The 2023 baseball season saw an incredible crop of talented rookies make their MLB debuts and immediately make an impact on the field. This new wave of stars is already creating a buzz and driving interest among collectors for their rookie cards. With another exciting season now in the books, here’s a look at some of the hottest rookie cards on the market as we head into the offseason from the group of players who made their big league debuts in 2023.
Spencer Strider, Atlanta Braves – The flamethrowing righty dazzled in his first full season, establishing himself as the Braves’ ace. His stellar 2.67 ERA and 202 strikeouts put him in the conversation for Rookie of the Year. Strider’s prized rookie card is his Topps Chrome Silver Pack Refractor RC, numbered to just 99 copies. Examples have already sold for over $1,000 on the secondary market. Look for his cards to gain even more value if he stays healthy and continues dominating next year.
Bobby Witt Jr., Kansas City Royals – After a strong rookie campaign where he showed five-tool potential and played Gold Glove-caliber defense at third base, Witt is considered the future face of the Royals franchise. The #2 pick in the 2019 draft also displayed plus speed and power. His Topps Chrome Blue Refractor RC holds immense appeal for collectors and has eclipsed $500 in recent sales. Witt could end up being one of the best all-around players of this rookie class.
Oneil Cruz, Pittsburgh Pirates – At 6-foot-7 with ridiculous raw power, Cruz was one of the sport’s most exciting prospects even before he reached the majors. He gave Pirates fans a glimpse of his true ability down the stretch in 2023 and looks poised for stardom. His Loulseville Slugger Authentic Stadium Club Chrome RC could become one of the pricier cards from this rookie crop if Cruz fulfills his superstar ceiling.
Ryan Pepiot, Los Angeles Dodgers – Not many rookies had the luxury of pitching for a perennial juggernaut like the Dodgers, but Pepiot took advantage with an impressive 3.18 ERA in 13 starts. His control and four above-average pitches give him mid-rotation potential. The Dodgers pitcher’s Topps Chrome Sapphire Refractor RC could be a blue chip card in the years to come if he continues developing in LA’s system.
Alek Manoah, Toronto Blue Jays – The hulking righty was already establishing himself as the ace of Toronto’s staff before a late-season elbow injury. When healthy, few pitchers are as dominating as the 6-foot-6 Manoah with his mid-90s fastball and veteran savvy. His 2021 Topps Chrome Sapphire Refractor RC, numbered to just 10 copies, is the crown jewel among Manoah RC cards.
Jarren Duran, Boston Red Sox – After a disappointing 2023 season where he battled injuries and inconsistency at the plate, Duran still has tantalizing five-tool upside that could make his cards valuable long-term prospects. He brings elite speed and defensive skills to the outfield and his raw power is starting to show more in games. Duran’s 2021 Bowman’s Best Chrome Autograph RC could be a sleeper if he puts it all together.
Steven Kwan, Cleveland Guardians – Already a fan favorite and budding star atop Cleveland’s order, Kwan finished third in ROY voting after hitting .298 in his first full season. At just 5-foot-9, the lefty hits for average and gets on base at an elite clip. Kwan’s 2022 Topps Opening Day Blue Refractor RC has impressed collectors and looks to gain more traction as he cements his role.
Adley Rutschman, Baltimore Orioles – After years of hype as the top prospect in baseball, Rutschman lived up to expectations by controlling the heart of Baltimore’s order as a rookie. The switch-hitting catcher showed why he’s considered the future face of the franchise. Rutschman’s prized 2021 Bowman Chrome Autograph Refractor RC is a true blue chip and will be a hot commodity for years.
Seph Straw, Houston Astros – A versatile defender capable of playing all over the diamond, Straw settled in as Houston’s starting centerfielder in 2023. He made highlight-reel catches, stole bases, and got on base at a high clip from the top of the order. Straw’s 2022 Topps Heritage Minors RC Autograph is one to watch long-term as he continues establishing himself in the Astros’ young core.
This class featured many more talented rookies who all have the potential to become future stars. From power hitters like Michael Harris and Luis Robert to flamethrowers like George Kirby and Braxton Garrett, there are endless options for collectors to pursue. With another exciting MLB season now in the books, the hottest rookie cards from 2023 set the stage for what’s sure to be an intriguing offseason in the collectibles market.
