Adley Rutschman had one of the most anticipated debuts in recent memory when he made his MLB debut with the Baltimore Orioles in 2022. As the top overall pick in the 2019 MLB Draft and considered the top prospect in all of baseball for several years, interest in Rutschman cards on the secondary market has been immense. Let’s take an in-depth look at the Rutschman rookie card landscape on eBay and what collectors can expect to find.
2019 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects Autograph (#BDPP-AR): As Rutschman’s first signed baseball card released after being drafted, this served as the true rookie autograph card. Only inserted at a rate of 1:300 packs or less, PSA 10 gems of this card have sold for over $2,000. Even raw copies in good condition have sold for $500+. With its ultra-low print run and status as the true rookie autograph, this card remains extremely scarce and valuable.
2019 Bowman Chrome Draft Picks & Prospects Autograph (#BCDPP-AR): The chrome parallel of the above card, it carries a similar rarity level but with a bit lower population of high-grade PSA/BGS slabs. Prices tend to be a couple hundred dollars less than the base autograph. Still an exceedingly rare pull and one of the key early Rutschman cards.
2019 Bowman Draft Chrome Green Refractor Autograph (#BDPP-AR-GR): The prized parallel of Rutschman’s debut, this features his auto on a refractory green background. Populations of high-grade slabs are minuscule, with a PSA 10 recently selling for over $4,000. Even raw copies in good condition can fetch $1,000+. An iconic rookie card parallel due to its rarity and aesthetics.
2019 Bowman Chrome Draft Green Refractor (#BDPP-AR-GR): The non-auto parallel to the above, it still holds tremendous value due to being one of the rarest Rutschman parallels from his rookie set. PSA 10s have sold for $1,000+, with most raw copies in good condition going for $200-400. Still quite scarce and an important piece for Orioles/Bowman collectors.
2020 Topps Chrome Update Blue Refractor (#US400): Rutschman’s true MLB rookie card debut, though he did not play in 2020. The blue parallel carries a rarity similar to the green refractors above and is highly sought after. PSA 10s have crested $1,000, with most raw copies selling for $200-500 depending on condition. A true “flagship” rookie parallel.
2020 Topps Chrome Update Rainbow Foil (#US400): The prized parallel of Rutschman’s Topps rookie set, these feature an iridescent rainbow foil pattern on the front. Populations are minute, with a single PSA 10 recently selling for over $2,000 on eBay. Even well-centered raw copies can fetch $800+. A true high-end modern rookie parallel.
2021 Topps Chrome Update Gold Refractor (#US400): Rutschman’s update issue rookie card from his first full season in the minors. The gold parallel is quite scarce, with PSA 10s selling in the $500-700 range and raw copies in the $150-300 range depending on centering quality. High demand due to rarity and prospect status at the time of issue.
2022 Topps Series 1 Base (#331): As Rutschman’s true MLB debut rookie card released during his actual rookie season, demand has been through the roof for this flagship issue. Even PSA 10s have sold for over $150 due to a perfect storm of prospect hype meeting on-field production. Raw copies in good condition easily fetch $20-40. A true modern rookie card blockbuster.
In summary, Adley Rutschman cards have proven to be an incredible investment area for collectors over the past few years. With his top prospect status and now budding MLB career, interest and prices are likely to remain very strong across all of his notable rookie issues – especially the ultra-rare autograph and parallel cards from 2019 Bowman. For collectors looking to invest in a young star on the rise, Rutschman’s rookie cards present an excellent opportunity – both to enjoy owning cards of a future star, and to benefit from the rising prices his career success is sure to bring. eBay remains the top marketplace to find virtually any Rutschman card in a variety of grades and prices.
