One of the most valuable cards from the 1991 Upper Deck set is the Ken Griffey Jr. rookie card. Griffey Jr. went on to have an outstanding career and is considered one of the greatest players of all time. His rookie card is one of the most iconic and sought after in the entire hobby. In a PSA 10 gem mint condition, Griffey Jr.’s rookie currently sells for over $10,000 and has reached as high as $22,000 in auctions. Even in lower grades of PSA 8 or 9, it still fetches thousands. This is because Griffey was such a talented, exciting young player who really took the league by storm in his rookie year in 1989.
Another extremely valuable 1991 Upper Deck card is the Frank Thomas rookie card. Like Griffey, Thomas had one of the best and most productive careers of any player in the 1990s. He won two MVP awards and racked up over 500 home runs and 1,500 RBI in his career. In pristine mint condition, a PSA 10 graded Frank Thomas rookie has sold for around $7,000-$9,000. But even in lower grades, it commands $2,000 or more because collectors appreciate his dominance during the 1990s as one of baseball’s premier sluggers. Thomas was just starting to break out in 1991, making his first rookie card in high demand for collectors of him.
Two other notable rookies worth big money from the 1991 Upper Deck set are Chipper Jones and Brad Ausmus. Chipper Jones went on to have a Hall of Fame career with the Atlanta Braves and is considered one of the greatest third basemen ever. A PSA 10 Chipper Jones rookie can sell for $4,000-$6,000. Meanwhile, catcher Brad Ausmus did not have the career production of the others, but he was nonetheless a key rookie in 1991 who played in the league for 18 years. In top grades like a PSA 9, his rookie has sold for $800-$1,000, showing the demand even for lessheralded players’ first cards.
In addition to popular rookies, 1991 Upper Deck also featured valuable cards of veteran superstars. One of the most significant veteran cards is the Nolan Ryan Express card, depicting him in mid-windup for the Texas Rangers. With his express train nickname and the capturing of his epic fastball, this Ryan issue sells for $2,000-$3,000 in high grades like PSA 9-10. The Ken Griffey Sr. and Roberto Alomar cards are also coveted by collectors for their subject’s talents and tend to sell in the $500-$1000 range in top condition. Stars like Cal Ripken Jr., Ryne Sandberg, and Tony Gwynn routinely demand $200-$500 even in lower grades from collectors wanting cards of these Hall of Famers.
Two inserts from 1991 Upper Deck that consistently sell for $1,000 or more are the Turkey Red parallel set and Draft Picks special issue cards. The parallel Turkey Red cards were printed on ultra-thick card stock and featured similar but subtly contrasting designs from the base set. Specific Turkey Red singles of sought-after players like Griffey Jr. and Frank Thomas tend to attract bids over $1,000 when pristine. Likewise, the Draft Picks insert set highlighting stars directly out of high school like B.J. Surhoff and Darren Daulton bring similar prices in top condition due to their rarity and subject matter highlighting the UD set’s theme of talented young future pros.
While it featured many valuable stars and rookies, 1991 Upper Deck had a special allure and proved hugely influential as one of the earliest modern mass-produced baseball sets upon release. This is evident given how well its cards have held value and appreciation over the decades since. Whether owing to rookie cards of soon-to-be superstars, inserts highlighting young talent, or depictions of seasoned vets, the 1991 Upper Deck release contained many individual cards that can be considered true collector’s gems worth well over $1,000 in high grades to this day.
