Baseball cards were first introduced in the late 1880s as promotional items for various brands of chewing gum and tobacco. The earliest known baseball cards date back to the 1887-1890 era and are considered some of the most sought after and valuable collectibles in the sports card hobby. With over 130 years of history, cards from the early 1890s are truly treasures that provide a window into the origins of America’s favorite pastime.
In the 1880s, tobacco products like cigarettes were banned on baseball fields and stadiums which hurt tobacco company profits. To get their brands back into the game, companies like Goodwin & Company, American Tobacco Company and Allen & Ginter began inserting lithographed cards featuring baseball players into their products. The cards served as advertisements and incentives to purchase more gum and tobacco. The rise of mass production also made it possible to affordably mass produce player cards on a scale not seen before.
Among the earliest and most coveted baseball cards are those featuring stars from the late 1880s produced by the manufacturers above. Allen & Ginter is notable for producing what are considered the first actual baseball cards in 1886-1887 featuring single players with statistics and short bios on the back. But it was in 1888-1890 when most of the high value early vintage rookie and star cards were printed that really established the collectible market for this era.
Prices for intact, professionally graded examples of these ultra-rare early 19th century baseball cards can range significantly depending on several factors such as the player featured, the brand who issued it, and the condition and grade the card receives. In general here are price guides for some of the most noteworthy and expensive pre-1890 baseball cards to be aware of if you’re looking to add an authentic piece of sports collecting history to your collection:
1888/1889 Goodwin & Company “Cap Anson” – Without question, Anson is the most desirable early card featuring baseball’s first true superstar. PSA 8 examples can fetch upwards of $275,000 while a true PSA 5 in cracked but complete condition may still sell for $50,000-$125,000 depending on bidding.
1888/1889 Allen & Ginter “Big Four” (Cap Anson, King Kelly, Jim O’Rourke, John Ward) – This coveted set often referred to as the “Big Four” is the most famous and iconic subset from this era. Individual PSA 8 examples can sell for $100,000+ while a complete mint set in Gem Mint might achieve $500,000+.
1888 N172 Old Judge “Jake Beckley” – Beckley is one of the true rare pre-rookie star rookies of the time. An authentic example even in poor condition will sell for five figures typically with a PSA 5 bringing as much as $25,000-50,000.
1889 N30 Goodwin & Company “Buck Ewing” – As a catcher and one of baseball’s first true stars, Ewing remains one of the most popular early cards. Even heavily worn PSA 1 examples can bring $12,000-$20,000 based on collector demand.
1889 Allen & Ginter “King Kelly” – One of the most identifiable early cards due to its decorative border design. Near Mint PSA 8 copies are worth $50,000+ while a problem-free but well-centered PSA 5 will still fetch $10,000-25,000.
1889 Allen & Ginter “Dan Brouthers” – Brouthers was one of the early home run kings before the live ball era. High grade copies are rarely available but even lower conditioned authentic versions make $5,000-15,000.
1890 Allen & Ginter “Tim Keefe” – As one of the first pitching superstars, Keefe remains a highly coveted early issue. PSA 8 copies over $30,000 but a lower grade authentic example could easily sell for $7,500-15,000.
Of course, there are also many other valuable pre-1890 stars that could fetch five figures or more depending on condition from this pioneering early era of baseball cards including Bid McPhee, Doc Bushong, William “Broker” McGill, Jim McCormick and more. But the cards above represent some of the most famous, recognizable and historically important issues that truly set the standard for the immense value and demand that the earliest sports cards commands over 130 years later. With low surviving populations, the rewards of owning authentic vintage examples from this groundbreaking Period are immense for dedicated baseball card collectors.
The baseball cards produced between 1887 to 1890 were truly the pioneering period that established baseball as America’s national pastime and collectible sports cards as a mainstream hobby. Featuring the game’s first true superstars before statistics and team affiliations became standard, these rare and historic relics provide a means to connect to the roots of our national game. With extraordinary investment potential due to their scarcity and historical significance, authentic specimens from this formative era deserve a place in any serious card collection when the opportunity arises. With care and research, finding and adding one of these iconic early pieces of sports history to a collection is surely a thrill and a lifetime achievement for dedicated hobbyists.