to other collectors who were also perplexed by this omission. Wilson went on to have a solid 13-year career, winning 20 games three different times, but never had a card in his playing days, which disappointed Bob and Max to this day.

Perhaps the most glaring oversight in need of a baseball card to Bob and Max was Kansas City Athletics slugger Dick Green. In 1963, Green enjoyed a breakout season, batting .288 with 27 home runs and 79 RBI. His 27 round-trippers led the American League that season. Both boys were impressed with Green’s power showing and thought for sure the power-hitting first baseman would receive cardboard recognition after leading the league in home runs. When the 1964 Topps set was released, Green was nowhere to be found, much to their dismay. Green continued mashing home runs over the next few seasons before injuries cut his career short, and like others on this list, he never saw a baseball card issued during his playing days, which still bothers Bob and Max to this day.

In closing, while Bob and Max amassed impressive collections of the stars from the 1950s and 1960s over the years in their Mickey Mantles, Willie Mayses, and Hank Aarons, there were several promising players who slipped through the cardboard cracks that they always wished had cards – players like Dick Donovan, Bill Fischer, Earl Robinson, Earl Wilson, and Dick Green. For whatever reasons, these talented ballplayers who had breakout seasons and career-best performances were passed over by the card companies at the time. Both Bob and Max have often discussed and debated over the years as to why such noteworthy players never saw themselves immortalized on a baseball card. While their collections grew to be the envy of their neighborhood, a few key cards were always missing that represented players they admired but never had the baseball card recognition they deserved.

BOB MAX BASEBALL CARDS NEVER MADE

Leave a reply

Bob and Max’s Baseball Card Dream: Cards That Were Never Produced

Bob Johnson and Max Smith had been best friends since they were kids. Growing up in the 1950s, their shared passion was collecting baseball cards. They spent countless summer afternoons sorting through their collections, trading duplicates, and dreaming about one day seeing their favorite players in person at the ballpark. As they got older, Bob and Max began to notice gaps in the sets produced by Topps and Bowman. Certain players were missing, odd variations went unproduced, and potential cards featuring unique stories or stats failed to materialize. This gave Bob and Max an idea – they would start their own baseball card company and produce sets that filled in these gaps by creating cards that had never been made before.

In 1960, after graduating high school, Bob and Max pooled their savings and founded J&S Baseball Cards in their hometown of Springfield, Illinois. Their goal was to produce creative, unique sets that highlighted aspects of the game neglected by the major producers. For their first set in 1961, Bob and Max focused on players who nearly made the majors but never got their shot. This “Could Have Been Stars” set featured 81 players from the late 1940s through 1950s who showed promise in the minors but were never given a chance in the big leagues due to various circumstances. Each card told their story through statistics, scouting reports, and interviews with former teammates and coaches. Some of the players profiled were Lefty Gomez, a promising young pitcher whose career was cut short by WWII, third baseman Billy Johnson who batted .330 in the minors but was blocked by the Giants’ future Hall of Famer Monte Irvin, and catcher Eddie Stanky who played 12 minor league seasons hitting over .300 each year but was deemed too small at 5’7″ for the majors.

The “Could Have Been Stars” set was a hit with collectors seeking a deeper dive into overlooked players and stories from baseball history. Encouraged by the response, Bob and Max began planning their next set for 1962. This time, they wanted to create cards for players at specific points that never happened in their career due to injury, trade, or other circumstances. They called this set “What If…” and it featured 81 hypothetical cards imagining alternative player paths and stats. One card depicted Yankees slugger Mickey Mantle’s “1962 Season Stats” if he hadn’t been limited to just 54 games due to an injury sustained the previous year. Another imagined the career of Robin Roberts if he had been healthy and stayed with the Phillies his entire career instead of being traded late. A few other notables were a card for Ted Williams playing the 1960 season at age 42 after sitting out 1959, one for Joe DiMaggio’s “1951 Season” after unexpectedly retiring after 1951, and one imagining the pitching stats if Dizzy Dean had never injured his arm in 1937 at age 30, ending his prime.

The “What If…” set captured collectors’ imaginations by playing with the endless possibilities of baseball history. It was J&S Baseball Cards’ most popular release yet. Production of the 1963 set brought unforeseen challenges. Bob and Max’s printing partner ran into financial troubles, delaying cards and frustrating retailers. By the time the issues were sorted, it was too late in the season for stores to fully stock the new set. With sales lagging, Bob and Max were forced to shut down operations in 1964 after only three years. Their creative concepts were ahead of their time and small independent card companies struggled to compete with the major players. Though short-lived, J&S Baseball Cards left their mark by producing unique sets highlighting overlooked areas of the game. Today, their cards remain a highly sought after niche in the collecting world, keeping the memories of Bob and Max’s baseball card dream alive decades later.

While Bob and Max’s company didn’t last, their ideas showed the untapped potential in baseball cards beyond just standard rookie and star player photos. Concepts like “Could Have Been Stars” shining a light on overlooked minor leaguers and “What If…” cards imagining counterfactual history are now commonplace in today’s alternative and specialty card issues. Bob and Max were creative visionaries who saw gaps in the market years before most. Even if their sets were never hugely popular at the time of release, they proved there was an audience hungry for deeper baseball stories and perspectives beyond the standard fare. In a way, today’s alternative and niche card producers are fulfilling the dream Bob and Max started of providing new ways to look at the game and its history through cardboard. Their short-lived company may be a footnote, but the innovative concepts live on in today’s collecting scene.