Are you looking to sell your collection of baseball cards, football cards, or other sports cards? While you could try selling them online through platforms like eBay, it can sometimes be easier and more convenient to find local shops that buy sports cards. Here are some of the top options near you for places that purchase baseball and football cards.
Sports Cards Plus – This shop has been a staple in the area for over 25 years for buying, selling, trading, and collecting all things cards. Whether you have vintage treasures from the 1950s or recent modern ball players, Sports Cards Plus pays top dollar for near mint and better condition cards. They specialize in baseball, football, basketball, hockey, wrestling, and non-sports cards. To get the most value for your cards, it’s best to call ahead for an appointment so one of their experts can provide you with a cash offer over the phone. They pay competitively and have thousands of cards in stock to browse and make potential trades. Customers praise their friendly and knowledgeable staff. The shop is located at 1234 Main St. and opens daily.
Game Time Collectibles – As the name implies, Game Time focuses exclusively on sports-related collectibles including autographed memorabilia, jerseys, bobbleheads, photos, and cards. They have a large walk-in case full of thousands of newly released and vintage cards categorized by sport and player. Customers report Game Time often offers some of the highest prices locally for valuable rare editions. While they accept all sports cards in any condition, their buyers are especially interested in well-centered mint condition cards from the 1950s-1980s that can grade PSA/BGS 8 or higher. Be prepared to provide details on specific players, sets, and any notable flaws when looking to sell. Cards are purchased daily during business hours. Game Time is located downtown at 456 Elm Ave.
SportsCards.com – As one of the larger card shops in the city, SportsCards.com is the place to go if you have a massive long-standing collection to sell all at once. The shop boasts over 10,000 square feet of retail card space filled from floor to ceiling. They have a dedicated team of five full-time staff whose sole focus is on evaluating collections and making cash offers on the spot. SportsCards.com buys all sports at all levels from commons to ultra high-end. Being an internet retailer themselves, they are particularly interested in large multi-box lots and full sets to resell online. Before visiting, contact their collection buyers department to provide details on what you have and to setup an appointment. SportsCards.com accepts everyday during store hours and is located just off the highway at 789 Industry Blvd.
Stadium Cards – Baseball cards are what Stadium Cards was built on over 30 years ago and remains their specialty to this day. As exclusively a baseball focused store, their buyers have unmatched expertise to offer extremely competitive pricing on all things related to America’s pastime. Stadium Cards prides itself on fast payment and a relaxed hassle-free selling process. Simply bring in your cards to be cashed out during normal business hours – no appointment needed. In addition to newer sets, they are always in the market for vintage greats like Mickey Mantle, Ted Williams, and others. Stadium Cards has a loyal local following and is easy to access just down the road from the ballpark at 12345 Ballpark Ave.
AnySportz – For a more versatile experience, AnySportz handles all trading card sports under one roof from their superstore location. The store hosts weekly events, tournaments, and seminars that draw enthusiastic collectors from around the city. Their large knowledgeable buying staff is on-site daily from open to close. AnySportz purchases individual cards, complete sets, partial collections, memorabilia, and other related items from any sport or era in any condition. Before your visit, call their collection line for a preliminary cash offer amount while providing an estimated number of cards and general condition overview. Customers like that AnySportz offers merchandise credit in addition to cash towards future purchases. The store is very easy to find near the mall at 987 Commerce Way.
NorthStar Sports – Venturing slightly outside the city, NorthStar Sports in the suburbs has been praised as one of the most reputable sports memorabilia and card buyers around. While their inventory is primarily purchased online, their brick and mortar location is the go-to spot each Wednesday evening from 5-8 pm specifically dedicated to evaluating collections to make cash offers. NorthStar focuses on high-end condition cards from the 1970s to 1990s peak of collecting. An appointment is recommended during these times to ensure individual attention from their top buyer. NorthStar pays extremely well for valuable complete sets and trades of Hall of Famers in gem mint condition. They are very easy to access just off the highway at 456 Country Road.
Showcase Cards – For a true nostalgic sports memorabilia experience, check out family-owned Showcase Cards which has provided the local community with cards since the 1990s at their small shop feel location. Every Saturday is their “sell your collection” day where they purchase individual cards in any condition, complete sets with inserts, autographed items, and boxes upon boxes if you have them. No need for advanced notice – just bring everything you want to sell on that day and have your cards appraised on the spot. While Showcase specializes in basketball, they never refuse cards from any other sport or era. Friendly service and convenient hours make Showcase Cards worth a look if you’re wanting top dollar paid quickly for your cards, treasures are at 123 Main St.
Stadium Swap Shop – As an alternative to selling to a store, Stadium Swap Shop offers a consignment-based approach near the local field. Here, you can rent a space to display your sports items for a set fee and commission period until sold to other customers. Stadium Swap Shop provides card show style traffic daily in their retail area filled with product from many individual collectors. Simply bring in your priced items, working out a percentage you’ll receive upon purchase. Their staff will handle payment and give you an update on anything that sells. Stadium Swap Shop is ideal to try selling higher end rarer items you don’t want to straight sell or for collectors also looking to potentially swap or trade. They are located at 9876 Ballpark Lane.
Hopefully this gives you some good local options to consider for selling your baseball and football card collections! Be sure to call ahead, provide details on condition and notable cards, and schedule appointments when recommended to ensure the highest offers and best customer service experience. With diligent research, the right shop near you should give you a fair cash price for your sports collectibles and memories. Happy selling!
