The 1989 Leaf baseball card set is one of the most iconic and valuable sets from the junk wax era of the late 1980s and early 1990s. While many consider sets from this period to be worthless due to immense printing numbers that led to a market saturated with common cards, there are some rare and valuable gems to be found in the ’89 Leaf issue. Let’s take an in-depth look at some of the most valuable rookie and serially numbered cards collectors search for from this 35-year old set.
Perhaps the most iconic and valuable card from the 1989 Leaf set is the Frank Thomas rookie card. Widely considered one of the best rookie cards from the junk wax era, the Frank Thomas rookie has maintained strong collector demand and value over the decades. Part of what makes this card so desirable is that Thomas went on to have a Hall of Fame career and is considered one of the greatest hitters of his generation. In high grade, mint condition copies of the Frank Thomas rookie regularly sell for thousands of dollars. A PSA 10 Gem Mint example recently sold for over $27,000, showing the card retains significant collector interest. While most common copies in played condition are only worth $10-20, graded gems of this premier rookie continue to increase in secondary market price.
Another hugely valuable card from the ’89 Leaf set is the serially numbered Ken Griffey Jr. insert. Labeled “Griffey Jr. Prospect Card” and bearing the serial number on the front of the card, only 1000 of these rare Griffey inserts were printed. High grade copies in the single digits routinely sell for five figures or more when they surface on the market. In 2015, the #1 Griffey Jr. Prospect Card achieved the highest price ever paid for a 1989 Leaf card, selling for an astounding $75,600 at auction. What makes this preciously rare is that it features one of the game’s most beloved players and is exponentially lower in print run compared to the base cards. For Griffey super collectors, acquiring one of these 1/1000th serial numbered inserts is the holy grail from the set.
ADVERTISEMENT
Beyond the absolutely highest-end key cards in the set like the Thomas rookie and Griffey insert, there are other notable singles that can reach four figures or more in top condition. The Starlin Castro rookie card jumped in value in recent years as the former Cubs star re-emerged as an offensive force. A PSA 10 Castro now sells in the $1500-3000 range. Likewise, the Mark McGwire rookie has trended up thanks to sentimental nostalgia for his home run chasing feats with Sosa in the late 90s. High grade McGwire rookies can now break $1000. Rookies of Chipper Jones, Gary Sheffield, and Randy Johnson also maintain strong collector following and values well into the mid-triple digits in top shape.
Some other valuable 1989 Leaf cards that catch premium prices include serially numbered parallel issues of star players. For example, the ‘Leader’ parallel cards featuring Griffey, Thomas, and McGwire printed to 1000 copies or less are exponentially rarer than the standard base issue. Coins of these stars numbered to 100 copies or less, referred to as ‘Limited Edition’ parallels, have sold for $3000+, given their super low population. Error cards with missing statistics, team logos, or variations in player pose from the base issue create niche value. In 2012, a one-of-one printing plate proof of the Frank Thomas rookie realized a $16,000 final bid.
For investors and collectors who don’t mind taking on more risk, there is upside potential in acquiring ungraded high-value cards from the 1989 Leaf set. Because so many were produced and carelessly handled in the junk wax era, pristine copies worthy of the highest grades are incredibly elusive. There remains the opportunity to discover a true gem-mint candidate that could yield a substantial return getting slabbed by a reputable third-party grading service like PSA or BGS. For example, spending a few hundred on an raw Thomas rookie with strong centering and no flaws could potentially net thousands more if it grades as the sole PSA 10 on the population report. Of course, there is no guarantee of a perfect grade – but the upside is there for patient collectors willing to do the research.
While the 1989 Leaf baseball card set was among the most overproduced of the junk wax era, it does contain some true gems that maintain strong collector demand decades later. Keys like the Frank Thomas and Ken Griffey Jr. rookie cards continue increasing in value as the players’ careers are fondly remembered. Additional valuable finds include serially numbered parallels, error variations, and top-graded rookie cards of other Hall of Fame stars. For investors or collectors building sets, it remains a fun set to collect at affordable levels. But discerning collectors are wise to focus on pristine graded examples of the true blue-chip cards that can deliver the biggest long term returns. With patience and market research, value can still be found amidst the sea of common copies in this storied but oft-maligned vintage issue from the late 80s and early 90s sports card boom years.
