Heritage Auctions is one of the biggest auction houses when it comes to collecting sports memorabilia and trading cards. Each year they sell hundreds of millions of dollars worth of rare cards, autographed items, jerseys and more through both online and live auctions. Baseball cards make up a huge portion of their business and some truly amazing rare examples regularly sell for record prices.
Some of the most expensive baseball cards ever sold went through Heritage Auctions. In May 2016, they auctioned off what is considered the card holy grail – a 1909-11 T206 Honus Wagner that earned a PSA grade of 1. It had been part of the personal collection of the late NFL Hall of Famer Gerald Ford and his family since the 1960s. The winning bid was an astounding $3.12 million, setting a new record. It remains the most valuable trading card of all-time based on a single sale.
Other exceptionally rare Wagner cards have also sold big through HA. In 2013 they moved a PSA 2 copy for $2.1 million. Then in August 2018, another premier example rated as PSA NM-MT 8 sold for an impressive $1.32 million. The Wagner is truly in a league of its own when it comes to value but Heritage has moved other beloved vintage issues for seven figures too. In 2007, a mint condition 1913 Baltimore News Babe Ruth card brought a winning bid of $996,000.
Perhaps the most recognized vintage star after Wagner and Ruth is Mickey Mantle. When it comes to his 1952 Topps debut card, considered the finest known, Heritage played a major role in two record sales. In 1991 a PSA 5 copy traded privately for $50,000. Then in 2007 HA put the same card, now encased and graded PSA Gem Mint 9, on the block. The winning bid shattered expectations at $531,000. In 2016 they one-upped it again when another PSA 9.5 realized $525,000.
Rookie cards for other Yankee greats have also found new homes through Heritage. In February 2020, a PSA 8 1964 Topps Yogi Berra rookie brought $100,800. A PSA 8 1963 Topps Roger Maris rookie went for $83,200 in 2018. But it’s not just vintage cards that bring the big money. HA has become a destination for scarce modern issues too. In 2018, they sold a rare Stephen Strasburg 2009 Bowman Chrome Superfractor auto patch 1/1 for $49,800. That same sale featured a 1998 SP Authentic Mike Piazza Auto BGS 9.5 that hammered for $24,000.
Graded rookies for active players also do very well. In 2017, Heritage moved a BGS 9.5 2009 Bowman Draft Picks Paul Goldschmidt auto patch for $19,600. Later that year, a $15,000 bid won the auction for a 2011 Topps Chrome Mike Trout auto PSA 10. Graded Trout rookies in general are hugely sought after as Trout is considered by many to currently be the best player in baseball. In 2015, Heritage sold a flawless 2011 Topps Trout rookie PSA 10 for $24,960. And in 2018, an even rarer 2011 Bowman Sterling Mike Trout Auto refractor BGS 9.5 NM-MT sold for an immense $80,000.
Heritage also consistently achieves top dollar when rare complete sets change hands. In 2016, one collector took home a pristine complete run of 1933 Goudey Baseball cards, including the ultra prestigious Babe Ruth card, for $486,000. Years earlier in 2011, HA brought a jaw-dropping $478,400 for a near mint complete 1959 Topps set that featured stars like Willie Mays and Hank Aaron. But possibly their most impressive complete set auction occurred in 2006 when an extremely well-preserved 1918 M101-8 C5092 Sporting News Baseball Cards set, including the legendary Nap Lajoie Tobacco Card, sold for a phenomenal $2.8 million.
Of course, basketball, football, hockey, and non-sport cards also do remarkably well at Heritage Auctions. In 2015, they took home over $132,000 for a rare 1915 Cracker Jack Wilt Chamberlain Exhibit card. Two years later, the auction house earned nearly $28,000 off a 2006 SP Legendary Cuts Tom Brady Jersey Patch Autograph /1 BGS 9-9.5 GEM MINT. And in 2017, a near gem mint 1957 Topps #6 Bobby Hull hockey card changed hands for over $24,000 after some intense bidding. But baseball remains their bread and butter category due to the long history and tradition deeply embedded around the sport financially and culturally. With Heritage’s reputation, top memorabilia will continue drawing serious collectors there for years.
When a true one-of-a-kind baseball rarity, complete set, or investment grade single card hits the Heritage Auctions marketplace, world records are there for the taking. With deep pools of knowledgeable buyers, amazing items are often realized at prices once unimaginable to the collecting community. Heritage continues to showcase how valuable and appreciating vintage cards and related merchandise can become when consigned and sold through their premier auction house platform. They’ve certainly played a major role in shaping current reference prices for the category’s most coveted investment pieces.