One of the most well-known and reliable places to sell baseball cards in Memphis is at Midtown Comics. Midtown Comics has two locations in Memphis – one in East Memphis located at 5849 Poplar Avenue Suite 112 and another location in South Main Arts District at 2650 Broad Avenue. Midtown Comics pays cash for sports card collections and individual rare/valuable cards in good condition. They have experts who can properly evaluate collections and offer fair market value for the cards. Selling to a large dedicated comic/card shop provides peace of mind that your cards are going to knowledgeable collectors. Midtown also buys full team sets, stars from specific eras, and vintage cards from the 1950s/1960s. If you’re looking to liquidate a large collection quickly, Midtown Comics can often make an offer the same day.
Another excellent option in Memphis is to sell your baseball cards to Gametime Sports Cards & Collectibles, located at 2889 Barron Avenue in East Memphis. Gametime Sports Cards specializes solely in buying, selling, and trading all things related to sports cards and memorabilia. They have a loyal customer base of knowledgeable collectors and will pay cash for valuable individual cards or full collections on the spot. Selling to Gametime allows you to get top dollar for rarer finds because they focus only on the card market and have built strong relationships with Memphis-area enthusiasts. Gametime may be able to get the best price compared to a more general comic/toy shop since cards are their expertise. Their staff is friendly and knowledgeable to help evaluate sets or answer any questions.
If you’d prefer to sell baseball cards online, eBay is a widely used marketplace. To receive the highest sale price and avoid issues with scammers or inaccurate listings, it’s best to go through a dedicated third party seller on eBay with experience consigning sports memorabilia and cards. In Memphis, Sports Card Exchange is a highly reputable eBay consignment business located at 1126 Jackson Avenue that specializes in auctioning off sports collectibles. They handle the photography, description, shipping, and customer service so you don’t have to deal with any of it. Sports Card Exchange takes a commission (usually 10-15%) but you’ll reach the broadest potential buyer base through their active eBay store. They also pay proceeds promptly and can advise on rare card grades and values.
More locally, online Facebook groups like “Memphis Sports Cards Buy/Sell/Trade” and “Memphis Area Sports Cards & Memorabilia” allow you to post photos of your collection directly to an active market of regional collectors. You can often sell individual teams, players, or full sets on Facebook for reasonable prices vs trying to piece out deals. However, Facebook sales require more organizing photos/details yourself and only local pickups or potentially shipping within TN. Social media is best as a supplemental sales method along with the dedicated shops.
For guaranteed top dollar and smoothest experience, consider consigning valuable baseball card collections or rare finds to Midtown Comics, Gametime Sports Cards, or Sports Card Exchange in Memphis. Their expertise and national buyer reach will ensure fair prices. Local Facebook groups are a supplemental option. Whichever avenue you choose, doing research on current card values and carefully protecting items will lead to the highest returns on a baseball card sale in Memphis.
