The 1991 Topps baseball card set has produced many valuable collectors items over the decades. The designs and rookies featured in the 1991 Topps set made certain cards very desirable. As interest in vintage baseball cards has increased in recent years, prices for the top 1991 Topps cards have risen dramatically. Here’s a look at the 10 most valuable 1991 Topps baseball cards based on PSA 10 Gem Mint condition prices:
#10 – Ken Griffey Jr. (card #340)
Widely considered one of the best pure hitters of his generation, Ken Griffey Jr. had one of the sweetest left-handed swings in baseball history. His iconic uppercut stance and effortless power are what made him a fan favorite. Griffey’s rookie card in the 1991 Topps set has increased in value thanks to his stellar 22-year career and induction into the Baseball Hall of Fame. In a PSA 10 gem mint state, Junior’s rookie card can fetch $300-400.
#9 – Jeff Bagwell (card #398)
Jeff Bagwell burst onto the scene in 1991 with an impressive performance that won him the Rookie of the Year award. His MVP-caliber career and power numbers as a first baseman have made his rookie card very collectible. The condition sensitive 1991 Topps Bagwell rookie in a PSA 10 gem mint can sell between $400-$500.
#8 – Juan Gonzalez (card #547)
Nicknamed “Juan Gone” for his mammoth home runs, Juan Gonzalez made a huge impact in his rookie season with the Texas Rangers in 1991. He went on to win back-to-back AL MVP awards in 1996-1997. Gonzalez’s desirable rookie card has increased steadily in value and a PSA 10 version can sell for $500-600.
#7 – Chuck Knoblauch (card #352)
A slick-fielding second baseman, Chuck Knoblauch had exciting rookie campaign in 1991 where he showed power and speed that made him an All-Star. His smooth left-handed swing remained a fan favorite throughout his career. Knoblauch’s rookie card is a key Cardinals and Twins collectors item, with a PSA 10 grading bringing $600-700.
#6 – David Justice (card #322)
An athletic and powerful outfielder, David Justice enjoyed a productive career highlighted by two World Series titles with the Atlanta Braves. Justice’s debut 1991 Topps card increased in demand and a near-mint to mint PSA 9 copy can reach $700, with a pristine PSA 10 exceeding $800.
#5 – Will Clark (card #88)
One of the game’s most feared pure hitters in the late 1980s and early 1990s, Will Clark was the heart and soul of the San Francisco Giants teams. His sweet left-handed swing and five-time All-Star performances made his cards highly collectible. Clark’s flagship 1991 Topps card in a PSA 10 condition consistently crosses the $800-1000 sales range.
#4 – Donruss Frank Thomas (card #20T)
While not an official Topps product, the coveted 1991 Donruss Frank Thomas rookie card parallel to the Topps set ranks as one of the most iconic and valuable cards from that year. “The Big Hurt” went on to a Hall of Fame career and his rookie remains a holy grail for White Sox collectors. In a PSA 10 mint condition this rare Thomas rookie has reached auction prices over $2000.
#3 – Chipper Jones (card #512)
One of the greatest switch-hitters in baseball history, Chipper Jones was a career-long Atlanta Brave who won the 1999 NL MVP. His debut 1991 Topps rookie card gained increased popularity within the hobby and for elite PSA 10 examples, values have soared past the $2500 mark.
#2 – Derek Jeter (card #520)
As the longtime captain and shortstop of the New York Yankees dynasty, Derek Jeter’s iconic career and classy on-field demeanor made him one of the most beloved players in MLB history. His highly coveted 1991 Topps rookie card has become the holy grail for Yankee enthusiasts. A PSA 10 mint Jeter rookie recently reached a stunning $75,000 winning bid at auction.
#1 – Barry Bonds (card #520)
Holding the all-time home run record, Barry Bonds was undoubtedly one of the most gifted pure hitters in baseball annals. Throughout his widely debated steroid era, Bonds’ dominance captivated fans and his rookie card has always remained a highly invested collectible. Recently a pristine 1991 Topps Bonds rookie PSA 10 gem was purchased for a record-shattering $189,900 – cementing it as the most valuable single card from the entire set.
The 1991 Topps baseball set offers compelling rookie cards and investments for avid collectors over 30 years later. Headlined by modern legends like Griffey, Bonds and Jeter, these valuable vintage cards continue to increase in demand thanks to the historic players and careers commemorated within the set. With the hobby booming more than ever, the highest graded examples of these most sought-after 1991 rookies are sure to keep ascending to new record prices.
