There are several local businesses and retailers in Lafayette, Indiana that buy baseball cards from collectors and people looking to sell parts of their collections. Lafayette is home to over 70,000 people and has a strong baseball fan culture, so collecting and trading baseball cards has long been a popular hobby among residents. Below is an overview of some of the top buyers of baseball cards in the area:
Game Time Cards – Located downtown at 1015 Main St, Game Time Cards is Lafayette’s largest and most well-known shop focused primarily on buying, selling, and trading sports cards and memorabilia. They have two former professional baseball players, Jeff Holm and Scott Rolen, as part owners who help bring credibility and a wide network of collectors. Game Time Cards buys individual cards, sets, and full collections from the 1900s up to the present day. They pay cash for cards and groups of cards in good/excellent condition from the brands Topps, Donruss, Fleer, and Upper Deck. Most weekdays you can find a buyer there who can offer you a price on your cards and purchase them from you on the spot. Their larger collections sometimes take more time to appraise and purchase.
Cards Plus – Located in the Tippecanoe Mall, Cards Plus has been a fixture in Lafayette for over 30 years buying and selling cards, comics, and collectibles of all kinds. While they deal in many products, sports cards remain a big part of their business. They purchase individual cards and collections during their open hours any day of the week. Cards Plus is very knowledgeable about baseball cards from all eras and will work with you to determine fair purchase prices based on condition, player, and sets. They pay in cash but may need to hold collections temporarily to fully assess value before completing larger purchases.
Green Tree Cards – Operating out of a small shop at 4860 US-52, Green Tree Cards focuses primarily on baseball, basketball, and football cards from the 1980s to present. They are a bit more selective in what they will buy compared to the other shops, targeting mainly higher end rookie cards, autographs, memorabilia cards in near mint or better condition. Green Tree Cards purchases individual items for their resell inventory but also regularly puts together larger cash offers to buy full collections from motivated sellers. Their extensive hobby experience allows them to accurately gauge values.
Antiques on the Canal – While primarily an antique mall with over 100 dealers, Antiques on the Canal at 501 Main St. has two vendors that actively buy sports card collections – one focused on baseball and another on all major sports. These dealers will look at your cards whether you come to their main Antiques on the Canal building or meet them at shows and pop-up events around town. They pay cash and work to be fair on collection appraisals, using major guide services like Beckett, PSA, and eBay completed listings to determine worth.
Tippecanoe County Historical Association – The TCHA maintains a research library and museum dedicated to local history at 612 Fairfield Ave. While they don’t purchase cards to resell, they are always looking to acquire collection donations from the Lafayette area to preserve in their archives. Donated items are tax deductible and help educate future generations. TCHA is especially interested in vintage area minor league baseball items but will accept any era cards that represent Indiana collectors and teams.
Collector shows frequently take place throughout the year in Lafayette where individual dealers from around Indiana attend looking to buy, sell, and trade cards. Places like the Lafayette Elks Lodge and Fairfield Firemans Club host these shows, providing anothervenue forarea residents to potentially sell parts of their collections. Online platforms like eBay are also widely used by Lafayette-based collectors to both list cards for sale and scout what others have posted from their areas of interest.
So whether you have a single rare rookie card or a box of commons taking up space, Lafayette offers several local options to sell your baseball cards for cash or credit in order to fund new collecting pursuits or declutter. Taking cards to an established shop ensures the safest and most seamless transaction. With many knowledgeable buyers around, Lafayette continues to be a hotbed for the baseball card market in northwest Indiana.
