Aaron Judge has quickly become one of the biggest stars in Major League Baseball since debuting with the New York Yankees in 2016. The 6-foot-7 outfielder has smashed MLB single-season rookie home run records and been named an All-Star in three of his first five seasons. With his towering home runs and dominant play in the Bronx, Judge has also become one of the most sought-after modern players in the baseball card collecting hobby.
Judge’s rookie cards from 2017 Topps Series 1 and 2017 Topps Series 2 are among the hottest modern rookie cards on the secondary market. In pristine gem mint condition, these flagship Aaron Judge rookie cards routinely sell for thousands of dollars online. For example, a 2017 Topps Series 1 Aaron Judge rookie card graded mint 9 by Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) recently sold on eBay for over $6,000. In the same PSA 9 grade, 2017 Topps Series 2 Aaron Judge rookies have also crossed the $6,000 mark. Even in lower near-mint to mint condition grades from PSA or Beckett Grading Services, these prized rookie cards still demand prices well over $1,000.
For collectors seeking truly investment-grade specimens of Judge’s rookie cards, pristine PSA 10 or BGS Black Label 10 examples can sell for mind-boggling sums. In January 2022, a PSA 10 graded 2017 Topps Series 1 Aaron Judge rookie shattered records when it sold for an astounding $2.1 million through an online auction. Just a few months later, another PSA 10 example from the same base card design brought in $1.13 million at auction. BGS Black Label 10 versions, the pinnacle authenticating grade, have also crossed the $100,000 price point before. It’s clear these impeccably preserved flagship Judge rookie cards have reached true modern icon status in the collecting world.
Beyond the standard Topps rookie cards, several other key Aaron Judge rookie variants hold significant value as well. His 2017 Bowman Chrome Prospects autograph rookie card remains one of the most iconic and valuable modern autographed cards. PSA 10 examples have sold for over $30,000, with PSA 9 copies still commanding $10,000+. Judge’s rare autographed Bowman’s Best Chrome Prospects rookie parallel in a PSA/DNA 10 recently sold for an astounding $138,000.
Other notable high-value Judge rookies include his 2017 Topps Heritage Minors rookie debuting his pro uniform ($3,000+ PSA 9), 2017 Topps Opening Day base rookie ($1,000+ PSA 9), and 2017 Topps Update base rookie ($800+ PSA 9). Even insert cards like his 2017 Topps Holiday Snowflake parallel rookie can reach $500 raw in top-graded condition. For collectors seeking autographs, signed versions of Judge’s 2017 Topps Series 1 and Series 2 rookie cards have sold for $1,000+ in PSA/DNA authenticated slabs as well.
Aaron Judge’s performance and star power have only increased since those early rookie years, leading to strong sustained demand for his cards across all levels of the hobby. His 2018 Topps base and insert cards remain hot commodities as well, with PSA 9 copies of flagship parallels like the Chrome, Heritage, and Update issues selling for $300-$500 each online. Autographed versions command $500+ raw.
Judge’s most recent flagship cards from 2019-2021 Topps series also hold significant collector value already. His prized 2019 Topps Update Silver Pack parallel #/70 has sold for over $1,000 PSA 9. Even base rookies from later years like 2020 Topps sell for $100+ in top grades. As Judge continues smashing home runs and milestones for the Yankees, the prices for all his modern cards are likely to keep appreciating over the long run for dedicated collectors and investors.
For the ultimate Aaron Judge cards, collectors will need to explore rarer parallels and serial numbered inserts. His ultra-short printed 2017 Topps Archives Diamond Anniversary parallel #/25 recently sold for over $6,000 raw. Serial numbered versions of cards like 2017 Topps Holiday Snowflake #/10 and 2018 Topps Opening Day #/99 have brought $1,000+ as well. Autographed memorabilia cards capturing iconic moments from Judge’s career also hold tremendous collector value.
Whether you’re a die-hard Yankees fan, modern card investor, or just appreciate one of the game’s true superstars, Aaron Judge’s impressive baseball cards will remain a must-have for any collection. As the slugger continues smashing home runs and rewriting record books, prices for even his earliest cards will likely remain sky high. With Hall of Fame caliber talent, Judge is poised to become one of the most iconic players of his generation – meaning his collectibles may be wise longterm holdings for any hobbyist portfolio.
