The 1991 Fleer baseball card set was issued at the tail end of the junk wax era during which production of baseball cards exploded, decreasing scarcity and therefore collectors’ value. The 1991 set featured 660 total cards including base cards, rookie cards, stars, and variations.
Some key highlights and valuations about specific cards in the 1991 Fleer set include:
Ken Griffey Jr. rookie card (#501): Considered one of the most iconic rookie cards of all-time. Griffey was already a rising star in 1991. High grade examples can sell for thousands in individual auctions but most complete sets don’t have pristine Griffey rookies. Still, it adds significant value to any ’91 Fleer set.
Juan Gonzalez rookie card (#500): Gonzalez went on to have a solid career winning back-to-back AL MVP awards in 1998-1999. Due to lower supply versus Griffey, grade NM-MT examples can reach $100-300 individually.
Andy Benes rookie card (#516): As the #1 pick in the 1988 draft, Benes had promise but an eventual mediocre career. His rookie holds little current value at $5-10 individually.
Don Mattingly card (#25): Mattingly was one of baseball’s biggest stars in the late 80s/early 90s. His commons may fetch $5-10 while higher graded versions could reach $50-100 individually for a true star/HOF collector.
Nolan Ryan card (#90): Even in his aging 40s, Ryan was still one of baseball’s most popular players. His commons hold steady value around $5-10 while more desirable versions reach $20-50.
Ozzie Smith card (#98): The Wizard was a fan favorite for his defensive wizardry. Common versions of his ’91 Fleer card are $3-7 while better condition copies may reach $20-40.
Bo Jackson card (#134): Even though his baseball career was cut short, Jackson remained one of the most physically gifted athletes of all time. His ’91 Fleer card tends to sell in the $8-15 range.
In their untouched state straight from 1991 factory-sealed wax packs, complete sets usually sell in the range of $75-150. As with most late 80s/early 90s sets, condition is key. Near complete runs (650-660 cards) in excellent centered Near Mint condition with only a handful of flaws could fetch $250-500 from avid collectors. And a true gem mint set graded by PSA or BGS with all cards grading high could potentially reach $1,000-2,000 from dedicated hobbyists, especially if the big name rookies grade well.
Long term, as millennials and younger generations enter their peak spending years, demand for stars of their childhood from the late 80s/90s is likely to remain strong. And iconic rookie cards like Griffey which were mass produced but have since held value despite supply could continue their steady appreciation over the decades. But for less desirable common cards, values are likely to remain flat. In the end, the ’91 Fleer set constitutes an affordable way for collectors to acquire cards of their favorite players from baseball’s previous eras, provided they can find complete high grade examples. While less valuable than earlier vintage issues, it still encapsulates a snapshot in time from the early 90s game.
While mass produced sets like 1991 Fleer don’t rival the value of true vintage cards, complete near mint examples with stars and key rookies grading nicely continue to hold collector interest three decades later. Condition sensitive, they sell most often in the $75-500 range depending on overall quality, with true gem mint10 examples potentially reaching $1,000-2,000 for dedicated collectors and investors. The inclusion of a legendary rookie card like Ken Griffey Jr. adds much to any ’91 Fleer baseball set’s long term appeal, keeping this particular issue relevant amongst fans and collectors of the era.
