Baseball cards have been a beloved hobby for generations, allowing fans to collect pieces of their favorite players and relive memories of America’s pastime. The city of Conway, Arkansas has long been a hub for baseball card collectors and dealers in the Natural State. Located just 30 minutes from Little Rock, Conway’s vibrant baseball card scene caters to collectors of all ages and interests.
Perhaps the most well-known baseball card shop in Conway is All Star Sports Cards, located in the Conway Commons shopping center along Highway 64. Owned and operated by lifelong baseball fan Bobby Langston, All Star Sports Cards has been a staple of the Conway baseball card community since 1990. Walking into the store is like stepping into a baseball museum, with walls lined from floor to ceiling with cards organized meticulously in plastic sleeves and binders. Bobby prides himself on having one of the most extensive vintage collections in the state, with rare rookie cards and autographed memorabilia spanning every era of Major League Baseball history.
All Star Sports Cards is a baseball card collector’s paradise, but it also serves the casual fan looking to build their first set or find a gift for a loved one. In addition to singles, the shop stocks all the latest card products from Topps, Panini, Leaf and more. Bobby and his knowledgeable staff are always happy to help new and experienced collectors alike find the cards they’re looking for. During baseball season, the shop becomes a lively hub for discussing the latest games and trades. All Star Sports Cards has nurtured generations of Conway-area baseball fans and built a culture of kindness and community among collectors.
While All Star Sports Cards caters to collectors of all ages and interests, Conway is also home to shops specializing in vintage cards. Located in a nondescript building along Oak Street, Timeless Treasures Vintage Sports Cards is run by Randy and Melissa Sims. Stepping into Timeless Treasures feels like a step back in time, with rows of dusty long boxes filled with treasures waiting to be discovered. Randy has been collecting cards since he was a boy in the 1960s and has amassed one of the finest vintage collections in the Midwest.
At Timeless Treasures, the focus is squarely on the early years of the hobby, from the late 1800s tobacco cards all the way through the 1970s. Randy takes pride in having some of the rarest and most coveted vintage cards in the country, including pre-war tobacco issues, vintage rookie stars, and oddball regional issues. His deep connections with collectors nationwide have allowed him to build what many consider the finest inventory of high-grade vintage anywhere. Serious vintage collectors from across the globe make pilgrimages to Conway just to dig through Randy’s trove, and many important collections have passed through his store over the years.
While All Star Sports Cards and Timeless Treasures attract collectors from far and wide, Conway’s local card scene is also thriving. Tucked away in the Conway Commons shopping center is Card Shack, a family-run shop owned by the Green family. At Card Shack, the focus is squarely on serving the needs of local collectors and fostering the next generation of the hobby. In addition to stocking all the latest products and singles, Card Shack hosts weekly Friday Night Magic drafts, Pokémon leagues, and youth baseball card tournaments.
On Saturdays from April through August, Card Shack transforms into a baseball card hotspot as locals gather to trade, play games and discuss the latest Arkansas Travelers minor league baseball action. The friendly atmosphere and community focus make Card Shack a special place for Conway-area collectors of all ages. Generations of local families have grown up frequenting Card Shack, keeping the hobby alive through close bonds developed over a shared love of cards, games and sports.
This is just a sampling of the vibrant baseball card scene found in Conway, Arkansas. With nationally renowned vintage shops and local favorites nurturing new collectors, the city serves as an oasis for hobbyists across the Midwest. Whether you’re a casual fan or serious collector, Conway offers a community and culture unlike any other for anyone with a passion for the cardboard wonders that have captured imaginations for over a century. The friendly faces and treasured collections waiting to be discovered make any baseball card lover feel right at home.
