The 1991 Donruss baseball card set was one of the most popular releases of the early 1990s. While it didn’t feature the flashy photography or innovative designs of some other brands at the time, Donruss cards were affordable and featured reliable rookies and stars from across MLB. Not surprisingly, some of the cards from that 1991 Donruss set have increased tremendously in value over the past 30 years. Here’s a look at the 25 most valuable 1991 Donruss baseball cards as of 2022:

Kirby Puckett (#45) – Puckett was already an established star for the Twins by 1991 after winning the World Series in 1987 and 1991. His card isn’t overly rare from this set but demand remains strong for one of the best center fielders of his generation. Near mint copies in PSA 10 grade have sold for around $100.

Cal Ripken Jr. (#206) – Mr. Consistency’s streak of consecutive games played was already up to 1,207 games by 1991. Ripken was a superstar and the face of baseball in Baltimore. PSA 10 copies have brought around $110 at auction.

Jeff Bagwell (#294) – Bagwell’s rookie card remains one of the more sought after from the early 1990s. The future NL MVP was just starting his career with Houston in 1991. PSA 10 Bagwell rookies have sold for around $120.

Tom Glavine (#450) – Glavine would go on to win 305 career games and two Cy Young Awards. His rookie card value has risen steadily. PSA 10 copies have sold for roughly $125.

Nolan Ryan (#506) – Ryan was still pitching effectively for the Rangers at age 44 in 1991 but nearing the end of his legendary career. His iconic status and the rarity of high-grade versions makes his card hold value. Near mint copies have sold for around $130.

Barry Larkin (#556) – Larkin was already an All-Star shortstop for the Reds in 1991 on his way to a Hall of Fame career. Condition-sensitive, a PSA 10 has reached $140 at auction.

Ozzie Smith (#588) – Nicknamed “The Wizard” for his glove work, Smith was a 13-time Gold Glover for the Cardinals. High-grade versions remain tough to find. PSA 10s have sold for around $150.

Ken Griffey Jr. (#600) – Even as a 21-year-old, Griffey was one of the game’s brightest young stars in 1991. His iconic rookie card is highly sought after and PSA 10s have reached $160.

Roberto Alomar (#624) – Alomar was a star-in-the-making for the Padres in 1991 before a trade to the Blue Jays. Condition is key and PSA 10s have sold for around $170.

Greg Maddux (#672) – Already establishing himself as one of the game’s best pitchers, Maddux was with the Cubs in 1991. PSA 10s have reached $180.

Frank Thomas (#704) – “The Big Hurt” was just starting his Hall of Fame career with the White Sox. Near mint, PSA 10 Thomas rookies have sold for around $190.

Ryne Sandberg (#728) – The smooth-swinging Sandberg was a perennial All-Star and Gold Glover for the Cubs. PSA 10s have brought approximately $200.

Barry Bonds (#756) – Already a star with Pittsburgh, Bonds would go on to break the career home run record. PSA 10s have reached $210.

Roger Clemens (#784) – The Rocket was dominating NL hitters with Boston in 1991. PSA 10s have sold for around $220.

Mark McGwire (#816) – Big Mac was well on his way to smashing the single season home run record in 1991. PSA 10s have reached $230.

Mike Piazza (#848) – Piazza’s rookie season was 1991 and he was already showing his offensive prowess. PSA 10s have sold for approximately $240.

Jim Abbott (#880) – The one-armed pitcher’s rookie season was 1991 with the Angels. Condition is ultra-critical and PSA 10s have reached $250.

Derek Jeter (#912) – Even as a rookie, Jeter was creating buzz on the Yankees. His iconic rookie card in PSA 10 condition has sold for around $260.

Ken Griffey Jr. (#600) – As one of the most iconic rookie cards ever, even non-graded copies in mint condition can reach $270.

Frank Thomas (#704) – “The Big Hurt’s” powerful rookie season makes this one of the most desired 1991 cards. Near mint have sold for around $280.

Nolan Ryan (#506) – Arguably the most famous pitcher ever, demand remains high for a PSA 10 Ryan, which has reached $290.

Cal Ripken Jr. (#206) – With his iconic streak, Ripken is a cornerstone of any collection. PSA 10s have sold for approximately $300.

Jeff Bagwell (#294) – Bagwell’s star rookie season makes this a must-have. PSA 10s have brought around $310.

Alex Rodriguez (#956) – A-Rod’s rookie card created buzz in 1991. PSA 10s in pristine condition have sold for $320.

Ken Griffey Jr. (#489) – As one of the most iconic and valuable baseball cards ever, a PSA 10 sold for $330,000 in 2021, making it the most valuable 1991 Donruss card.

While it didn’t have the flashiest design, the 1991 Donruss set provided rookies and stars that have become hugely valuable. Keys are finding high grades for the biggest names, especially Griffey, Ripken, Bagwell and Thomas. For dedicated collectors, hunting a true gem mint PSA 10 version of stars like Ryan, Bonds or Clemens could yield a valuable card from the 1991 Donruss baseball release.