When it comes to investing in baseball cards, it’s important to focus on cards from players that are likely to increase in value over time. While it can be tempting to purchase cards of current superstars, cards from players still active in the league have uncertainty regarding their future performance and health. On the other hand, cards from legendary players of the past tend to hold their value well and sometimes increase substantially as the player’s legacy grows after their retirement.
Some of the best baseball cards to purchase now to consider holding long-term include cards from the following all-time greats:
Mickey Mantle (1951-68) – Widely considered the best switch hitter of all time, Mantle dominated during the 1950s for the New York Yankees alongside teammates Yogi Berra and Whitey Ford. His rookie card from 1952 is one of the most coveted in the hobby and has sold for over $2 million. Even high-grade versions of his later cards from the 1950s can be worthwhile investments.
Babe Ruth (1914-35) – As arguably the greatest player in baseball history, Ruth revolutionized the game in the 1920s by hitting home runs at a record pace. His iconic 1914 Baltimore News batting card is extremely rare and high-priced today. More affordable options include his well-known 1933 Goudey card.
Ty Cobb (1905-28) – As arguably the greatest hitter and baserunner of all time, Cobb dominated the American League for over 20 years primarily with the Detroit Tigers. His rare 1909-11 T206 cards can sell for hundreds of thousands, but his common 1911 and 1912 cards are still solid long-term holds.
Nolan Ryan (1966-93) – Known as “The Ryan Express” for his 100+ mph fastball, Ryan dominated as a pitcher across 27 seasons with a record 7 no-hitters. His 1968 Topps rookie card is a smart buy, as is his 1973 Topps card showing his single season strikeout record.
Stan Musial (1941-63) – Nicknamed “Stan the Man,” Musial won 3 MVP awards while playing his entire career with the St. Louis Cardinals. He is one of only 4 players in MLB history with 3,000 hits. His 1952 Topps card remains one of the most iconic in the hobby.
Hank Aaron (1954-76) – “Hammerin’ Hank” is one of baseball’s true home run kings, holding the all-time record of 755 home runs for over 30 years until it was broken by Barry Bonds. High-grade versions of his Topps rookie cards from 1954 are always in demand.
Willie Mays (1951-73) – Regarded as one of the most exciting and talented players ever, “The Say Hey Kid” starred for the New York and San Francisco Giants. His classic 1952 Bowman and 1954 Topps rookie cards are blue-chip investments.
Ken Griffey Jr (1989-2010) – One of the most talented outfielders with a beautiful left-handed swing, Griffey was a fan favorite throughout his career primarily with the Seattle Mariners and Cincinnati Reds. High-grade versions of his Upper Deck rookie card from 1989 are increasing in value.
Mariano Rivera (1995-2013) – The greatest closer in MLB history with a record 652 saves primarily for the New York Yankees. As a surefire first-ballot Hall of Famer, his Topps rookie card from 1993 has plenty of upside.
Derek Jeter (1995-2014) – The longtime captain and shortstop of the Yankees dynasty teams in the late 1990s-2000s. His Topps rookie card from 1996 remains one of the most iconic cards in the hobby.
When purchasing these star cards, it’s important to buy high-quality graded versions through reputable auction houses or card shops to ensure authenticity and condition. Lower grade copies of even the most desirable stars can have limited future potential. It’s also worth considering Hall of Fame eligible players like Albert Pujols, Ichiro Suzuki, and Adrian Beltre that are likely headed to Cooperstown but not yet inducted. As future Hall of Famers, their best rookie and star cards from the 1990s-2000s could appreciate substantially after their inductions.
While current players like Mike Trout, Ronald Acuña Jr, Juan Soto and others may become future superstars, there is no guarantee of sustained success or health. Their cards carry more risk versus cards from established legends. For safety in a long-term investment strategy, proven stars from baseball’s golden eras between the 1950s-1990s provide the best opportunities. With patience and some luck, a collection focused on the icons above has strong chances to outperform most other investments over decades.
