The baseball card class of 1991 was one of the strongest for pitching prospects in the modern era. Upper deck and score racing to capture the next dynasty of future stars debuting at the major league level. While stars like Cal Ripken Jr. and Barry Bonds continued to establish themselves, a new crop of young arms was on the rise. The 1989, 1990 and 1991 drafts were pivotal in restocking farm systems with blue chip pitching talent ready to take center stage. Score was there documenting every step of the way with their rookie prospect issues in series one and two of 1991.
Leading the way was Ben McDonald, the number one pick from the 1989 draft by the Baltimore Orioles. His score rookie card showed promise of a true ace, depicted pitching with a powerful delivery. In his first full season of 1990, McDonald won 10 games in the minors before getting the call up to Baltimore late in the season. His first full MLB campaign in 1991 saw him win 13 games as a 22-year old with a promising future. An injury plagued career never lived up to the hype initially, but that 1991 score rookie card remains a key piece from the period.
Another arm generating excitement was Todd Van Poppel, selected 14th overall by the Oakland A’s in the 1990 draft. With a blazing fastball that touched triple digits on the radar gun, it was only a matter of time before he made his debut. His rookie card in score showed why he was coveted, with an intimidating stare down wind up. Van Poppel reached the majors late in 1990 but struggled with control issues. Bouncing between the minors and majors, he never fully delivered on expectations. Still, his rookie card endures as a snapshot of a pitcher with electric stuff that teased what could have been.
Pointer
One of the top international amateur signings of 1990 was Pedro Martinez from the Dominican Republic. Signed by the Los Angeles Dodgers as a 17-year old, his rookie card in score was among the earliest glimpses of the future hall of famer. While listed at just 145 pounds at the time, his delivery showed how that slight frame was deceiving with a high leg kick and whip like arm motion. After tearing up the low minors in his stateside debut season of 1990, Pedro was poised for stardom. Traded to Montreal before 1991, within three years he was an all-star with the Expos on his way to dominating MLB for over a decade. The 1991 score Pedro Martinez rookie card stands out as one of the best long term investments from the entire set.
While pitchers drew the most excitement, sluggers like Juan Gonzalez also had promising rookie cards. As an 18-year old signed by the Texas Rangers out of the Dominican Republic, his hulking physique and sweet left handed swing was evident on his 1991 score issue. Gonzales tore up A-Ball in 1990 with 23 home runs in just 84 games, announcing his power potential. Within two years he was in the majors to stay, launching tape measure home runs on the way to two MVP awards and over 450 career long balls. His card appealed to both prospectors and Latino baseball fans alike as a star was born.
Some other key prospect pitchers featured included David Cone (Blue Jays), Jimmy Key (Yankees), Frank Tanana, (Angels), Pat Rapp (Expos), Anthony Young (Mets), Greg Swindell (Indians), Mike Harkey (Padres). Each had promising rookie cards showing them in minor league or big league uniforms with stat lines hinting at MLB success to come. While not all panned out as planned, their inclusion captured the pipeline of new pitching talent entering the sport during baseball’s steroid and home run surge era in the 1990s and beyond.
Perhaps the biggest what if of the pitching focused 1991 score rookie prospect set could have been Bret Saberhagen of the Kansas City Royals. A two-time Cy Young winner and the 1985 World Series MVP by age 22, his inclusion in the set was a reminder of how dominant he already was by 1991 at just 26-years old. But arm injuries would slow his career progress and keep him from achieving the ace status his early prime suggested. Still, as the reigning AL Cy Young winner in 1989 and a pitching maven, his card embodied the promise any arm held as MLB refinements continued innovating.
Other hitters with aspirations of stardom featured included Felix Jose (Rangers), Raul Mondesi (Dodgers), Chuck Knoblauch (Twins). Each possessed the toolbox of abilities scouts covet, crafted nicely by the photography and design of score. While injury, expectations or adjustments may have altered careers; for a brief snapshot these cards captured dreamers chasing glory on the sports biggest stage. Reminding fans of the renewal process constant in baseball across generations, score 1991 rookie prospects were a special class forever imprinted on the sport.
The 1991 score rookie prospect set delivered exactly what investors and collectors hoped for. Dozens of future all-stars, hall of famers and enduring careers were unveiled. Pitchers predominated the checklist as clubs stockpiled arms for the demanding schedules of modern MLB. While natural fluctuations saw some bust while others excelled, the cards captured aspiration. Over 30 years later they remain a fond reminder of baseball`s eternal cycle and hope renewed with each new draft class. For engaging fun and profit potential alike, 1991 score rookie prospects were among the strongest offerings in the modern trading card boom era. Their legacy lives on whenever fans reminisce of stars beginnings.
