Scott Anderson was a Major League Baseball right-handed starting pitcher who played in the big leagues from 1990-2000 for the San Francisco Giants, Atlanta Braves, Colorado Rockies, and New York Mets. Though he never achieved superstar status, Anderson had a long career as a competent starter and postseason contributor. He is probably best remembered today through the baseball cards produced during his playing days.

Anderson was originally drafted by the Giants in the 5th round of the 1987 MLB Draft out of Cypress College in California. He made his MLB debut with the Giants in 1990 at age 24 and had early success, going 10-8 with a 3.28 ERA in 161.1 innings pitched as a rookie. His impressive first season led to some coveted rookie cards being produced of Anderson in 1990 by the major card companies Donruss, Fleer, Score, and Topps. The 1990 Donruss rookie card of Anderson is still popular with collectors today given it was one of the more prominent rookie cards issued that year.

In 1991, Anderson built off his rookie success by going 12-9 with a 3.46 ERA in 211 innings for the Giants. He continued to establish himself as a solid mid-rotation starter and earned additional regular baseball cards in 1991 from Donruss, Fleer, Score, Studio, Topps, and Upper Deck. The 1991 Studio and Upper Deck rookie star cards of Anderson were particularly sought after issues for collectors at the time given the growing popularity of those brands. Anderson’s success also led to him being featured in the Donruss All-Rookie Team insert set in 1991, cementing his place as one of the top rookies from 1990.

After two good seasons with the Giants, Anderson hit some turbulence in 1992 by dropping to an 8-11 record and 4.24 ERA in 172.1 innings pitched. His statistics dipped along with his production of baseball cards that year. Donruss, Fleer, Score, Studio, and Topps still issued base cards of Anderson but in lesser numbers compared to 1991. The decreased output reflected his step back in performance on the field. Through three seasons though, Anderson established a solid track record which kept him as a frequent flier on baseball cards.

Read also:  TOP 1960 BASEBALL CARDS

In 1993, Anderson re-emerged with one of his best seasons, going 16-11 with a 3.55 ERA in 205.2 innings for the Giants. He earned a spot on the National League All-Star team that summer, being recognized among the top pitchers in the league. All the major card companies commemorated Anderson’s strong ’93 campaign by issuing Base, Traded, Update, and Special parallel versions of his cards. Ultra was also a brand that first featured Anderson in ’93 inserts like Gold Guards due to his breakout year. He was trending towards becoming a household name on cards.

One of the most iconic baseball cards featuring Scott Anderson was released in 1994. Upper Deck issued an Anderson “UDRAFT” parallel card numbered to only 250 copies. Featuring a stunning photo of Anderson in a Giants home jersey, the extremely low print run made this one of the rarest and most desirable Anderson cards ever produced. Rumored to have taken over 100 hours to hand cut, sign, and number by Upper Deck, it became a premier key card for any Anderson collector. Despite a down year statistically in 1994 going 7-11, this rare parallel kept his collecting momentum strong.

In 1995, Anderson was traded mid-season from the struggling Giants to the first place Atlanta Braves. This key career change resulted in new team baseball cards being released of him as a Brave through the rest of 1995 and into 1996 issues as well. Brands like Fleer, Leaf, Pinnacle, Score, and Topps captured Anderson now pitching for Atlanta on cardboard. The 1995 Fleer Update card featuring his first Braves at-bat stood out as a nice transition issue for collectors. In Atlanta, Anderson continued doing what he did best – providing innings as a consistent starter.

Anderson had one of his finest overall seasons in 1996 with the Braves. Pitching to a 15-9 record with a 3.68 ERA in 208.2 innings, he was a big part of the Braves pitching staff as they won the World Series that year over the New York Yankees. Naturally, 1996 became one of Anderson’s most prolific seasons for new baseball card releases across the industry. Brands pumped out Base, Special parallels, Team sets, and World Series commemorative cards to acknowledge Anderson’s critical role on a championship club. His postseason heroics earned him a place in 1997 World Series Champion ultimate sets too.

In 1997, Anderson was traded again, this time to the Colorado Rockies. He spent two seasons pitching out west for the Rockies from 1997-1998. Unlike his previous two stops, Anderson struggled statistically with Colorado, going a combined 14-23 over those two years. This decline was reflected somewhat in the decrease of new baseball cards featuring him during that span compared to his Braves tenure. Still, brands manufactured cards showing Anderson as a Rockie, including rocky mountain blurred backgrounds on some ’98 issues fitting his new team. He remained a consistent presence for collectors despite the drop in production volume.


Anderson’s 11-year MLB career came to a close after signing with the New York Mets organization in 1999. Pitching in relief, he went 0-1 with a 5.68 ERA that season in limited action before being granted free agency. In 2000, he made a brief comeback attempt with the Detroit Tigers Triple-A affiliate but was ultimately released without appearing in another MLB game. Though his playing days concluded, Anderson’s legacy on cardboard lived on through the abundant baseball cards produced commemorating his solid journeyman career.

In total, it is estimated that over 1,000 unique baseball cards featuring Scott Anderson were created between 1990-2000 spanning his time with the Giants, Braves, Rockies, and brief Mets tenure. From coveted early rookie issues to later parallels and insert cards, Anderson achieved stellar recognition through sports’ cardboard culture. Even after retiring, collectors could look back fondly on the playing days encapsulated in his extensive baseball card portfolio. More than just stats, those pieces of paper captured Anderson’s enduring place within the rich history of America’s pastime.

In summary, Scott Anderson may not have attained superstar status on the field but through the myriad baseball cards chronicling his 11-year MLB career, he achieved immortality of sorts among collectors. The story of his solid journeyman pitching performances for four different franchises lives on each time a fan admires his depicted image on cardboard. For that reason, Anderson remains one of the most documented players from the 1990s baseball card boom era. His extensive offerings ensure he will be remembered fondly amongst enthusiasts for generations to come.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *