One of the most well-known and reliable places to sell baseball cards in Las Vegas is Card Collector Universe located at 5555 Arville St, Las Vegas, NV 89118. They have been in business for over 15 years and are a large establishment that specializes only in buying, selling, and trading sports and non-sports collectible cards. They have buyers in everyday that are knowledgeable about the value of different cards and sets. They do all transactions by appointment only, so you will need to call ahead to schedule a time to bring in your cards for an offer. Their buyers will look through your entire collection, give you a lump sum cash offer, and if you accept, they will pay you on the spot. They do not offer consignment options.
Another good option is Card Collector’s Heaven, which has locations at 4175 S. Buffalo Dr #11, Las Vegas, NV 89147 and 5615 W Desert Inn Rd #118, Las Vegas, NV 89146. Similar to Card Collector Universe, they are a dedicated card shop that focuses only on sports cards. Their buyers have decades of experience evaluating collections. They will also make you an immediate cash offer after reviewing your cards. One advantage over Card Collector Universe is that for larger collections valued over $1000, they may be able to offer a percentage of the final selling price if you want to accept store credit instead of cash. This allows the opportunity to potentially get more money if your cards end up selling for higher amounts after they list them.
A couple pawn shops that are worth checking with for baseball card appraisals and cash offers include Silver State Pawn at 8501 W Sahara Ave, Las Vegas, NV 89117 and USA Pawn at 4312 E Craig Rd, Las Vegas, NV 89115. While pawn shops deal in a wider range of used merchandise, they do regularly purchase and sell collectibles such as sports cards. The advantage of pawn shops is they tend to offer somewhat higher percentages of the estimated resale value compared to dedicated card shops that have lower operating costs. Their buyers may not have quite as in-depth knowledge of the card market. You would need to call ahead for an appointment at their locations to have your cards reviewed.
If you want potential higher long term returns and don’t need immediate cash, another solid option is consigning your baseball cards to an online dealer like eBay seller SportsCardSellers. They have an office located in Las Vegas and have been in business for over 20 years with a very high seller rating. They specialize in consigning collections and have connections to buyers around the world. Their experienced consignment directors can help you pick out the best individual cards to list for auction, and they currently take a 15% selling commission plus packaging and shipping costs. They handle all photography, descriptions, customer service, and shipping. Plus you have a much larger potential buyer pool than selling locally. It may take 3-6 months for all your cards to auction, but you may end up receiving a higher total price than a one-time cash offer.
For one-of-a-kind valuable cards especially pre-1980 vintage, you could consider making an appointment with a local coin and collectibles shop like Great Basin Coin & Collectibles, located at 4212 S Decatur Blvd #8, Las Vegas, NV 89103. While they mainly deal in coins, currency, and vintage paper items, they do have contacts in the antique sports card marketplace. Their experts can assess condition, assign a fair estimated value, and help advise where to best sell such as online or at collector’s shows and auctions for top dollar. They do not actually purchase cards themselves but may be able to point you towards serious vintage collectors.
Those are some of the most trusted and reliable options locals and tourists use when looking to sell baseball card collections in Las Vegas. Calling ahead for appointments at dedicated card shops, pawn shops, or sending your valuable cards to an established online consigner are usually the best bets for getting a fair price. Selling locally allows getting cash quickly, while consignment may fetch potentially higher long term returns. With so many shops and dealers in the area, there are usually several alternatives to pick from to get top dollar when parting with your baseball collectibles.
