The 1991 Fleer baseball card set is considered by many collectors to be one of the best and most valuable Fleer releases from the late 1980s and early 1990s. While the majority of cards from this 700+ card set hold relatively little monetary value today, there are certainly some standout rookie and star player cards that can be quite valuable, especially if they are in top graded condition.
One of the headlining rookies from the 1991 Fleer set is Rod Beck’s rookie card. Beck went on to have a solid 16 year career as a relief pitcher, tallying 168 saves over that span. In top graded gem mint condition, his rookie card has sold for over $300. Another notable rookie is Dennis Martinez’s card. As one of the more accomplished Latin American pitchers of his era, Martinez’s rookie is popular with collectors and has sold for up to $150 in top shape. Paul O’Neill, who would go on to win a World Series with the Yankees and have a stellar career, also has a relatively valuable rookie card from this set, fetching $50-75 in top condition.
In addition to rookie stars, the 1991 Fleer set contains cards featuring some of the game’s biggest players at the time that can hold solid value. Perhaps the most famous card from the set is the Ken Griffey Jr upper deck rookie card, which was accidentally packaged within the 1991 Fleer wax packs. This accident made the Griffey Jr UD rookie one of the rarest and most desired baseball cards ever. While outside the ‘official’ 1991 Fleer checklist, finding one of these rare misprinted Griffey cards in pack is essentially priceless.
Moving to cards actually in the Fleer ’91 checklist, cards featuring superstar sluggers like Barry Bonds and Mark McGwire can be quite valuable in high grades. Bonds’ 1991 Fleer card has sold for over $100 in Mint condition, while McGwire’s powerful image from that season has sold for $75-100 graded Mint. Pitching legends Tom Glavine, Greg Maddux, and John Smoltz all debuted in the 1991 Fleer set as well, with their rookie cards valued around $50-75 in top shape. Like Martinez, these three would go on to have tremendous success both individually and together as teammates on dominant Braves staffs.
Among the set’s biggest star veterans, Nolan Ryan’s 1991 Fleer card is one of the most valuable from that year. Known for his blistering fastball and record-setting strikeouts late into his 40s, Ryan was still considered one of baseball’s most exciting and dominant hurlers in 1991. His card has been known to sell for upwards of $150 in top graded condition. Kirby Puckett, who was coming off back-to-back World Series titles and MVPs with the Twins, also has a valuable ’91 Fleer card at the $75-100 level in top shapes.
While most cards from the expansive 1991 Fleer baseball set hold relatively little individual value, there are numerous star rookie and veteran cards that baseball card collectors actively seek out and are willing to pay handsomely for if presented in pristine mint condition. For those willing to put in the effort to locate and grade these valuable standouts, the 1991 Fleer release remains one of the most fun and potentially profitable sets from the early 90s baseball card boom.
