The 1990 Score baseball card set featured the Score brand’s “Rising Star” subset focusing on promising young players who were beginning to make a name for themselves in Major League Baseball. With the proliferation of baseball cards in the late 1980s and early 1990s, Score and other card companies sought out unique ways to highlight rookie and prospect cards that could become valuable if those players panned out. The 1990 Score Rising Star subset ended up identifying several future stars who lived up to their potential.
Among the featured Rising Star cards from the 1990 Score set were pitcher Greg Maddux of the Chicago Cubs, pitcher Dwight Gooden of the New York Mets, pitcher Jimmy Key of the Toronto Blue Jays, third baseman Gary Sheffield of the Milwaukee Brewers, and outfielder Kevin Mitchell of the San Francisco Giants. All five of these players became All-Stars and contributors to World Series championship teams over their careers. In particular, Maddux emerged as one of the greatest pitchers in baseball history, winning 4 Cy Young Awards and becoming a first-ballot Hall of Famer. His 1990 Score Rising Star card, which featured him in a Cubs uniform, now routinely sells for well over $100 in top-graded condition given his legendary career.
Beyond those five established stars featured, the 1990 Score Rising Star subset also identified several other talented young players who had breakout potential but careers that didn’t fully materialize. Catcher Sandy Alomar, Jr. of the San Diego Padres and shortstop Mike Bordick of the Baltimore Orioles both enjoyed solid big league careers as role players and starters for over a decade but fell short of true stardom. Pitcher Ken Hill of the Texas Rangers flashed excellent stuff early in his career but was derailed by injuries. Outfielder John Olerud of the New York Mets developed into a premier hitting first baseman but never eclipsed the superstar hype that surrounded his prospect card.
Several other Rising Star cards from the 1990 Score set profiled players who never panned out in MLB for various reasons. Pitchers Trevor Hoffman of the Cincinnati Reds and Jimmy Key of the Toronto Blue Jays did have some initial success but serious arm injuries cut their careers short. Outfielders Brian L. Hunter of the New York Mets and Darren Daulton of the Philadelphia Phillies showed promise as rookies but hit roadblocks that ultimately relegated them to part-time duty. Pitchers Jack Armstrong of the Chicago White Sox and Darrin Jackson of the Chicago Cubs flashed ability on the mound but control issues sent them to bullpen roles before premature retirements.
Despite featuring a few busts, the 1990 Score Rising Star subset as a whole did a commendable job of identifying talent on the cusp of stardom across baseball. Maddux, Gooden, Sheffield, and Mitchell in particular became perennial All-Stars who all cashed in on huge free agent contracts later in their careers. While the excitement of prospect hype often precedes true greatness, Score took an early chance on showing the promise of these young guns with photographic cards emphasizing their beginnings. For investors and collectors, picking a star performer or two from prospect sets can yield historic returns if that talent develops as forecast. The 1990 Score Rising Stars cards offer a unique time capsule into the early careers of players who made substantial impacts throughout the 1990s.
In the trading card market today, complete Topps and Upper Deck rookie card sets often get the most attention from collectors. Prospect subsets like Score’s Rising Stars from past decades have quietly gained admiration for identifying future Hall of Famers still in the early stages. The allure of finding “the next big thing” before their stardom takes root remains exciting for any collector or investor. When it comes to the 1990 Score Rising Stars, admirers can look back with the benefit of hindsight and appreciate how prescient some of those selections ended up being. For better or worse, the cards epitomize the excitement and uncertainty surrounding baseball’s emerging talent 30 years ago.
