The 1958 All Star Baseball cards inserted in Sport magazine formed a unique and memorable set that captured a specific point in time for American baseball. Both the set and the era it portrayed are remembered fondly by many baseball card collectors and fans today.
Sport was a general sports magazine published between 1938-1972 that included various inserts over the years. In 1958, they produced a 36-card set featuring 18 National League and 18 American League All Stars as selected in a fan vote that year. What made this set stand out was the timely nature of the cards—they were inserted fresh into issues of Sport magazine during the summer of 1958, allowing collectors to acquire cards of the very best players from that current MLB season.
Some key things to know about the 1958 Sport All Star baseball card set include:
Design: The cards featured a simple but classic design with a color team logo at top, black & white player photo below, and stats/description on the reverse. This no-frills approach allowed the cards to feel authentically of their era.
Photo Quality: While not the highest photographic quality by today’s standards, the photos still captured the players and their uniforms well. Seeing stars like Mays, Aaron, and Mantle in their on-field gear from 1958 is a treat for collectors.
Rarity: Being magazine inserts from over 60 years ago limits surviving populations today. Graded high-end examples can fetch thousands due to their historical significance and scarcity in the marketplace.
Star Power: The set is a who’s who of late 1950s baseball legends, including future Hall of Famers like Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, Richie Ashburn, Eddie Mathews, Robin Roberts, and more. Many were playing in their primes when these cards were distributed.
Piece of History: Collecting the entire 36-card set stitches together a snapshot of the very best MLB had to offer during a fascinating period for the sport. It was a time of racial integration, rising television audiences, and larger-than-life superstar players.
Beyond just the cards themselves, the 1958 season and late 1950s baseball era provides important historical context for the Sport All Star set. Some broader themes and events surrounding this period included:
Integration and Social Change: Willie Mays, Hank Aaron and other black stars were achieving mainstream success and helping drive integration on both social and athletic levels. Their inclusion in this popular card set was symbolic.
Era of the Superstar: Charismatic sluggers like Mays, Aaron, Mantle, Killebrew and others were ushering in an new age where individual players became nationally renowned celebrities off the field as well.
Post-World War 2 Prosperity: America was experiencing strong economic growth after years of global conflict and depression. Sports card collecting was booming as a family-friendly hobby among the burgeoning US middle class.
Rise of National Pastime: Television was exploding nationwide and helped turn baseball into America’s undisputed national pastime. New franchises and stadiums were popping up as the sport’s fortunes reached new peaks.
Last Hurrahs: Many star players from the 1940s and early 50s were still in their prime, with Roberts, Spahn, Dark and others leading their respective leagues. Some were entering the final stretches of truly remarkable careers.
In capturing a specific season frozen in time, the 1958 Sport All Star cards are especially valuable for examining the larger context and changes unfolding around baseball during this transition period between eras. While stars like Mays, Aaron and Mantle would remain fixtures for years to come, other veterans were passing the torch to a new generation of sluggers that would dominate the 1960s.
In terms of condition and availability today, high-grade specimens from the 1958 Sport set command steep prices due to their inherent rarity and historical nature. PSA-graded examples of popular stars frequently sell for thousands, with rookies and key outliers achieving even greater sums. Simply finding intact lower-grade copies to check off want lists remains difficult due its limited initial print run over 60 years ago.
For dedicated baseball card collectors and fans of 1950s MLB history, the 1958 Sport All Star issue holds a special place. It managed to perfectly capture the very best the big leagues had to offer during one singular summer long ago. Decades later, these low-key magazine inserts continue sharing their compelling snapshot of the national pastime from a bygone American era that many still look back on fondly. Their staying power is a testament to both the talent they depict and collectible nostalgia surrounding the vintage card hobby itself.
