Yogi Berra is widely regarded as one of the greatest catchers in Major League Baseball history and one of the finest leaders the New York Yankees have ever had. Berra played nearly his entire 19-year MLB career with the Yankees from 1946 to 1963, winning a record 10 World Series championships. His witty sayings like “It’s déjà vu all over again” have endured for decades. Given his legendary status in baseball, it’s no surprise that Yogi Berra baseball cards have significant collectible value and fans still eagerly seek them out.
One of the top destinations to find coveted Yogi Berra cards available for purchase is COMC, or Cards On Mission Control. COMC is a massive online marketplace featuring over 250 million trading cards, sports memorabilia, and other collectibles. On any given day, they typically have hundreds of different Yogi Berra cards across all grades and years listed for sale from numerous individual collectors and dealers.
Among the most desired and valuable Yogi Berra cards that can be found on COMC are the following:
1951 Bowman #61 – Berra’s first true rookie card was issued this year by Bowman. In the lowest grade of Poor-1, this key card still fetches $200-300. Higher gradedNear Mint to Mint examples can sell for $1,000 and up depending on centering and condition.
1954 Topps #126 – Berra looks back over his shoulder in this iconic card image from his prime playing days. Low grade copies are $50-100 but Mint condition versions have reached $800+ at auction.
1956 Topps #258 – Widely considered one of Berra’s best and most iconic baseball cards visually. Even well-worn copies in Poor grade sell for $150-250. Near Mint+ copies often trade hands for $500-800.
1960 Topps #5 – Berra is framed perfectly centered in this later issue card showing him at age 35. Low grade copies are $40-60 while high grade Mints can demand $300-500.
1962 Topps #12 – Berra’s second-to-last individual card from his playing career. Low grade versions are $30-50 but a sharp Mint example recently sold for just under $400.
1963 Topps #369 – Berra’s true “final card” as an active player at age 38. Again, $30-50 in rougher shape but mid-grade examples have sold for $150-250.
1987 Topps Tiffany #TT4 – This special higher-end Tiffany set issue features Berra in a unique color photo from his post-playing days. Even well-worn copies pull $100-150 given the set’s prestige.
COMC typically plays host to many graded Yogi Berra rookie cards as well. A 1951 Bowman PSA 6 is currently listed around $600 while a PSA 8 would reach $2,000-3,000. High grade PSA/SGC NM-MT 8s of his 1954 Topps, 1956 Topps, and 1960 Topps #5 cards are all priced over $1,000 as well on the site.
Yogi Berra autograph cards on COMC are naturally even more valuable opportunities. Some of the highlights would be a 1995 Upper Deck SP Autograph which is priced in the $1,000 range or a 1998 Fleer Greats SuperScripts Auto that is listed around $1,500 currently. An ultra-rare 1973 Topps Yogi Berra autograph card just sold for an incredible $22,500 on COMC back in September 2021.
For dedicated Yogi Berra collectors, COMC consistently has affordable raw copies and graded gems to choose from across his entire playing career. Searching the site daily is worthwhile as new consignments are continually being added. With Berra’s beloved status in New York and status as a baseball icon, his classic cards hold value remarkably well over decades. COMC proves to be the leading online marketplace for finding Yogi Berra cardboard to add to any collection.
