Tag Archives: considered


Baseball cards have been collected by fans for over a century and are considered by many to be an important part of sports memorabilia collecting. With the popularity and monetary value of vintage and rare baseball cards increasing significantly in recent decades, many collectors have wondered about the tax implications of buying, selling, and holding baseball cards as investments. So can baseball cards be treated as collectibles for tax filing purposes?

The answer is yes, in most cases baseball cards would qualify as collectibles per IRS guidelines. The IRS defines a “collectible” as any work of art, rug or antique, metal or gem, stamp or coin, alcoholic beverage, or other tangible personal property specifically designated by the IRS. This would include sports cards and memorabilia. Some key considerations and tax rules around collectibles as they apply to baseball cards include:

Capital gains tax rates: Any profits from the sale of collectibles that have appreciated in value are subject to capital gains tax. The rates for collectibles are typically higher than rates for other investments. Most baseball card sales that have realized a gain would be subject to a maximum 28% long-term capital gains tax rate (cards held over one year) as opposed to the 20% rate for non-collectibles.

Cost basis: It’s important for collectors to keep careful records of all baseball card purchase prices to determine accurate cost basis for tax reporting purposes when cards are eventually sold. Cost basis is subtracted from the sale price to determine capital gains tax liability. Proper documentation is key since items like sports cards purchased decades ago often did not include receipts.

Annual exclusion amounts: The IRS allows for an annual exclusion on capital gains for personal assets of $1,000 for single taxpayers or $2,000 for married filing jointly for collectibles like baseball cards. Any gains under the threshold in a given year are not taxed. This can provide tax savings for collectors realizing only small profits each year through incremental card sales.

Dealer status concerns: If an individual routinely buys and sells baseball cards with the intentions to realize short-term trading profits, the IRS may view them as a card dealer required to pay self-employment tax on net annual income. Hobbyists can sell the occasional card as a collector without this designation. Frequent trading could trigger an audit.

Charitable donations: Baseball card collectors may be eligible for a tax deduction by donating rare cards or complete sets to a qualified charitable organization like a sports museum. To claim the deduction, cards must be appraised and the value cannot exceed 20% of adjusted gross income for the year.

While baseball cards are technically considered collectibles per the IRS definition, there are some relatively tax-friendly attributes like annual capital gains exclusions for collectors realizing small profits each year. Higher capital gains rates and strict cost basis tracking apply. Those running a business reselling cards could face self-employment taxation as well. In most scenarios, baseball cards do indeed fall under collectible asset tax treatment similar to works of art or coins based on IRS guidelines. Maintaining clean records is a must for both hobbyist collectors and potential dealers.


The early history of vintage baseball cards starts with the earliest tobacco cards of the late 1800s through the early 1900s. The American Tobacco Company began inserting cards into their products starting in 1867, which are considered the first sports cards ever made. These early tobacco cards featured some baseball players but focused mainly on random celebrities and presidents. The cigar manufacturer Royal Cannons and Sweet Caporal began dedicated baseball card sets in the late 1880s that are the first true vintage baseball card sets.

The modern era of baseball cards generally agreed to have begun in 1909 with the hugely popular and iconic T206 tobacco card set. This set featured colored photos on the front for the first time and is still considered the finest and most desirable set for vintage collectors. Through the early 20th century, tobacco companies like Phillip Morris, American Leaf, and Piedmont issued extensive card sets, several per year. The designs evolved with photos taking over from illustrations and into the 1920s you see the first cards with player stats, team affiliations, and other details.

In the 1930s, the Goudey Gum Company issued several highly collectible sets, most notably their 1933 release which is one of the most popular vintage sets ever. These early 20th century tobacco and gum company sets from 1909 through the late 1930s are undisputedly considered vintage baseball cards in the hobby. By World War 2, baseball cards were also included in candy, cracker, and other products besides just tobacco.

The post-war period of the late 1940s and 1950s saw the sport explode in popularity and brought a golden age of baseball cards. Many regional sets came out from independent companies for specific areas which added to the collecting diversity. The 1950s Bowman and Topps sets remain iconic to this day. Topps overtook the market by the mid-1950s and their annual releases became the most anticipated. Their iconic designs like the 1953 red back and iconic photos helped turn cards into a serious hobby.

The 1960s saw little graphical change from the 50s but many memorable rookie cards appeared in the period like Hank Aaron’s first Topps issue. In the early 1970s, Topps had competition again from Fleer and the American Card Company. This period modernized designs a bit with color photos. Rated Rookie cards also started as an exciting new concept. The 1970s are generally the cut-off point for defining a true vintage baseball card.

