Aaron Judge has become one of the biggest stars in Major League Baseball in recent years due to his towering home runs and MVP-caliber play for the New York Yankees. As a result, Judge’s rookie cards and other baseball cards from his early career with the Yankees have skyrocketed in value since his debut in 2016. Many collectors now view Judge’s rookie cards as a key piece of any baseball card collection.

On the online auction site eBay, Aaron Judge cards regularly fetch high prices from avid collectors looking to add a prized Judge rookie or star card to their collections. Some of Judge’s most coveted and expensive cards that can be found for sale on eBay include:

2017 Topps Series 1 #168 Aaron Judge Rookie Card – Considered Judge’s true rookie card as it was from his first season in the majors, these cards in near-mint to mint condition can sell for $500 or more on eBay. Graded gems in Mint 9 or Mint 10 condition have even sold for over $1,000.

2017 Bowman Chrome Aaron Judge Autograph Rookie Card #BCP99 – As one of Judge’s scarcest autograph rookie cards, these autographed beauties are extremely difficult to find on eBay. When they do pop up, expect to pay $2,000 minimum for a PSA-graded 10 version. Ungraded copies still go for $1,000+.

2017 Topps Opening Day Aaron Judge Red Foil Parallel #OD-AJ – With its red foil treatment, this parallel version of Judge’s base rookie card stands out in collectors’ eyes. Near-mint copies sell in the $150-250 range, while a PSA 10 can reach $500.

2017 Topps Five Star Aaron Judge Autograph #5 – Judge’s autograph is one of the most coveted in the hobby, and the Five Star parallel offers multiple autographs per card. Even well-worn, unsigned versions sell for $100-200, with autographed copies commanding $500-1,000.

2017 Topps Archives Refractor Aaron Judge #97 – As a retro-styled card with a modern refractor treatment, Archives cards are always popular. Judge’s refractor rookie in this set typically sells for $75-150 based on condition.

2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge Refractor Rookie #158 – The flagship Topps Chrome set is a must-have for any player, and Judge’s refractor rookie regularly sells for $50-100 on eBay. Higher grades can double that price.

2017 Topps Series 2 Aaron Judge #166 – The base rookie card from Judge’s second Topps series of his rookie year is still plentiful on eBay. Near-mint copies usually sell between $15-30.

2022 Topps Aaron Judge #87 – Judge’s 2022 Topps base card is one of the most common modern Judge cards available. Near-mint copies typically sell for $3-5.

2017 Topps Opening Day Aaron Judge Blue Parallel #OD-AJ – Similar to the red parallel but much rarer, the blue foil version commands $250-400 on eBay depending on condition. A PSA 10 could surpass $1,000.

2017 Topps Chrome Update Aaron Judge Refractor #US266 – As Judge’s second Topps Chrome refractor from his rookie season, these are still very popular. Near-mint copies sell around $50-75. Higher grades push $100+.

2017 Topps Allen & Ginter Aaron Judge #121 – The prestigious Allen & Ginter set features unique designs, and Judge’s rookie in this set has sold for $40-75.

Of course, the true crown jewels of any Aaron Judge card collection are the ultra-rare 1-of-1 parallels and autograph cards that occasionally surface on eBay. These include printing plate autographs, autograph patch cards, and serial-numbered parallels /1. Given Judge’s superstar status, any true 1-of-1 card would likely sell for $5,000 or more depending on the exact insert, autograph or relic involved.

Overall, Aaron Judge’s popularity and dominance on the baseball field have made many of his early cards from 2016-2017 highly sought after collectibles on eBay. With Judge still in his prime at age 30, and with the possibility of chasing the all-time single season home run record in 2022, interest and prices for his rookie cards are unlikely to decline any time soon. Savvy collectors will want to snap up desirable Judge cards now before prices continue their seemingly inevitable rise in the years ahead. Whether spending $5 or $5,000, owning a piece of Aaron Judge’s early career in cardboard form is a sound investment for any baseball card enthusiast.