The 1940 Play Ball baseball card set is one of the most iconic and valuable card sets from the Golden Age of baseball cards in the pre-war era. Issued by the American Chicle Company, the 1940 Play Ball set stands out as the last major set produced before wartime paper shortages led to the suspension of new card production until after World War 2 had ended. The 1940 Play Ball cards feature all 16 major league teams from that season and include the stars of that era like Ted Williams, Bob Feller, and Joe DiMaggio. Collectors today still prize finding a complete near-mint or mint set from the 1940 Play Ball cards due to their historical significance and the quality of the classic card designs.
The 1940 Play Ball cards were issued as gum and small stick of chewing gum packaged with each card. Like most early card sets, they measured 2 1/8 inches by 2 3/4 inches in size and featured player likenesses on the front with basic stats like batting average on the back. Some the notable things about the 1940 Play Ball design was the Art Deco inspired graphics printed in colors of red, dark blue and light blue. Team logos and names were prominently featured across the top of each card. The cards stock was of high quality thick paper stock that has held up remarkably well given the cards are now over 80 years old.
All 16 major league teams were represented in the 160 card base set, with 10 cards issued for each club. Notable rookies included Ted Williams’ first card and Joe DiMaggio’s second card after his impressive 1939 rookie season that saw him win the American League batting title. Other young stars like Lou Boudreau, Phil Rizzuto, and Stan Musial had some of their earliest issued cards in the 1940 set as well. Veterans stars included Dizzy Dean, Mel Ott, Lefty Gomez, and Hank Greenberg. The set also included 12 additional minor league player cards, making a total of 172 total cards issued in the full 1940 Play Ball release.
While production and distribution of the cards was affected by paper shortages as World War 2 escalated, around 2.5 to 3 million complete sets of the 1940 Play Ball cards were successfully released in stores. They retailed for 1 cent per card or 15 cents for a complete rubber band sealed set. Despite their relatively large initial print run, high quality complete 1940 sets in gem mint condition today are valued between $15,000 to $25,000 depending on centering and state of preservation. Even well-kept near mint sets that grade between a 8 to 9 out of 10 can fetch $7,500 to $10,000 at auction.
Part of what makes finding a pristine 1940 set so rare and valuable today is due to how the cards have held up and survived over 80+ years. Paper quality was not as high as would become standard in later decades and the gum and starch ingredients used tended to damage edges on cheaper stock. Although millions of kids enjoyed and collected the sets in the 1940s, time and improper care have diminished the surviving population down to a fraction of the original print run. Cellophane wrappers or rubber band sealed full factory sets offer the best chance of all cards remaining in tidy near mint condition.
While the vintage appeal and condition of a complete 1940 Play Ball set draws many collectors, the individual significant rookie and star player cards themselves remain highly sought after as well. A Ted Williams PSA 9 gem mint rookie in particular can sell for well over $1,000 on its own due to his status as a baseball icon. Other individual standouts like a PSA 8+ Mel Ott, PSA 9 Lou Boudreau rookie, or Hank Greenberg tend to range between $300 to $700 depending on grade. Even commons from the set in high grades will sell in the $50 to $150 range.
Beyond the iconic rookie cards and star players of the day, the 1940 Play Ball set is also historically important as one of the last true “pre-war” issues that still retain that early 20th century baseball card aesthetic before production was permanently altered coming out of World War 2. They marked the end of an era and captured a unique snapshot of the baseball stars from that transition season. As such, high quality complete 1940 Play Ball sets remain a prized trophy in most vintage card collections and considered one of the most significant releases from the entire Golden Age period in terms of historical, condition and monetary value. Their relative scarcity compared to post-war runs ensures the 1940 Play Ball cards will continue to be widely collected and highly sought after vintage issue for generations of baseball card enthusiasts to come.