Sets from the late 70s like 1978 Topps and 1979 Topps are often not considered vintage anymore by serious collectors, putting the vintage era between the 1880s/1890s through late 1970s. The defining factors are the production period, associated company/brand, design aesthetics, available player stats, and overall condition and survival rate compared to modern mass-produced cards. Anything before the modern explosion in popularity post-1970s is widely accepted as vintage in collecting circles.

Vintage baseball cards span roughly the 1880s through late 1970s period defined by the early tobacco/gum inserts, the golden age of the post-war 1950s/1960s Topps/Bowman era, and pre-80s modern production standards. The early Tobacco/Gum cards through 1930s, the 1950s Topps classics, and pre-1971 issues from Fleer/Topps are most universally agreed upon as the core of vintage baseball card collecting and carry the highest values today due to their historical significance, rarity, and classic straightforward designs that still captivate collectors.


Baseball cards occupy a somewhat gray area when it comes to eligibility for Media Mail rates through the United States Postal Service. Media Mail is a special mailing rate intended for certain written, printed, recorded, or promotional materials under domestic mail classifications. While baseball cards do have commercial value as collectors’ items, their primary purpose and function relates to conveying factual information and promotion. As such, there are reasonable arguments on both sides of whether baseball cards should qualify for the lower Media Mail rates.

Baseball cards act fundamentally as a means of conveying factual information about baseball players, teams, statistics, and the sport itself. Each card contains printed details like a player’s name, position, team, career stats, accomplishments, and perhaps a small biography. In this sense, baseball cards serve to disseminate informative data about baseball much like magazines, books, catalogs, or other merchandising periodicals qualify for Media Mail rates. The USPS defines eligible Media Mail items as “printed matter and promotional materials that contain advertising, educational information, or entertainment value.” From a content standpoint, baseball cards undeniably provide factual sports data and promotion of baseball players/teams as their primary function and purpose.

There are also clear commercial aspects of baseball cards that complicate their eligibility. While early baseball cards from the 1880s-1930s were purely meant to provide player stats/info alongside tobacco products, modern baseball cards primarily function as collectible memorabilia with significant monetary value based on scarcity, condition grading, autographs, and other coveted attributes. The baseball card industry generates hundreds of millions in annual secondary market sales, driven mainly by speculation, investments, and high-value vintage cards. In this light, baseball cards could reasonably be viewed more as commercial products and commodities rather than solely as information/promotional conveyances. The USPS emphasizes Media Mail is not intended for materials whose purpose is financial gain or profit.

There are also liability concerns if the USPS was to formally acknowledge baseball cards as eligible for Media Mail rates. The substantially lower shipping costs could enable increased fraudulent activity like sellers dodging appropriate insurance/tracking on valuable vintage cards by abusing the Media Mail classification. Different card designs, autographed vs non-autographed cards, graded vs ungraded cards, and so forth complicate establishing clear eligibility guidelines acceptable to all stakeholders in the baseball card industry. Unclear rules could lead to disputes between buyers/sellers and costly litigation for the USPS to resolve.

In practice, post offices have applied the baseball card Media Mail eligibility question inconsistently due to these ambiguities. Some clerks will accept baseball cards sent at Media Mail rates, while others will deny the lower rate and require additional postage. This means there is no definitive nationwide policy from the USPS formally classifying baseball cards one way or the other. Sellers and collectors are essentially left guessing whether using Media Mail will result in delivery or returned shipments at their local post office.

After considering all angles of the issue, drawing a definite conclusion on baseball card Media Mail eligibility remains complicated. While the primary informational purpose of baseball cards aligns with Media Mail objectives, significant modern commercial concerns undermine clear qualification. For practical and liability reasons, a definitive nationwide policy from the USPS may be infeasible. This leaves the gray area determination largely up to individual post office interpretation absent any revisions to Media Mail program rules and guidelines. Reasonable perspectives exist on both sides, making a simple yes or no answer elusive for this unique collectible good that straddles the line between information and commerce.


Baseball cards have been around since the late 19th century and were originally included as an extra promotional item inside packages of chewing gum and cigarettes to help advertise brands. Over time, people began saving and collecting the cards for enjoyment and to showcase their favorite players. Even back in the early 1900s, some considered their baseball card collections valuable.

The collecting and valuing of baseball cards really took off in the post-World War II era as the hobby grew in popularity across the United States. Important factors that helped establish baseball cards as true collectibles included the more widespread availability of cards through retail avenues like shops and drug stores rather than just inside gum/cigarette packs. More sets from different brands also provided more cards to pursue.

