Sportslots Baseball Card & Collectibles – This shop has been located in Tampa for over 25 years and is one of the most well-established and reliable places to sell baseball cards in the area. They have a huge inventory of cards available to purchase and also actively buy collections from sellers on a daily basis. The experts there can evaluate your cards and offer you a fair price based on the current market values. They pay cash on the spot for qualifying collections. They are located at 3616 W Gandy Blvd, Tampa, FL 33611. Their phone number is 813-839-7900.
Old Time Sports Cards & Collectibles – This shop has a strong reputation among Tampa area collectors. They have three full-time staff that are passionate about the hobby and very knowledgeable to properly assess the value of any cards brought in for sale. They buy entire collections or single rare/valuable cards. Their payment is also usually in cash on the spot. They work with collectors to get them the best possible price for their cards. The shop is located at 8013 N Dale Mabry Hwy Suite A, Tampa, FL 33614. Their contact number is 813-960-5866.
Next Level Exchange – While not strictly a card shop, this retailer actively buys and sells sports cards and is a great option for selling collections in Tampa. They have numerous locations across the Tampa Bay area including in Westshore, Brandon, South Tampa and Downtown. Their expert team knows the current values on thousands of players and can make you a competitive offer on everything you bring in. Payment is also usually cash but they may offer credit if you’re selling high value items. Next Level Exchange 120 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Tampa, FL 33609. Their phone is 813-258-6977.
DA Card World – Located in iconic Ybor City, this vintage trading card and collectible shop is a fun destination with vintage vibes. While smaller than some other options, they still move good volumes of cards weekly through their buying and selling. Bring in your cards and within a few days they can make you a written offer after doing research on current values. Their payment comes in the form of store credit which can then be used towards other cards or collectibles in their inventory. Location: 1911 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605. Phone: 813-248-2273.
TampaCardHunter.com – While not a true brick and mortar location, this is an online seller and buyer of sports collectibles based in Tampa run by an experienced collector. They will meet you locally to evaluate your cards in person or you can ship them cards. Photographs are then posted online showcasing your collection with their verified buy offers. Payment is usually via PayPal, Venmo or cash if meeting locally. They are very responsive and transparent throughout the buying process. No physical address but email TampaCardHunter@gmail.com or visit their website.
As you can see, Tampa has many excellent options for appraising, verifying values and selling your baseball card collection for the best possible price. Going to reputable card shops or experienced online buyers is the way to ensure a smooth transaction locally. Proper research of past transactions and online reviews can also confirm the legitimacy of wherever you ultimately decide to sell. With some cards potentially worth thousands, it pays to take your time and go through a trusted source.
