Baseball cards have been around since the late 1800s, with the earliest known baseball cards dating back to the late 1880s. It was not until the early 1900s that baseball cards really started to take off in popularity. The 1920s was a pivotal decade that helped establish baseball cards as a mainstream collectible. By 1925, baseball cards were being inserted into tobacco products on a large scale by companies like American Tobacco, making them widely available and affordable for young collectors.
Understanding the values of vintage 1925 baseball cards can be challenging due to many factors. Condition is extremely important when determining the price of any collectible over 90 years old. Other considerations include player performance, rarity of the specific card issue, and general collector demand. This price guide aims to provide a starting point for understanding the potential values of various 1925 baseball cards in different grades. There will always be exceptions depending on the exact card and market conditions.
1925 Cracker Jack Baseball Cards
One of the most iconic and sought-after vintage issues is the 1925 Cracker Jack set. These cards were inserted in Cracker Jack popcorn boxes and featured 12 players from the American and National Leagues. In gem mint condition, the following 1925 Cracker Jack cards could command the listed prices:
Babe Ruth – $15,000+
Ty Cobb – $10,000+
Rogers Hornsby – $5,000+
Grover Cleveland Alexander – $2,000+
Eddie Collins – $1,500+
Walter Johnson – $1,000+
Tris Speaker – $800+
Nap Lajoie – $600+
Eddie Plank – $500+
Ray Schalk – $300+
George Sisler – $200+
Rabbit Maranville – $150+
In lower grades of very fine or excellent condition, values would decrease significantly, possibly to only 10-20% of the gem mint prices. The rarity of finding these nearly 100-year-old cards in top condition makes gem examples extremely valuable to dedicated collectors.
1925 Baseball Gum Company Sets
The American Caramel Company and Goudey Gum Company also produced popular baseball card sets in 1925 that included both team sets and individual player issues. In mint condition, some key cards from these sets could command the following prices:
Honus Wagner (Goudey) – $50,000+
Ty Cobb (Goudey) – $15,000+
Babe Ruth (Goudey) – $10,000+
Walter Johnson (Goudey) – $5,000+
Tris Speaker (Goudey) – $3,000+
Eddie Collins (Goudey) – $2,000+
Nap Lajoie (Goudey) – $1,500+
Home Run Baker (Goudey) – $1,000+
Zack Wheat (Goudey) – $800+
Eddie Plank (Goudey) – $500+
George Sisler (Goudey) – $300+
Ray Schalk (Goudey) – $200+
Compared to the Cracker Jack issues, the gum company cards generally have higher values due to smaller print runs. Again, condition is paramount, with prices decreasing significantly in lower grades of very fine or excellent. Finding these vintage cards in true mint condition is extremely rare.
Rookie Cards from 1925
While most players featured in 1925 sets were established veterans, there are a few notable rookie cards that can demand large premiums due to the players’ later accomplishments:
Jimmie Foxx (Goudey) – $25,000+ (HOF, Triple Crown winner)
Mel Ott (Goudey) – $15,000+ (HOF, 500 home runs)
Lefty Gomez (Goudey) – $10,000+ (HOF, 6-time All-Star)
Bill Dickey (Goudey) – $5,000+ (HOF, Yankee catcher)
Joe Cronin (Goudey) – $3,000+ (HOF, AL MVP)
Lefty Grove (Goudey) – $2,000+ (HOF, 3-time AL MVP)
Finding the rookie cards of all-time greats like Foxx, Ott, and Gomez in high grade is an incredible discovery for any collector. Their values reflect the significance of capturing a player at the very beginning of their career before stardom.
Key Factors in Determining Value
The most important factors when evaluating the potential value of a vintage 1925 baseball card are:
Condition – Mint or gem grades are extremely rare and valuable after nearly 100 years
Player Prominence – Hall of Famers and superstars have the highest values
Rarity of Issue – Smaller print runs are scarcer and more desirable
Rookie or Early Career Cards – Can be exceptionally valuable finds
Market Demand – Popular collections see rising values over time
While no guide can predict exact prices, these benchmarks provide a starting point for understanding relative values between different 1925 baseball cards. With care and preservation, these fragile pieces of sports history from the early 20th century can retain their collectibility and significance for generations of fans to enjoy.