Improved production technologies also led to higher quality cards that held up better over time for display in albums. The increased focus on statistical tracking of players and records also gave collectors more to admire about their favorite stars. By the 1950s, condition and scarcity started being major determinants of value for certain cards. This showed collectibility was an inherent part of the experience for many fans.

In the late 1980s and 1990s, the collecting boom took off to new heights driven by nostalgia of baby boomers, greater discretionary income levels, and the rise of online trading. Popular TV shows like Beckett Magazine’s PriceGuide helped bring transparency to the collecting marketplace. Cards from the 1950s began commanding big sums, especially for icons like Mickey Mantle. This underscored how top baseball cards could function similar to financial investments.

The emergence of online auction sites like eBay in the mid-1990s opened the floodgates further by giving anyone a platform to buy, sell and discover values. Users could now track specific cards they wanted and learn of recent comparable sales prices around the world. The transparency and liquidity benefited collectors. Prices surged for legendary cards like the 1909-11 T206 Honus Wagner, considered the Mona Lisa of sports cards.

Some key reasons baseball cards remain premiere collectibles today include:

Nostalgia and connection to baseball history – Cards allow fans to relive memories and admire the legends they watched or read about. Newer collectors enjoy learning baseball history through the photos and stats on vintage cards.

Investment potential – Top rare cards from the T206 era through the 1950s have appreciated enormously based on supply and demand. The cards represent tangible assets that hold or increase value over time for savvy investors.

Individualized connection to players – Collectors form personal connections to their favorite players through collecting their rookie cards and following their careers. This emotional driver enhances the hobby.

Visual artistic appeal – The photography, graphics and designs on cards evolve over the decades but remain a visually appealing component that attracts collectors interested in nostalgia, art and history alike.

Endless variety and achievement – With over a century of cards produced and tens of thousands of unique cards issued, the scope of collecting invites competition to complete sets or collect specific players, teams or years. Chasing checklists fuels addictive tendencies.

Tangibility and interchangeability – Unlike cryptocurrencies or digital collectibles, physical cards remain interchangeable assets that can be enjoyed, displayed, traded and potentially resold. This appeals to those who like to touch and assess what they collect.

Authenticity verification – Grading services authenticate condition and assure buyers they are getting a genuine, unaltered item. This builds confidence for serious investors and adds standardization for comparing values.

Ongoing involvement – The baseball card collecting hobby has evolved into a lifelong pursuit with constant revelations of new finds, trends in player values, collecting challenges, community bonding and educational experiences that keep the excitement going year after year.

The unique combination of entertainment, nostalgia, history, art, tangible assets and competitive/comparative aspects inherent to baseball cards is what has cemented them as among the most popular and valuable sports collectibles in existence. The over 120 year tradition and track record of the cards holding or gaining value based on supply and demand certifies them as true collector’s items. While digital collectibles have emerged, physical baseball cards remain highly coveted by collectors and investors alike for their special intrinsic qualities and proven staying power in the marketplace over a long period of time.


In the early 1970s, the annual release of Topps baseball cards was still a major part of the hobby for many young baseball fans. Children would eagerly open packs of the new Topps cards, hoping to collect their favorite players or chase after elusive short printed or serial numbered cards. When it comes to the 1972 Topps set, the card numbers serve as an indicator of scarcity, with higher numbers representing more scarce or difficult to find cards within the set.

The 1972 Topps set contains 556 total cards, including base cards, multi-player cards, manager cards, and checklists. Cards were issued in sequential order from #1 to #556, with the lowest numbered cards generally being the easiest to obtain in packs or in the trading market. Back in 1972, many young collectors hoped to complete their set but may have fallen just short due to not being able to find some of the higher numbered cards. So in the original collecting context of 1972, the threshold of what constituted a “high number” would likely have been considered 400 or above.

Any card from the 1972 set with a number of 400 or higher today would be considered much more scarce and valuable compared to the lower numbered cards from the set. This is because fewer packs from 1972 have survived intact and unsearched over the past 50 years. The play period for these cards was also shorter before they entered long term storage in attics, basements, and collection boxes. Each subsequent year further thins the surviving poplulation of high numbered gems from the vintage 1972 set.

Some key data points help shed more light on why numbers 400 and above are notable as being scarce in the 1972 Topps set:

The checklist card is #555, meaning any card #556 would have been the last possible basic card in the set.

Multi-player cards like the team cards took up higher numbers like #547, #548, #549, leaving less room for true singles cards at the top of the numbering system.

