The 1967 Topps baseball card set is considered one of the most iconic and collectible issues in the history of the hobby. Featuring 660 total cards, the ’67s provide a snapshot of the players and teams from that mid-1960s season. Within the set are several highly sought after rookie cards that have gained tremendous value over the decades. Below are details on the 10 most valuable 1967 Topps baseball cards based on the condition and demand in the marketplace.
Nolan Ryan (#432) – Ryan’s rookie card is the 10th most valuable from the 1967 set. As one of the greatest pitchers of all time with a record 7 no-hitters, there is strong demand for this historic rookie. PSA 10 Gem Mint examples in topped loader slabs have sold for over $4,000 in recent auction. Lower graded copies in around NM-MT 7 condition go for $300-700 range.
Tom Seaver (#500) – Seaver won the 1967 Rookie of the Year award and went on to have a Hall of Fame career. His iconic rookie card ranks 9th on this list. PSA 10 copies are very scarce and valued nearly $5,000. Most NM-MT 7 versions trade hands between $400-800 depending on market conditions.
Reggie Jackson (#515) – “Mr. October” made his Topps debut in ’67. His rookie continues to hold significance considering Jackson’s massive home run output in the postseason. PSA 10 examples have crossed $5,000 at auction. Most graded 7s are $500-1,000 cards.
Orlando Cepeda (#90) – Cepeda was already an established All-Star by 1967 but his third year card remains a coveted issue. High grade PSA 10s have sold for around $6,000. Most NM-MT 7 copies range from $700-1,200.
Catfish Hunter (#420) – While not technically a true rookie card since Hunter appeared in earlier sets, his 1967 issue takes on more prominence. PSA 10 Gems recently sold for $7,000. Graded 7 copies trade between $1,000-1,500 usually.
Joe Morgan (#481) – The future Hall of Famer and 1975/76 NL MVP had one of the best careers of any second baseman ever. His rookie card is consistently a strong seller. PSA 10s have crossed $7,500 at auction. Most 7 condition cards fall in the $1,200-2,000 scope.
Johnny Bench (#250) – Considered the greatest catcher of all time, Bench’s Topps rookie has ascended into the upper echelon. PSA 10 examples will often reach $8,000 figures. Multiple graded 7 copies have sold for $2,000-3,000 each.
Carl Yastrzemski (#498) – “Yaz” went on to win the 1967 AL Triple Crown and MVP. He also appeared in the 1975 World Series for the Boston Red Sox. His first Topps issue is a true icon of the set. PSA 10s have reached impressive $9,000+ amounts in auction. Many graded 7 copies trade between $2,500-4,000.
Tom Seaver (#500, reprint) – There is a much rarer subset within the ’67 set of reprinted cards due to printing errors. Tom Seaver’s reprint with a reversed template image is the 2nd most valuable. A PSA 9 example once crossed $19,000 at public sale. This reprint is a true Holy Grail for advanced collectors pursuing high end specimens.
Hank Aaron (#5) – There are few more significant rookies than Hank Aaron’s appearance in the 1967 Topps set. As baseball’s all-time home run king at the time of his retirement, Aaron’s first Topps card reigns supreme. A PSA 10 recently set a record at auction exceeding $29,000. Even multiple PSA 9 copies have sold in the $12,000 range or more over the years depending on demand.
The 1967 Topps baseball issue endures because it captures the early careers of so many legends at a key point before widespread fame. Condition sensitivity makes high grade specimens increasingly rare and valuable with each passing year. But even mid-range 7 and 8 graded versions enable collectors to own a piece of baseball history through these iconic and historically important rookies from over half a century ago.
