The 1986 Topps baseball card set is considered one of the most valuable vintage sets from the 1980s. While it does not contain any cards that rival the sky-high prices of iconic rookie cards from the 1950s and 1960s, there are several standout cards from the ’86 Topps set that can be quite valuable, especially in top graded condition.
One of the headlining rookies from the ’86 set is Toronto Blue Jays outfielder George Bell. As the 1985 American League MVP, Bell’s rookie card is one of the most sought after cards from the year. High-grade versions of the Bell rookie have sold for thousands in recent years. Another key rookie is New York Mets pitcher Dwight Gooden. As one of the biggest pitching prospects ever, Gooden’s rookie exploded in value in the late 80s and early 90s during his dominance on the mound. Pristine copies have reached over $10,000.
Beyond the rookie cards, standout stars from the 1980s also have cards in the ’86 set that hold value. One of the most iconic is Chicago Cubs ace Rick Sutcliffe, pictured pitching on the front of the base card. Highly sought after by Cubs fans, mint Sutcliffe cards can fetch a few hundred dollars. Kansas City Royals star George Brett also has a card from his playing days that is popular with collectors from that organization. Graded mint copies of Brett’s ’86 card sell for $100-200.
Two other superstar cards that command big prices are New York Yankees pitcher Dave Righetti and Oakland A’s slugger Jose Canseco. Righetti’s card shows him windmilling during one of his dominant relief appearances. Canseco’s breakout 1985 season made him one of the first true “five-tool” players of the modern steroid era. Their cards consistently sell in the $75-150 range when in near perfect condition.
Another area that can yield valuable returns is finding star players’ cards from their breakout rookie or early career seasons captured in the ’86 set before they became household names. San Diego Padres third baseman Gary Sheffield had his career year in 1986 and his card reflects his promise before future All-Star seasons. Cincinnati Reds pitcher Tom Browning won 20 games in 1986 as well. Finding high-grade versions of these before they broke out can net $50-100+.
While not all 1986 Topps cards will make you rich, there is clearly growth potential contained within the set when it comes to keys like the Bell and Gooden rookies as well as stars like Brett, Righetti, and Canseco. With over 600 players featured across the 792 total cards, savvy collectors can still find relative bargains by targeting emerging young talent or franchise favorites poised to increase over the long run. When combined with the 1980s nostalgia factor, choice ’86 Topps pieces certified in pristine condition means this set remains an intriguing investment option for vintage baseball card collectors.
While the 1986 Topps set may not contain modern-era record prices seen for iconic 1950s rookie cards, there are still several valuable gems to be found within the set. Rookies like George Bell and Dwight Gooden along with star players like George Brett, Dave Righetti, and Jose Canseco make up the headlining expensive cards. But savvy collectors can also find diamonds in the rough by targeting players on the verge of stardom whose values increase as their careers progressed. The ’86 Topps set remains a foundational part of the vintage collecting scene worth exploring for valuable pieces.
