1957 was a pivotal year in baseball history as the New York Yankees dynasty was starting to show signs of slowing down after nearly two decades of dominance. Led by legends like Mickey Mantle, Whitey Ford, and Yogi Berra, the ’57 Yankees won the American League pennant but fell short in the World Series against the Milwaukee Braves. This team’s baseball cards from the ’57 season are highly sought after by collectors today. Let’s take a closer look at some of the key players and examine what their cards are currently selling for according to the latest price guides.
Mickey Mantle was undoubtedly the biggest star on the ’57 Yankees and one of the greatest players of all time. As the team’s center fielder and cleanup hitter, Mantle posted another MVP-caliber season batting .365 with 34 home runs and 94 RBIs. His ’57 Topps card is one of the most iconic in the entire set and is still among the most valuable baseball cards on the market. In near-mint to mint condition, Mantle’s ’57 Topps card regularly sells for $150,000-$250,000 at auction depending on centering and corners. The card has incredible nostalgia and Mantle mania attached to it that drives the price up compared to other vintage cards.
Another Yankee superstar of that era was pitcher Whitey Ford. As the ace of the staff and 16-game winner in ’57, Ford was a leader of that team. His ’57 Topps card is highly sought after by collectors but doesn’t command the same price tag as Mantle due to lower print run and the inherent risk of condition issues that come with pitching cards over the years. Still, a PSA-graded Ford in Gem Mint condition would sell for $15,000-$25,000 based on recent sales. Catcher Yogi Berra was also a cornerstone player for the Yankees dynasty. His cheerful demeanor and clutch hitting made him a fan favorite for decades. In top condition, Berra’s ’57 Topps card sells in the $3,000-$5,000 range.
Moving down the roster, outfielder Hank Bauer and shortstop Tony Kubek were also key cogs for that ’57 team. As a reliable run producer, Bauer’s card in top shape would sell for $1,000-$2,000. For Kubek, who won a Gold Glove that season, his card in similar condition trades hands between $800-$1,500. Pitchers like Bob Turley, Johnny Kucks, and Tom Sturdivant also have cards from that set that hold value of $300-$700 depending on grade. More common players on the bench like Norm Siebern, Dale Mitchell, and Ed Fitz Gerald can be acquired in high grades for $100-300.
For Yankee rookies from that season, cards of future stars like Bobby Richardson, Hector Lopez, and Ralph Terry are especially popular. Richardson had a breakout rookie campaign and his ’57 Topps RC in a PSA 8 or above would sell for $1,000-$2,000. Lopez and Terry rookie cards in similar condition trade between $500-$1,000. Even backups like Jerry Lumpe, John Blanchard, and Don Larsen, who tossed a perfect game in the ’56 World Series, have rookie cards valued at $200-$500 depending on quality.
The 1957 Topps set that captured this iconic Yankees team is considered one of the most, if not the most, important vintage baseball card sets of all time. With Hall of Famers on nearly every line of the roster coupled with their sustained run of success, cards from this set will likely never lose their luster for collectors. Centering the condition scale around a PSA 8, most of these Yankee stars from ’57 can be acquired for $1,000-$5,000 with Mantle as the glaring exception. For a complete, high-grade ’57 Topps set, an auction price of $75,000+ would not be unreasonable based on population reports and recent sales data. The mystique of that Yankees dynasty lives on through the cardboard they left behind in ’57.
