Cincinnati has a long history with baseball and as a result, there are many local shops and collectors in the area interested in buying baseball cards. Whether you have a large collection you want to sell or just a few rare cards, here are some of the top options for selling your baseball cards in the Cincinnati area.
Sportscards Plus – Located in Blue Ash, Sportscards Plus is one of the largest and most well-established card shops in the Cincinnati area. They have over 30 years of experience buying and selling sports cards of all types. They have a huge inventory of cards for sale and also actively buy collections from individuals. They pay cash on the spot for cards and have knowledgeable staff that can help you get fair prices for your cards. Their large store makes it easy to showcase large collections.
Sports Collectibles – This shop in West Chester has a strong reputation for fair prices when buying cards from sellers. While they don’t pay top dollar, you can feel confident you won’t get lowballed either. They have a simple process where you can bring your cards in, get an offer, and complete the sale quickly if you accept. They are always looking to add to their inventory, so this is a reliable option if you just want to liquidate your collection easily.
Dave and Adam’s Card World – Located in Blue Ash, Dave and Adam’s is one of the largest card shops in the Midwest. While their primary focus is on selling cards, they do purchase collections as well. They have the expertise to properly value even the most unique and rare cards. You’ll want to call ahead to schedule an appointment if you have a large collection to sell. They pay some of the highest prices in the area but are also very discerning buyers.
Card Shack – This small but well-reviewed shop in Montgomery has been a staple of the local card scene for decades. While they don’t have the buying power of the bigger stores, they offer a more personal experience. The owner has an encyclopedic knowledge of the hobby and takes the time to ensure fair prices. They specialize in vintage cards from the 50s-80s era and will pay a premium for the right cards.
Card Collector Shop – Located in Blue Ash, this shop has a strong online presence as well as their local storefront. They are very active buyers who pay cash for large and small collections alike. While they don’t offer the highest prices, their convenient location, fast payment, and fair offers make them a reliable option. They are always looking to source new inventory, so you can feel confident they will make you a competitive offer.
Auctions – If you have truly high-end vintage cards graded PSA/BGS 10 or game-used memorabilia, an auction may net the highest prices. Goldin Auctions and Heritage Auctions both handle major sports collectibles auctions. You’ll need to consign your items, but the exposure of an online auction can find a top bidder worldwide. Local auction houses like J.P. Riley and Sons in Cincinnati may also accept consignments of valuable cards and memorabilia.
Online Sales – Selling online through platforms like eBay is an option, but it involves more work listing items and handling shipping. You also have to deal with occasional problem buyers. For the right rare cards, you can get the highest market value, but common cards may not sell. Sites like COMC allow you to more easily sell large volumes of cards at a base price, letting the site handle the work.
When selling in Cincinnati, having cards in top condition is important. Higher grades from certification services like PSA and BGS can unlock much higher values. Be sure to do research on recent sold prices so you know the real worth of your collection. With the many local shops and auction options, Cincinnati collectors have several reliable avenues for getting top dollar for their sports card collections.
