MOST VALUABLE 1995 FLEER ULTRA BASEBALL CARDS

The 1995 Fleer Ultra baseball card set showcased some of the biggest names and rising stars in Major League Baseball during the mid-1990s. While not one of the larger Fleer sets produced during that time period in terms of total card count, 1995 Fleer Ultra contained several highly sought after rookie cards and stars of the era that have led to certain cards appreciating greatly in value over the past 25+ years. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most valuable 1995 Fleer Ultra baseball cards on the collectors market today based on their current average sold prices.

Ken Griffey Jr. Ultra Star Refractor (#US50) – Widely considered one of the most iconic and valuable baseball cards ever printed, the Griffey Jr. Ultra Star Refractor is the true crown jewel of the 1995 Fleer Ultra set. Only 24 of these refractive parallels were produced, making it an incredibly rare pull even back in the 1990s. Today, mint condition Ultra Star Refractor #US50 Griffey rookie cards in a PSA/BGS 10 Gem Mint have sold for over $100,000. Even well-centered low-grade examples still fetch five-figure prices. Griffey’s magnificent career and popularity as “The Kid” have cemented this as one of the holy grails for collectors.

Derek Jeter Ultra Base Rookie (#73) – As one of the greatest shortstops in baseball history and a surefire first-ballot Hall of Famer, Derek Jeter’s spectacular career has turned his 1995 Fleer Ultra rookie into another highly sought after card. PSA/BGS 10 Jeter rookie prices have reached as high as $30,000-$40,000 in recent sales. Even mid-grade copies still sell for thousands given his name recognition and on-field accomplishments spanning two decades with the Yankees. This serves as a prime example of how sustained success at the highest level can significantly boost a player’s rookie card values.

Read also:  1995 PINNACLE BASEBALL CARDS VALUE

Tom Glavine Ultra Base Rookie (#160) – Although overshadowed statistically by other lefty aces of his era such as Randy Johnson and John Smoltz, Glavine still had a Hall of Fame worthy career spanning 22 seasons. As a two-time Cy Young Award winner and integral part of the 1995 World Series champion Braves, his rookie card has gained steady value increases in PSA/BGS 10 condition – regularly fetching $3,000-$5,000. This serves as a reminder that even “quiet” superstar careers can produce valuable rookie cards if the player achieved team and individual success at baseball’s highest level.

Roy Halladay Ultra Base Rookie (#198) – Known as “Doc” for his workhorse consistency, Roy Halladay was one of the most dependable aces in baseball from 1998-2013 mostly with the Blue Jays and Phillies. A two-time Cy Young winner, perfect game pitcher, and playoff standout – Halladay’s tragic death in a plane crash in 2017 only magnified collectors’ appreciation for his rookie card. PSA/BGS 10 Halladay rookies have sold between $2,500-$4,000 in recent years as a testament to his great career and untimely passing increasing demand from both Phillies and Blue Jays collectors.

Read also:  BASEBALL CARDS FROM 1961

Chipper Jones Ultra Base Rookie (#261) – As the longtime sparkplug and hometown hero for the Atlanta Braves dynasty teams, Chipper Jones put together a surefire Hall of Fame career at third base mostly with the Braves from 1995-2012. That sustained excellence and popularity in Atlanta has pushed mint PSA/BGS 10 copies of his Ultra rookie card up near $2,000-$3,000 price levels. A19 year career hitting over .300 while playing for consistent contenders always helps a player’s collectibility and rookie card values.

Dante Bichette Ultra Base Rookie (#293) – While not a true “star” strictly based on ability, Dante Bichette managed to put up some gaudy offensive stats during his 14-year career – especially with the Colorado Rockies. From 1995-98 with Colorado, Bichette racked up 118 home runs and an impressive .299/.358/.561 slash line. That power surge and being one of the early stars for Rockies has increased demand for his Ultra rookie considerably. PSA/BGS 10 grades now sell around $800-$1,200 range.

Read also:  TIMS BASEBALL CARDS

Other 1995 Fleer Ultra notable rookies that have gained value include: C Todd Helton (#341), P Doug Jones (#383), OF Gary Sheffield (#384), P Jay Powell (#386), P Kevin Brown (#406), P Ramon Martinez (#443), INF Craig Counsell (#455) and P Brad Radke (#474). While not reaching the heights of the star rookies above, most true gem mint 10 graded examples still sell in the $300-$700 range today. Condition sensitive cards like Helton, Sheffield and Brown certainly have $1,000+ upside if higher grades were attained.

The sustained success and popularity of superstar players like Griffey, Jeter and Chip Jones along with solid careers compiled by pitchers like Glavine, Halladay and Bichette have made their 1995 Fleer Ultra rookie cards some the most valuable and sought after in the entire set today. For Griffey and Jeter especially, strong cases can be made that no other modern baseball card holds more monetary worth and collector desire than their 1995 Ultra refractors and base rookies in pristine condition. While rare parallels and gems of other top rookies also carry significant four and five-figure valuations. The 1995 Ultra set serves as a reminder of how rookie cards for truly great MLB careers will continue increase greatly in value with time.

Spread the love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *