Card Collectibles – This shop has two locations, one in Rockville Centre on Long Island and another in Massapequa. They have been in business for over 25 years and are a trusted buyer and seller of sports and non-sports cards. They do individual evaluations and will make you a cash offer on your collection. They have a very large inventory of vintage cards for sale as well.
Long Island Sports Card Exchange – Located in Westbury, this shop has been buying and selling cards since 1989. They specialize in vintage cards from the 1950s-1980s and will pay cash for your cards after assessing the condition and value. They host frequent card shows and tournaments throughout the year.
Stadium Sports Cards – With stores in Brooklyn, Queens, and Long Island, Stadium Sports Cards is one of the top retailers in the New York area. They buy individual cards or full collections and will pay reasonably based on today’s market values. They have an online database to help you lookup estimates as well before bringing your cards in for evaluation.
Robert Edward Auctions – For higher end and valuable collections, Robert Edward Auctions is a good option. They are an auction house based in New Jersey that runs live and online sports memorabilia auctions. They will accept individual vintage cards, complete sets, or entire collections for consignment. After the auction, you will receive a check for your items less any commission fees.
Sportscards Plus – Located in Armonk, New York, this shop has been in business for over 30 years. They buy and sell all trading cards but have an expertise in vintage baseball, football, and basketball cards from the 1970s-1990s. They pay cash for individual cards and collections.
Heroes & Legacies – Owned and operated by a former professional baseball player, this shop is focused solely on sports collectibles including cards, autographs, signed photos and jerseys. They have a physical location in Wayne, New Jersey and will meet you elsewhere in the tri-state area as well to appraise valuable items and complete transactions.
Lelands – For truly high-end vintage cards graded NM-MT condition or rarer items, you may want to consign with Lelands. They are an auction house and dealer that specializes in vintage sports memorabilia valued at $1000 or more. They charge commissions but market items to an international buyer base.
Online Auctions – For those uncomfortable meeting in-person during the pandemic, eBay, Heritage Auctions, and Goldin Auctions are reputable online marketplaces. Condition is crucial so learn photography tips, carefully describe items, and let competitive bidding set the price rather than accepting low offers. You may net less than from a local shop but have access to many qualified buyers.
Sports Card Conventions – Browse card shows and festivals held throughout the Northeast. Shop owners may be open to buying on location. Larger annual events include the Cardinal Collectibles Super Show in White Plains and Tri-State Sports Collectibles Show in New Jersey. You can network with dealers and gauge interest in your collection.
When selecting where to sell your baseball cards in NYC or nearby areas, consider factors like the size of your collection, its overall condition and value, your comfort level with online versus in-person transactions, and your priority on maximizing profit versus a quick sale. Going to established local shops is probably your safest bet for fair offers on individual cards or groups. For rarer items, auctions may net a higher return. With diligent research, collectors have many viable options.
