Sportscardz NYC – Located in Manhattan, Sportscardz NYC has one of the largest retail stores dedicated to sports cards, memorabilia, and collectibles in New York. They have racks filled with new and vintage baseball cards for all teams and players. Some of their vendors specialize in high-end autographed and rare cards as well. In addition to loose packs and boxes of new cards, they buy, sell, and trade cards as well. Their knowledgeable staff can also help you find a specific card you’re looking for or provide valuations.
Lelands – For the more serious collector looking for rare and valuable baseball cards, Lelands auction house in Manhattan holds live auction events and also offers private sales. They regularly auction off six, seven and even eight figure baseball cards that are one-of-a-kind specimens. Even if you’re just browsing, it’s a cool experience to see some of the most valuable sports cards in the world. While prices are high, their experts can also assess your collection’s value.
Blue Screw – Located in Brooklyn, Blue Screw is a locally-owned nostalgic gaming shop with a large selection of new and vintage baseball cards for buying and browsing. Their prices tend to be fair and they focus on movable singles in plastic sheets rather than higher-end graded cards. It’s a great spot to find affordable cards from across the decades to build your own collection or fill in ones you’re missing.
City Sports Kings – City Sports Kings has two locations that are good options for buying baseball cards – one in Queens at the Flushing Meadows Corona Park and one in Manhattan near Columbus Circle. Both shops carry new wax packs, boxes and supplies but also have collector-friendly cases filled with graded vintage and modern cards sorted by player/team. Prices are reasonable and staff knowledgeable about the hobby.
Card Shack – Operating out of Manhattan’s iconic card shop Hub Hobby, Card Shack has a deep selection of new and used baseball cards available by the single, lot or box. You can find everything from affordable vintage commons to autographs, refractors and parallels of star players from past and present. It’s smaller than some shops but very well organized and competitively priced with knowledgeable folks to assist first-timers or serious collectors.
Steiner Sports – While primarily focused on signed memorabilia, game-worn jerseys and equipment, Steiner Sports’ memorabilia store in Manhattan also stocks a range of new and sealed baseball card products including hobby boxes, blasters, fat packs and more from recent seasons. They don’t have a large collection of singles but if you’re looking for some fresh wax to rip at a brick and mortar shop, it’s a reliable option.
CardIt – With locations in Queens, Brooklyn and Manhattan, CardIt shops are solid options for finding loose baseball cards priced reasonably. They carry a wide assortment across all eras and price points housed in wooden card cases organized alphabetically by player/team. The Manhattan location tends to have the largest stock while all staff are knowledgeable about the cards they sell. Great for building sets or just browsing at fair prices.
In addition to these stores, card shows, flea markets and conventions in the NYC area regularly host vendors who bring an array of baseball cards for sale at varying price points. Major card conventions like the National Sports Collectors Convention tend to be held in New Jersey but offer a massive selection under one roof from top memorabilia dealers nationwide. Online services through eBay, COMC and similar sites also provide access to the huge array of vintage and modern cards available from sellers worldwide. Overall, New York City offers collectors extensive accessible options to buy the baseball cards they seek.