Card production sheets from Topps at the time stated the intended population of cards #481-556 was much lower versus the early portions of the set. This was done deliberately by Topps to create scarcer “chase” cards.

Population census data compiled by tracking registraion and census programs over decades shows far fewer high numbered 1972 cards have been accounted for versus counterparts in the 100-300 range.

Pricing and demand in the vintage trading card market today overwhelmingly favors 1972 rookie and star player cards with numbers 399 and above versus their lower counterparts.

Anecdotal accounts from collectors who opened packs as children in the early 70s commonly note they never saw cards numbered 400 and up despite completing much of the lower numbered portions of the set.

So in summarizing why 400 and above carries significance for 1972 Topps scarcity – the original design of the set by Topps, shrinking card populations verified by decades of data, and demand trends prove the elusive high numbered vintage gems from the 1972 set have stood the test of time as the biggest challenges for completing a set from that classic era of the hobby. Cards like Nolan Ryan’s imposing #523 rookie remain iconic symbols of the ultimate chase at the top of the 1972 checklist almost 50 years later.


Baseball cards have been collected by fans for over 130 years and are considered one of the classic American pastimes. While their popularity has waxed and waned over the decades, baseball cards remain a beloved hobby for people of all ages. As a collectible item, baseball cards exhibit the key characteristics of a normal good in economic terms.

Normal goods are those where demand increases as income increases. This relationship holds true for baseball cards. Higher-income collectors generally have more disposable income to spend on growing and improving their baseball card collections. They can afford to purchase rare, vintage cards or complete sets that may cost hundreds or thousands of dollars. Lower-income collectors have to be more selective in their card purchases due to budget constraints. As their earnings rise, they too will spend more on their hobby.

The early years of baseball card production from the late 1880s through the 1930s are considered the vintage era. Cards from this period featuring legends like Honus Wagner, Babe Ruth, and Ty Cobb are the most coveted and valuable. Even common vintage cards held little monetary worth for much of the 20th century. It was not until the 1980s that serious adult collectors rekindled interest and prices started rising. This surge in demand was directly tied to growing discretionary incomes as the American economy prospered in the Reagan years.

More affluent collectors could afford to spend big on rare vintage cards for their collections or as an investment. Prices skyrocketed from just pennies per card to hundreds or thousands for top specimens. This boom accelerated baseball cards’ evolution into a higher-end collecting niche. While youths still enjoyed opening new packs, adults now dominated the high-value vintage market. As the saying goes, only the rich could afford expensive hobbies. Baseball cards exemplified this as a normal good during their 1980s resurgence.

In the 1990s, interest from a new generation of collectors kept demand and prices buoyant. The late ’90s also saw overproduction and crashes that devalued common modern issues. This was partly due to speculators hoping to quickly profit rather than true collectors. Still, the vintage market held strong as affluent collectors with disposable income sought the rarest 19th century tobacco cards or early 20th century examples. Even in down periods, the high-dollar vintage segment acted as a normal good closely tied to economic cycles.

Since the turn of the 21st century, baseball cards have developed into a true dual market. On one side, the vintage rarities remain closely correlated with normal good properties. Prices at major auctions regularly set new records for elite cards as the collecting population ages into higher income brackets with more wealth. Examples include a 1909 Honus Wagner selling for over $3 million or a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle fetching over $5 million. These ultra-premium cards are almost exclusively purchased by the very wealthy.

In contrast, the modern mass-produced segment has taken on more public good qualities. Commons from the past few decades hold little resale value. They still provide enjoyment and nostalgia for millions who enjoy opening current packs or building sets for fun rather than profit. Youth participation remains strong despite a lack of monetary worth. This dichotomy means baseball cards today encompass traits of both normal and public goods depending on the specific market.

For serious adult collectors focused on appreciating vintage rarities, baseball cards absolutely behave as a normal good. Demand strongly correlates with economic prosperity cycles and individual income levels. In down periods like recessions, even affluent collectors become more cautious spenders. Prices stabilize or decline slightly before rebounding when growth returns. This normal relationship is clearly visible in auction sale graphs tracking the high-end market since the early 1980s. As a whole, the collecting population also skews toward older age groups with greater accumulated wealth to spend freely on the hobby.

Baseball cards provide a clear example of a good whose demand increases in line with income as predicted by the normal good economic model. This is especially evident regarding the rarest and most valuable vintage specimens targeted by affluent collectors. While youth participation and common modern issues take on more public good aspects, the high-end vintage market remains firmly tied to normal consumption patterns. As disposable income rises across different economic conditions, demand and prices follow suit cementing baseball cards’ status as a normal good.