Evan Carter had one of the most impressive minor league debuts in recent memory in 2022, hitting .277 with 24 home runs and 88 RBI between High-A and Double-A as a 19-year old. After being selected fifth overall by the Texas Rangers in the 2021 MLB Draft, Carter immediately became one of the top prospects in all of baseball and a player collectors were eager to add to their collections.
Carter’s prospect status and breakout 2022 season have made his rookie cards some of the most sought after on the baseball card market. While he has only a single season under his belt so far in pro ball, Carter’s cards hold significant long-term value potential if he continues developing into the impact bat many scouts forecast. Here’s a closer look at some of the key Evan Carter baseball cards collectors should know:
2021 Bowman Draft Evan Carter Auto RC (BDA-EC): As Carter’s true rookie card from his draft year, the 2021 Bowman Draft Auto RC is the crown jewel of any Carter PC at the moment. Featuring Carter’s autograph on-card, these can be difficult to find in high grades like PSA 10. Ungraded examples still command over $100 due to Carter’s hype, with PSA 10s selling for upwards of $400-500 based on recent eBay sales. These are sure to increase in value if Carter lives up to expectations at the MLB level.
2022 Topps Evan Carter Chrome RC (TTC-EC): As his flagship rookie card from Topps’ standard baseball release, the 2022 Topps Chrome Evan Carter RC in either paper or refractors is extremely popular. Ungraded copies typically sell in the $15-30 range on eBay. Graded PSA 10 examples have sold for $75-100, showing there is strong collector demand for high-end Carter rookies from his first Topps issue. These will remain a staple in any Carter collection for years to come.
2022 Bowman Evan Carter Chrome RC (BCP-EC): Released shortly after his impressive 2022 minor league campaign, Carter’s 2022 Bowman Chrome rookie card saw a huge spike in popularity and value. Ungraded copies routinely sell for $40-60 due to the shiny Chrome design and Carter’s breakout season creating more buzz. PSA 10 examples have reached as high as $200-300 in recent sales, a true testament to how hot the Carter market became after his breakout. These remain some of his most coveted modern rookies.
2022 Bowman’s Best Evan Carter Autographed RC (BBA-EC): For collectors seeking an on-card autograph of Carter post-2022, the Bowman’s Best release delivered with an autographed version of his standard rookie card. These signings were relatively limited compared to other Carter releases, making the autograph that much more desirable. Ungraded autos sell for $150-250 depending on card quality and market conditions. A PSA 10 could realistically reach the $500-1000 range if Carter’s star continues rising in the majors.
2022 Topps Chrome Evan Carter Refractor RC (#TTC-EC): Within the 2022 Topps Chrome set, the coveted refractors that feature a colorful stripe across Carter’s front-facing image have drawn heavy collector demand. Ungraded copies typically sell in the $75-150 range, with higher end sales approaching $300 for true gem copies. PSA 10 examples have reached as high as $500-700 already based on the limited population, showing the premium placed on these popular refractors by Carter collectors.
While still very early in his career, Evan Carter has already proven to be one of the most in-demand prospects when it comes to the baseball card hobby. As long as he continues developing, his rookie cards stand to gain even more value long-term. The above cards represent some of the core Carter rookies for any collector to consider building around in their collection as one of the game’s brightest young stars. As Carter’s career progresses, these cards are poised to become classics within the modern baseball landscape.
