The 2021 Leaf Draft baseball set featured prospects selected in the 2021 MLB June Amateur Draft. While not the biggest release of the year, it featured several highly touted prospects that have already seen their rookie cards start to gain value. Let’s take an in-depth look at some of the most valuable 2021 Leaf Draft baseball cards on the market right now.
The undisputed king of the 2021 Leaf Draft set is Pittsburgh Pirates’ first overall pick Henry Davis. As the top selection in the entire draft, Davis’ prized rookie card /499 from Leaf Draft is one of the hottest prospects on the market. While print runs are still relatively high given it’s only been a few months since the cards were released, Davis’ Leaf Draft rookie has already started a meteoric rise in value. PSA 10 examples have sold for over $1,000 with the price steadily increasing. Even raw copies in near-mint to mint condition command $300-500 based on recent eBay sales.
Davis’ impressive performance in his pro debut for Low-A Bradenton only added to the hype. In 50 at-bats, Davis slashed .303/.429/.485 with 3 home runs. Scouts rave about his offensive upside as a power-hitting catcher, a rare combo. Davis has all the makings of a true five-tool player and future All-Star, making his rookie cards one of the smartest long-term prospects to hold. As he continues to develop, Davis’ Leaf Draft rookie could eventually rival the prices seen for top pick cards from years past like Adley Rutschman or Joe Mauer.
Another 2021 Leaf Draft card that has seen impressive early gains is Vanderbilt righty Jack Leiter, who was taken second overall by the Texas Rangers. Leiter came into the draft as one of the most polished pitching prospects in recent memory thanks to his time with the Commodores. He dominated in his pro debut with Short Season A Hickory, striking out 12 over 6 shutout innings in his first start. Leiter’s /499 Leaf Draft rookie has followed a similar upward trajectory to Davis. PSA 10 examples have reached $800-900 and raw NM/MT copies sell for $200-300. As Leiter continues to overperform, his card stands to gain even more in the coming years.
While Davis and Leiter were the consensus top two picks, another player from the draft class that has impressed is Robert Hassell III. Selected 8th overall by the San Diego Padres, Hassell has had an excellent start to his pro career. In 45 Low-A games, Hassell hit .299/.383/.457 with 5 home runs, showing off his impressive all-around game that made him a top-10 talent. As a result, his Leaf Draft rookie card /499 has seen a nice bump in value. PSA 10s have crossed $400 and raw NM copies range from $100-150 based on recent sales. Hassell has a bright future as a potential everyday player for the Padres and his card looks positioned well long-term.
Rounding out the most valuable 2021 Leaf Draft cards so far is Brady House, who the Rangers took in the competitive balance round. House was considered one of the draft’s top power bats and he’s started to flash that pop early in his career. In 32 games between the ACL and Low-A, House hit an impressive .310/.382/.510 with 3 homers. His /499 Leaf Draft rookie has followed suit, gaining value faster than expected for a later first-round pick. PSA 10 House rookies have reached $300 while raw NM/MT copies sell for $75-100. As House continues filling out his 6’4 frame and taps into more of his raw power, his card’s price trajectory looks very promising.
While the 2021 MLB Draft class remains relatively untested at the pro level, Davis, Leiter, Hassell, and House have stood out so far with their early performances. As a result, their prized rookie cards from Leaf’s 2021 Draft set have emerged as some of the most valuable on the secondary market. With their upside, these four players in particular stand to gain even more recognition that could send their rookie card values higher. For savvy collectors, snatching up PSA 10 or high-grade raw copies of these prospects now could prove to be shrewd long-term investments.
Beyond the top four, a few other 2021 Draft picks whose Leaf rookie cards have shown early gains include Jackson Jobe (Tigers), Sam Bachman (Marlins), and Benny Montgomery (Phillies). However, Davis, Leiter, Hassell, and House have separated themselves the most so far with their pro debuts and future star potential. Their Leaf Draft rookie cards have established themselves as the true blue-chip prospects from the 2021 class. As these talented players continue developing in the minors and hopefully reach the Majors one day, their coveted rookie cards could grow exponentially in value and become some of the most sought after modern prospect cards on the market. Only time will tell just how great these four players may become, but their Leaf Draft rookies offer collectors a prime opportunity to get in early on some of the newest prospects with superstar upside.
