In 1991, Donruss released an iconic set of Major League Baseball All-Star playing cards. The 36-card set celebrated the top players in the American League and National League at the halfway point of the 1991 season. The cards featured colorful yet traditionally-styled designs that proved very popular with collectors at the time.
Each card in the 1991 MLB All-Star set featured an action photo of an All-Star player from that season on the front, with stats and career highlights on the back. The 36 players in the set were chosen based on fan voting and player performance from the first half of the 1991 baseball season. Some of the biggest stars of the early 1990s are prominently featured, such as Terry Pendleton, Roberto Aguirre, Dennis Eckersley, and Kenny Lofton.
Some notable player cards in the 1991 MLB All-Star set include Barry Bonds’ card, which featured a close-up action shot of the Pirates outfielder at bat. The back discussed Bonds’ impressive start to the 1991 season and his 5 All-Star selections at that point in his career. Another memorable card was Roberto Alomar’s card, showing the Blue Jays second baseman fielding a ground ball. His card details how he was enjoying a breakout offensive season in 1991 where he led the AL in batting average.
The cards also captured smaller, unheralded All-Stars like Jeff Reardon, Charlie Hayes, and Scott Sanderson. Reardon’s Twins card highlighted his 230 career saves to that point. Hayes’ Pirates card lauded his strong defensive play at third base. And Sanderson’s Expos card praised his surprise 14-4 record and AL-leading 2.23 ERA for Montreal at the midway point. These types of role players made the comprehensive All-Star set more interesting for collectors.
Some key production details of the 1991 MLB All-Star card set included the traditional pink backs commonly used by Donruss at the time. The fronts featured colorful team logo designs with yellow, red, and blue borders framing the black-and-white photos. Set numbers ranged from 1 to 36 and included each player’s primary team logo. The card stock was sturdy and held up well to the friction of being repeatedly shuffled in collectors’ hands.
Distribution of the 1991 MLB All-Star cards was strong, as Donruss had major mass-market retail deals in place with stores like Walmart, Kmart, and Target. This allowed the cards to reach collectors across the country. The large national chains stocked entire racks full of Donruss baseball cards each spring and summer. Savvy collectors could reliably find unopened packs and boxes of the All-Star cards well into the baseball season at major retail outlets.
While not quite as collectible or valuable today as the iconic rookie cards from the same era, the 1991 MLB All-Star cards remain a unique and historically significant release. They captured the midseason stars and state of the game from one of the biggest seasons of the 1990s. Unlike modern All-Star card sets that focus only on that one game’s rosters, this Donruss release spanned both leagues and offered profiles of the top AL and NL players at the season’s halfway point. For baseball card collectors and historians, it continues to serve as a fun time capsule of the summer of 1991.
In the years since their release, the condition of the 1991 MLB All-Star cards has varied greatly based on how many times each was handled and tossed around in circulation. Gem mint specimens with sharp corners and clean surfaces can still fetch $10-15 per card individually on auction sites. But well-loved, played-with examples are more commonly available raw for under $5 each. Either way, the collectible and nostalgic appeal of this classic 36-card All-Star set endures as a historic relic from baseball card publishing’s peak popularity period in the early 1990s.
