The 1995 Upper Deck Collector’s Choice baseball card set holds a special place in the world of sports collecting. Released at the height of the trading card boom in the mid-1990s, the Collector’s Choice cards featured premium quality cardboard, photography, and designs that made them stand out among the sea of new baseball card releases each year. While most sets from that era have lost significant value over time, many of the rarest and most sought-after 1995 Collector’s Choice cards have retained and even increased in worth due to their low print runs and the superstar players featured on the fronts.
Perhaps the most iconic and valuable card from the 1995 Collector’s Choice set is the Ken Griffey Jr. rookie card. Often considered one of the greatest players of his generation, Griffey was already well on his way to legendary status by 1995 withseveral All-Star and Gold Glove awards to his name in just his first few MLB seasons with the Seattle Mariners. His Upper Deck rookie card, featuring superb action photography of “The Kid” in his signature follow-through batting stance, has long been viewed as one of the crown jewels of the collector’s card hobby. What makes the Griffey Collector’s Choice rookie even more rare is that it was only inserted in hobby boxes at an extremely low rate of 1:96 packs. As a result, graded mint condition examples often fetch tens of thousands of dollars when they surface for auction.
Another record-holding 1995 Collector’s Choice card is the Derek Jeter rookie. As the longtime captain and shortstop for the dynastic Yankee teams of the late 90s-2000s, Jeter cemented himself as not just a star but a true icon of America’s pastime. His stellar rookie season helped kick off an eventual Hall of Fame career. Much like Griffey, Jeter’s Collector’s Choice rookie was scarce, appearing around 1:120 packs. High grade Gem Mint Jeter rookies have broken the $100,000 price barrier in recent years, evidence of his enduring popularity and the rarity of this specific cardboard issue.
Superstar pitchers also made their Collector’s Choice rookie debuts in 1995. Randy Johnson, nicknamed “The Big Unit” for his imposing 6’10 frame and 100 mph fastball, was already in his 7th MLB season but had yet to emerge as the dominant force he would become. As a result, his 1995 Collector’s Choice rookie remains one of his key early vintage cardboard issues. Likewise, Pedro Martinez debuted with the Los Angeles Dodgers in 1995 and showed flashes of the brilliance that would lead to three Cy Young Awards. Both the Johnson and Martinez rookies were also quite scarce pulls from Collector’s Choice packs. Top-graded versions often sell for over $10,000 when they surface.
In addition to future Hall of Fame players, the 1995 Collector’s Choice set featured cards of current and past baseball greats. For example, an near-mint condition Ken Griffey Sr. “Father & Son” insert card which features a photo of both Ken Griffey Sr. and Jr. side by side sold for $15,619 at auction in September 2021. The card has additional rarity and popularity due to the family connection between the two all-star outfielders.Similarly, iconic stars like Cal Ripken Jr., Tony Gwynn, Barry Bonds, and Greg Maddux had spectacular “Best Of” parallel inserts in Collector’s Choice highlighting some of their top career accomplishments at that point. These parallel inserts, found around 1:4 packs, have attained considerable value in the secondary market.
While stars drive the high-end prices, the 1995 Collector’s Choice base set also features many other key rookie cards and early-career issues that remain affordable for most collectors. For example, Jim Edmonds, Troy Percival, and Bobby Higginson all made their debuts and went on to enjoy productive MLB tenures. Prospects like Ben Grieve, Paul Konerko, and Aaron Boone had cards that have grown in nostalgic value. Workhorse veterans like Mark McGwire, Bret Saberhagen, and Dennis Eckersley lent their star power to the release as well. This breadth of MLB talent over 650+ cards made 1995 Collector’s Choice highly coveted during the trading card boom.
Whether chasing superstars or completing the set, the 1995 Upper Deck Collector’s Choice baseball cards still fascinate collectors today with brilliant photography, premium production, and a who’s who of baseball greats. While the Griffey Jr. and Derek Jeter rookies remain truly unobtainable for all but the deepest of pockets, others cards from the set surprisingly hold steady and have even increased in price due to the recognition of players like Randy Johnson and Pedro Martinez in Cooperstown. For collectors and investors alike, the retrospective lure of 1990s sports cards and stable value of the Collector’s Choice releases continue to make this one of the most iconic baseball sets ever produced.
